2 ms·
Less exhausting than reading each of those 20+ emails separately. For any conversation of substance, you need the relevant context before you can understand the
by wahern 9y ago
Less exhausting than reading each of those 20+ emails separately. For any conversation of substance, you need the relevant context before you can understand the reply.
If context isn't required, then don't include it. Inline replies act as a forcing function, directing people to reply to the substance of what was said. That necessarily includes eliding irrelevant bits, which is often the most helpful aspect. Neither top posting nor bottom posting help emphasize substance.
In high quality forums inline posting is extremely useful for both reader and author. For the Outlook and Twitter set, it's a pointless debate.
- hota_mazi 9y agoEither you're part of an active email chain (e.g. happening over a period of a few hours), in which case you have the context. You don't need to read it over and over again, so the best place to put it is below the signature. Top posting wins here. Or you're catching up on a discussion that happened in the past, reading each email one after the other. Again, the context is secondary, so the best place is to put it below the signature. Again, top posting wins. For these rare emails where specific answers need to be positioned below some specific context, the writer of the email needs to have the discipline to put it there, and this can be achieved with top posting as well. Inline quoting has really no good reason to exist in most email chains.
- fiddlerwoaroof 9y agoThere are two relevant senses of context: what has already happened in the email thread and what a given person thinks he is responding to. Top posting is better for an outsider who is just reading through the thread while inline replies help the people in the thread understand where a given author is coming from.