3 ms·
Unlike Intel ME, these are all possible to secure in principle. You can replace a vulnerable piece of hardware. You can limit memory and bus access using IOMMU
by AstralStorm 9y ago
Unlike Intel ME, these are all possible to secure in principle.
You can replace a vulnerable piece of hardware. You can limit memory and bus access using IOMMU.
You can run the drivers in a locked down virtual machine.
You can theoretically reverse engineer a driver if required.
None of this is possible with Intel ME. Similar with SMM blobs, but these are optional. Firmware is replaceable in at least theory with something like coreboot, and if not, you still have multiple options on various mainboards.
- ksk 9y agoWell, I do see a distinction between 'ME has bugs', and 'ME is designed to be insecure and allow remote takeover'. From what I have read, ME requires provisioning to be enabled. Even the so called 'zero touch' provisioning requires you to first reboot the machine, then run a special DHCP server that sends out an Intel certificate. An attacker would have to forge this certificate, which has to be limited to the domain the specific computer exists in, get physical access to the network to run a DHCP server, reboot the machine, and then be able to provision it (if at all).