3 ms·
> Apple's accountants say Apple Paradise Inc. made the profit ... because they offset all local profits to expenses incurred in licensing the brand. > When t
by toyg 9y ago
> Apple's accountants say Apple Paradise Inc. made the profit
... because they offset all local profits to expenses incurred in licensing the brand.
> When they sell a cool computer for E2000, they have used their brand to sell it, and there tax is collected.
But tax is supposed to be collected there and it's not, because Apple accountants immediately declare all profits as debits towards AParadise, so there is $0 profit. That $2000 laptop is now sold at cost, so there is nothing to tax - unless you start taxing expenses, and good luck with that (you'll kill half the economy overnight). All profit goes to AParadise, and the European economy is now at net negative: it pays for the roads that Apple trucks use to deliver their China-made wares, it pays for the social security that frees disposable income for Euro citizens to buy laptops, and in exchange it gets a big fat $0.
The solution is to do away with the "IP licensing" regime altogether, or tax it at absurd rates to discourage these moves. Otherwise you might as well give up and turn into Somalia.
- improbable22 9y agoOf the E2000 the customer paid, about E400 is tax right away. That's far from nothing. You could argue it should be higher, or lower. It's frequently adjusted. My point is that this transaction is what certainly happened in Germany. Taxing this is very clear, transparent, and fair. Whether or not the global empire turned a profit that quarter (maybe you bought a Samsung!), and which bits of the global empire were losing money or making money... and which bits are independent or not really independent... these are much harder to pin down, perhaps impossible. And attempting to do so (as we do now) encourages all sorts of strange behaviour, which requires lots of fancy lawyers, and can't be copied by smaller competitors. I don't know why we do this. I'm very much not arguing for zero taxes, I do not want to live in Somalia. I'm arguing for a tax system which doesn't reward stupid tricks --- the financial equivalent of moving your email server 100m across some border. Instead of ever stricter rules about where your server is located, we just have to get used to the idea that the cloud exists, and if the cloud is in Somalia or on the moon who cares? It's where the human beings are that matters.
- euyyn 9y agoI admire the patience with which you've responded in succession to two different commenters that didn't bother to read your comment, to which they were replying.
- toyg 9y agoThat 400 is a consumption tax that consumers pay, not the company. The company pays a fraction of that, depending on what in their expenses was also carrying VAT. So you just maximize your vat expenses and voilà, no real tax for the company. > I don't know why we do this. We do this because we know that global companies are sociopathic, and left to their own devices would never contribute to the societies they benefit from. So we try to drag them kicking and screaming back into human decency; and they try to escape in more and more creative ways. It's like asking why we pursue burglars. > I'm very much not arguing for zero taxes But you are; you are arguing for zero taxes for international companies, leaving only individuals and geo-restricted entities to deal with the task of paying for the cost of living in a civilized society. That's increasingly what happens in practice already, and it's a huge part of the problem. The best case in point is VAT, a regressive tax that is paid almost entirely by consumers - the same people who are also paying income tax, which is still the primary source of funds for any government. So individuals get hammered twice, while wealthy corporations stash away piles of money. That isn't right.
- improbable22 9y ago> tax that consumers pay No, you should think of the tax man standing between the customer and the seller. Whether he takes the bank notes from the customer's hand just before, or from the seller's hand just afterwards, really doesn't matter. The legal incidence of the tax is that the shop writes a check to the taxman, but this is not very interesting. The economic incidence is fuzzier and more interesting, and depends on the elasticities -- if the tax were made 500 euros, would the customer fork out more or would Apple collect less? This obviously depends on lots of things. It seems bizarre to me that when we discuss VAT as a consumption tax we follow neither of these things, and instead assign it to the purchaser -- but this is just some convention. (I'm imagining sales tax not VAT for simplicity. Or that the company made the goods entirely from scratch. I think VAT will be collected on the wholesale price when the computer crosses the border from China, and then on the retail mark-up when it's sold... but no change to the moral of the story.) By "sociopathic" you mean amoral. Like plants in your garden. The weeds will take over if you let them. Personifying them doesn't help with understanding this. But whether you pay the gardener by handing him the cash, or by pinning it to the thorn bush for him to collect, really really doesn't matter.
- peoplewindow 9y agoYes, those countries with low corporation tax are so much like Somalia ... I think you lost the argument at that point. If Germany stops trying to tax companies that aren't German it won't turn into anarchy.