3 ms·
Suing directors for negligence is not easy at all. It's hard to imagine a shareholder lawsuit that basically says: "As a director you didn't guide management to
by pavlov 9y ago
Suing directors for negligence is not easy at all. It's hard to imagine a shareholder lawsuit that basically says: "As a director you didn't guide management to move operations to Jersey, so we want you to pay us $100 million"... It's even harder to imagine a US court being friendly to such a case.
The greatest example of board negligence in this industry (that I can think of) in recent years would be when Hewlett-Packard's board hired Léo Apotheker as CEO in 2010. The board members had never met the man and his career had been on a different continent, yet they didn't even interview him in person before giving him the job!
Apotheker spent $10.2 billion to buy a British company named Autonomy. Soon after he was fired. Only a year later, HP was forced to write down $8.8 billion of Autonomy's purchase price.
That enormous loss was directly the fault of HP's board for hiring such a terrible CEO and letting him do the terrible deal. But shareholders didn't have any recourse; the best they could do is vote on a new board.
- tskaiser 9y agoThank you for the insight. It is one thing what holds in theory, and quite another what happens in reality, as you point out.
- jmalicki 9y agoIt is actually quite common. Here is a list of hundreds of such open lawsuits: http://shareholdersfoundation.com/content/new-cases http://shareholdersfoundation.com/content/new-cases
- pavlov 9y agoYes, shareholder lawsuits are common. But it's the company that pays, not directors. HP actually paid $100 million in such a lawsuit for the Apotheker/Autonomy flop: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-hp-classaction-pggm/hp-pays-100-million-to-settle-autonomy-related-class-action-suit-idUSKBN0OP17O20150609 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-hp-classaction-pggm/hp-pay... The 2010 Board of Directors who created and permitted the $8.8 billion loss paid nothing. They kept their compensation, and most stayed on the board.