9 ms·
Spend, spend, spend: shop till you drop mentality. If you think malls are only about consumerism then you've misunderstood a big part of their appeal for a lot
by onion2k 9y ago
Spend, spend, spend: shop till you drop mentality.
If you think malls are only about consumerism then you've misunderstood a big part of their appeal for a lot of people. Young people and groups of friends don't go to the mall on their own. Malls merge consumerism with social activity - they're for people who enjoy shopping with their friends.
If that's not you then fair enough, but don't disparage malls simply because they don't appeal to you. If they disappear society will be worse for many, many people.
- craftyguy 9y ago> Young people and groups of friends don't go to the mall on their own. Malls merge consumerism with social activity - they're for people who enjoy shopping with their friends. I don't think this has been true, at least in the US, since the 1990s.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoAt our local mall, there's a sign warning that under 18 aren't allowed without adults. They also removed much of what would attract teens and that age group. And many of the "older person stores" are ridiculously priced. Amazon, Walmart online, Aliexpress, and others are cheaper. Malls are full of expensive stuff, not very good stuff, and caters to nobody in particular. I know for us, it's because "Payless Shoes" that has cheap size 15's is the only reason why. So we beeline in, and out.
- jsight 9y agoI agree. It feels like a lot of malls have basically optimized themselves for a customer base that is not really sustainable.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoIndeed. I know it's changed a ton since I grew up in the '80s. I remember Spaceport and Aladin's castle. .25$ arcades, and $1 gave 5 tokens. You could play for hours just on $5. And they allowed kids, competitions, and all sorts of things. I'd go hang out while my parents were shopping, and just chill. There also used to be, in quite a lot of the malls, a jungle gym or playground area. They'd be full of kids, and you could just chill and hang out, except for free. But there were usually age limits so you didn't hurt little ones. And around this was always a common area. Lots of tables, food places, coffee shop or 2. Clubs and nonprofits would meet here - it was a huge commons area. I remember fondly playing chess on chess club nights. Played some pretty awesome pros there. And the companies there.. You had Sears, Estee Lauder, Nordstrom, and all those big name box stores. And then you'd have all sorts of smaller stores scattered, with rarely ever any room left over (1-2 empty plots due to eventual turnover). But there was something for everyone. Maybe it was a candy store, or a toy store, or specialty thing. That's all changed. Arcades are gone. Yeah, there's one 35 miles away from me, in the next city over. The jungle gyms and playgrounds were deemed dangerous and unsupervised, so they were decommissioned. You know, for "safety". And those tables? Yeah, those only encourage bums and lazy people to congregate, so they're right out. And those clubs? Yeah, they need to pay rent if they want to have a group, so they too were summarily kicked out (Well.. it is private property :/ ). And now with less people, those food vendors started closing. That coffee shop had not enough customers and moved/closed. The rest of the food vendors (whom you've never heard of), now started skimping hard and jacking the prices. And that's not to add in the compounding issues with online stores. A single online store can house millions of products. No real retailer can do that. So, you see the big box stores being squeezed by both the malls running people out, higher prices than online, and better selection than online. So, they end up closing and going bankrupt. It's not any one fault here, but a compound effect that set these things in motion. For me, its that single shoe place. I make a point to park at the closest place to get in, try on shoes, and get out. There's nothing else here for me. And clothing is really the last bastion of something you really should be in person for - cause sending back stuff sucks.
- replicatorblog 9y agoIn my town (Southern NH) the local Simon Mall actually solicits clubs. My wife's "Mom's Club" is offered freebies to host events there. E.g. they'll comp a photo package with Santa in the winter knowing that it'll get 30 middle-class moms in and shopping.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoI wish our local mall would do that. I've asked, and they just flatly say no. They're already suffering pretty bad with quite a few storefronts abandoned. I think our paper said something like 20% are empty. It'd only be a small amount of electricity used, and a bit of janitors they already have. They could pull in a few non-profit groups doing fun stuff (game club, moms club as you said, techie club, etc.) and drum up foot traffic and business. But given the doom-and-gloom article after article, I'm guessing they're looking for as many ways to cut costs as possible. I figure our mall has a few years left. There's enough shops like "Lidz", candy stores, some weird smelly pet store, the usual 16-21 girly clothing stores, the goth store (spencers), a Target, and a few others. But the life's certainly being drained out step by step.
- jtmcmc 9y agoI had a birthday party at an aladdin's castle!
- VLM 9y agoMall security is what is unsustainable. I'm old by HN standards gen-X and I grew up with mall security hating me. Now mall security has under 18 kids arrested, which is worse. The point is for decades of formative years "the mall is that place where they hate me because of who I am". So its understandable that now that I'm in their prime demographic (older, financially well off) that I have no interest in going there. You'd have to be older than gen-x to remember malls favorably as a teen. The place to socialize is/was high school sports in (ahem, under) the stands, and darkly lit movie theaters. Since the 80s, which is a long time ago, trying to hang out at the mall will get you kicked out by rentacops or arrested. Another problem is the dead mall death spiral has no backwards movement, can only ratchet toward death. The closest mall to me went 95% womens clothing stores a long time ago and is now on the march toward having its sixth athletic shoe store. Its a one way path to foreclosure, like a diode action only moving one way. I don't buy womens clothes, so other than taking my wife or daughter there, its already dead to me... Its interesting that when I was a kid the mall provided the novelty of everything under one roof. Then big box stores happened and there is no appeal to lots of little box stores under one roof when I can just go to Target or Walmart. Walmart today is the early 80s mall of my youth.
- pm90 9y agoI think you make a lot of good points. Not having grown up in the US, I don't have an immediate aversion towards malls. And as a guy who loves fashion, malls offer me a way to checkout a whole bunch of different styles, which is worth the slightly higher prices (at least for me anyways). Besides, they do have sales when the prices are somewhat better. But even I have embraced online stores. Every major fashion brand has an online store, and its just much too convenient to order online rather than have to drive to a mall etc.etc. I would rather, read a book or hang out with friends over a beer. Which brings me to an excellent observation you made: most stores in malls are reorienting to serve more women. I think women love the social aspects of shopping (i.e. trying out new clothes with friends and getting their opinions) as much as the actual shopping itself, which is probably why many women continue to go to malls. I think Malls are missing out on some great opportunities to be entertainment centers. They get the footfall; instead of orienting towards selling shit, they should be trying to provide some kind of experience.
- logfromblammo 9y agoEspecially since a lot of malls intentionally made themselves unfriendly to students in high school and college in order to cater more to young families and affluent people. They are hoist on their own petard, because as it turns out, the young families chose the big box stores to save money, and the affluent people are not numerous enough or consumerist enough to support more than one mall in their town. That mall gets the Brookstones and Sephoras and Victoria's Secrets and the Apple Stores. The other malls are full of basically nothing but cell phone vendor kiosks and a food court, and they die. Malls made an intentional decision to push shopping over social activity, and killed their appeal, because you can shop from anywhere by using your phone, and 99% of what you want comes from a combination of your grocery store, big box store (possibly the same as your grocery store), and online shopping. There is now no reason whatsoever to physically travel to any mall in the US. They have only lame chain restaurants, the Borders/Waldenbooks has been closed for decades, the good music store closed and only the corporate sellout store remains, the Radio Shack is gone, Sears left, JCPenney is kaput, but you have plenty of stores that sell "fashion" to teen girls, including the ubiquitous Express, Justice, Forever 21, and Hot Topic. So the mall is where your mom takes you when the clothes at Wal-Mart, Target, or Kohl's aren't good enough any more. I think if malls had gone the other direction, perhaps by adding mid-size under-21 live music venues as anchors, they would not be falling apart today.
- ghaff 9y agoYou touch on one of the key points toward the end. Many of the traditional anchor stores are dead or dying and there are very few newer candidates healthy enough to take their place.
- xeromal 9y agoGo to a mall on the weekend and tell me. Maybe the malls are dying in dead cities, but they're booming in LA who already has plenty of mom and pop shops too. Both are thriving.
- colmvp 9y agoSome of the malls in the GTA are doing quite well too, but I've noticed most of them are going upscale.
- sanderjd 9y agoI'm not a sociologist, but my feeling is that malls are just a last resort place for young people to socialize that is unstructured and free of charge. That is: there isn't really anywhere else to go be with your friends without paying for the privilege, that isn't organized by adults (like school sports or church groups for instance). When I was growing up, we had the mall and we had parking lots, and the latter was only for the "bad kids". I get the sense that kids nowadays just hang out with each other online more as a replacement.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gbacon 9y agoA recent video called “Why The Kids Need Stranger Things”[0] made exactly this point about the nostalgia of the Netflix series and how malls were a symbol of free-range kids[1]. Circumstances have changed so much that the creators assert Stranger Things could not be set in the present day. [0]: https://youtu.be/qHl-BQXYg3s https://youtu.be/qHl-BQXYg3s [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-range_parenting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-range_parenting
- fsloth 9y agoThat's so weird. We in northern europe have no problem in letting our kids roam (Finland, but I presume the situation is similar in at least scandinavia).
- ForRealsies 9y agoWhat is a homogeneous culture, Trebek.
- telchar 9y agoForgive me, but it seems that you're taking a common argument (X policy that works in Scandinavia won't work in the US because the US isn't homogeneous) and extending it to some sort of xenophobic dog-whistle (i.e. kids in the US can't roam because the US isn't homogeneous). Is there a more charitable way to interpret your comment?
- itswhateverman2 9y agoI think you misunderstand. Malls only end up as a social gathering spot when there's nowhere else to go. And even then, that only really appeals to teenagers who have nothing else to do. A mall would never be preferable to what was mentioned above, a downtown with brick paths and quality scenery/stores, etc.
- brandonmenc 9y ago> A mall would never be preferable to what was mentioned above, a downtown with brick paths and quality scenery/stores, etc. Sounds great, until it snows.
- foobarian 9y agoWell nobody said the alternative has to be outdoors, that's just the OP. It could be a community center with arcades and playgrounds and what not.
- itswhateverman2 9y agoSo you just don't go outside when it snows? Snow does not stop me from running errands to any other regular store that has an outdoor entrance. I don't understand how this is an argument.
- heimidal 9y agoNever? I certainly prefer a mall over a nice outdoor space (which I have available to me) when it’s freezing outside with a sheen of ice covering everything.
- itswhateverman2 9y agoSure, it's convenient when the weather is bad. That still doesn't make malls a staple of social activity, which was the point I was arguing against.
- heimidal 9y ago
- astura 9y agoHow young? Many malls have banned people under 18 unless accompanied by a parent or guardian. This practice started around 10 years ago. Just in case anyone doubts me: http://www.parenting.com/news-break/why-your-teen-getting-banned-mall http://www.parenting.com/news-break/why-your-teen-getting-ba... >Up to 80 malls across the United States enforce a curfew or escort policy for teenagers I was still looking young in 2008 despite being well into my 20s and that's when I got IDed at a mall entrance. I was so annoyed/insulted by it I never went back to that mall every again. I can understand getting IDed at a bar, but not at a friggin mall.
- lithos 9y agoI learned to hate malls in the same way.
- BadCookie 9y agoYour story reminded me of when I went on a cruise for my honeymoon. There was a cruise employee who gave my new husband and me a stern warning about how we should not be on the cruise without our parents if we were under 18. (We were in our mid-20s.) So much of society today wants to keep people dependent on their parents forever, it seems.
- wahern 9y agoI think it's more the case that roving gangs of teenagers put adults on edge. And for good reason. When you put 5 or 10 of the most conscientious teenagers together, collectively they're like a bull in a china shop. Adults aren't much better, but they're much less energetic unless they've been drinking.
- greeneggs 9y ago> Up to 80 malls across the United States enforce a curfew or escort policy for teenagers If you follow the link, the more accurate quote is [1] > Close to 80 malls in the U.S. have some type of curfew or escort policy regarding teenagers Having a policy is different from enforcing it, and a curfew policy is quite different from an escort policy, so who knows what this really means? Time writes, citing Credit Suisse, that there are about 1100 malls in the US today [2], so this might still be fairly rare. [1] https://www.yahoo.com/news/teens-are-getting-banned-from-malls-107347372697.html https://www.yahoo.com/news/teens-are-getting-banned-from-mal... [2] http://time.com/4865957/death-and-life-shopping-mall/ http://time.com/4865957/death-and-life-shopping-mall/
- drak0n1c 9y agoFor many people malls are a comfortable place with free air conditioning during the summer months. Free internet also helps. I've seen McDonalds also serve a similar local function.
- rangersanger 9y agoThe sad reality is that much of America, particularly suburban America but even in cities, public gathering places are nearly non-existent. The shopping mall (or more recently, lifestyle center, Festival Marketplaces, etc) is the closest thing many have to the town square or decently appointed public park. However, the mall isn't a public space and things a healthy society allows for - protest, hand holding, being different looking, aren't necessarily allowed in a mall. Regardless if a mall is preferable in 100 degree heat or -10 degree cold, those other spaces are important for other reasons.
- bunderbunder 9y ago> Young people and groups of friends don't go to the mall on their own. They don't go at all. Because most malls nowadays (in my area, anyway) have rules saying they have to be chaperoned by an adult.