4 ms·
In the last week Disney prevented industry critics from accessing a new product early enough to have a review prepared before release. This move was a reversal
by slg 9y ago
In the last week Disney prevented industry critics from accessing a new product early enough to have a review prepared before release. This move was a reversal of both their own previous behavior and industry standard. People were outraged.
In the last week Apple prevented industry critics from accessing a new product early enough to have a review prepared before release. This move was a reversal of both their own previous behavior and industry standard. People didn't seem to care.
I am at a loss to explain why these reactions were so different. Is it because Apple has more goodwill? Is it because Apple is more opaque in their motivations? Is it because movie criticism is a more mature field with more consistent and well defined standards?
EDIT: As a response to the downvotes, here is the specific recent change that Apple made regarding the iPhone X [1].
And for those who say that it is different to punish an outlet for unrelated negative coverage, do I have to remind people how Apple reacted to the Gizmodo iPhone leak? [2]
[1] - https://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2017/11/01/apple-iphonex-review-restricted-limited-scared-wrong-spin/#26c267a15cc9 https://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2017/11/01/apple-iph...
[2] - http://www.mercurynews.com/2010/06/07/gizmodo-banned-from-apple-event/ http://www.mercurynews.com/2010/06/07/gizmodo-banned-from-ap...
- Aloha 9y agoWhich Apple Case? Disney got a poor reaction because they retaliated against the Los Angeles Times for reporting on fishy financial business between the City of Anaheim, and the Walt Disney Company - the issue is not secrecy, its retaliation.
- slg 9y agoApple severally limited pre-release access to the iPhone X and almost all extended access was given exclusively to non-tech sources. Apple also has a history of doing the exact same thing as Disney by shunning reviewers that they feel do not treat them fairly.
- Aloha 9y agoit'd be the same thing, if say, Disney dumped the Times for giving a bad review of Cars 4 - its not the same thing when you're covering a local issue, which is corruption in the City of Anaheim. They're lacking in 'moral equivalency'.
- slg 9y agoI am not sure I see a huge distinction between the two. One is bullying the industry press to give you favorable reviews. One is bullying the industry press to avoid publishing stories that paint you in a negative light. Either way, Apple has been accused of both.
- fatbird 9y agoYou're trying to limit this to a discussion of whether the coverage is good or bad for the company in question, but in Disney's case, there was also the public interest angle of the capture of Anaheim city council. I don't give a shit if I don't have a review of the iPhone X on the release date, but if Apple had corrupted my city council, I'd be very interested.
- s73ver_ 9y agoI think a big part of it is that Disney did so because the LA Times reported on their actions in Anaheim. I haven't heard anything such that Apple prevented industry critics from reviewing their product early because those outlets covered bad behavior by Apple.
- Johnny555 9y agoIn the first case, Disney punished a news organization for reporting the news. I can't find the second case in the news -- who did Apple block from pre-release reviews? The closest case I can find is an employee fired for an NDA violation after his daughter posted an unauthorized review of prerelease hardware, but I don't think you're talking about that one.