4 ms·
While I'm just another anecdote, I haven't found RBLs to be anywhere near the level of trouble you've accused them of. I've been a system administrator for over
by SwellJoe 16y ago
While I'm just another anecdote, I haven't found RBLs to be anywhere near the level of trouble you've accused them of. I've been a system administrator for over a dozen years, and built and maintained a number of mail systems, on the order of hundreds, and my company/project user base includes at least a couple million mail server administrators.
I can think of a couple of folks among our community who've raised a ruckus about RBLs, but they're folks that I know from experience raise a ruckus about everything (not to say you fall into that category). I can also think of another handful of folks who complained, who when I found more information found they actually are spammers, they just don't consider themselves spammers. It's strange how few spammers consider what they do wrong, and how indignant they become when things work against them. (Again, not to suggest that you fall into that category.)
Granted, RBLs don't really work all that well as a spam control mechanism. They aren't worthless in that regard, but they also aren't the most effective single tool. But, when used as a weighting factor, as in SpamAssassin, it's a perfectly sane addition to any mail server, and I wouldn't want to see them disappear.
In nearly every case of RBL listing I've ever seen in the years since RBLs came into existence, there actually was some reason for the listing: open relay, accidental spamming user with a virus of some sort, misconfigured DNS, etc.
Frankly, as someone that has maintained mail servers for all those years and for so many customers, RBLs are something I think about so rarely that I'm kinda stunned you have such a strong emotional feeling about them. I'm just not sure how my experience and yours can be so very different on the very same Internet.
- thaumaturgy 16y agoYeah, I'm stunned too, especially since you've had so much more exposure than I have. My first collision with RBLs was actually back in '97 or thereabouts. I was just starting to really mess around on the internet, had visions of becoming a dial-up ISP, all that good stuff. Anyway, my ISP at the time ended up on the MAPS RBL due to the actions of a customer-of-a-customer. Rather than give in, they decided to fight them, and I got stuck in the middle. For various reasons, I didn't have to deal with RBLs again for quite a while (I worked for other/larger companies, where it was someone else's problem; I left the computer industry entirely for a few years; so on), but eventually I got to be a tech-support/sysadmin monkey for a local ISP. They occasionally found themselves blackholed by one list or another for various reasons, whether it was a root'd box or a customer doing something dumb, usually a mailing list. Still, dealing with RBLs happened at least monthly. Since starting my own business, I've had to deal with RBLs probably 3 or 4 times a year. Not super often, but I don't have a really massive list of clients yet either. As yet another data point, nearlyfreespeech.net refuses to send out email notifications for planned outages. One of the reasons they give is that some percentage of their customers will lazily or mistakenly flag their message as spam and they'll end up on an RBL, which they don't want to deal with. I'm actually not opposed to RBLs being used as a factor in products like SpamAssassin. For one thing, SA can be configured by the end-user, which means that if they miss out on anything, they only have themselves to blame; and secondly, so long as the RBL isn't the sole reason for dropping a message or connection, it doesn't bother me nearly as much. At the ISP I worked for, "missing email" was probably the number 1 complaint, or close to it, and we spent an awful lot of time trying to fine-tune things so that legitimate messages wouldn't be lost. So, color me equally surprised that you've had no trouble with it at all. :-)
- SwellJoe 16y ago"Since starting my own business, I've had to deal with RBLs probably 3 or 4 times a year. Not super often, but I don't have a really massive list of clients yet either." So, this is more than I come in contact with RBL issues by a pretty good amount. I think about it occasionally because users ask how to tune their SpamAssassin rules regarding them, but that's usually not in response to any problem. But, what I find interesting is that something you deal with 3 or 4 times a year is considered a big deal, and worth throwing out the whole RBL system over (which, as I noted, I do consider a reasonably useful addition to a spam filtering system). I can think of a significant number of things I have to deal with a lot more often on a mail server, even if I did have RBL troubles that often: bounces, software updates, spam filter tuning, fixing clamav (honestly, dealing with clamav accounts for probably 75% of my mail server related work), troubleshooting why a large mailing is going slow, user stuff, whatever. All of that stuff happens all the time. RBL issues are once in a blue moon, and usually triggered by some other issue that would have had to be dealt with anyway...getting listed in an RBL just made me aware of the problem sooner. I've had to request de-listing twice that I can recall: Once for a new server that happened to end up on an IP that had been used by spammers. Once because of a pseudo-open relay (a web application had a hole that allowed mail to be sent to arbitrary recipients). In both cases it was fixed within the same day. I've also advised people on fixing open relays, DNS issues, among other things, over the years. I can't, at the moment, think of any false positives that I've dealt with directly or indirectly. To add to the argument that RBLs aren't more trouble than they're worth, I'll mention a relatively recent issue in SpamAssassin that did effect a lot of our users, and our own mail server. There was a rule, distributed in the default RHEL/CentOS SpamAssassin package, that considered mail with a date in 20x0 to be too far in the future, and thus very spammy. When we ticked over into 2010, suddenly thousands of users weren't getting any mail (except a few spams that cleverly used dates in the distant past)...that's pretty dramatic. Easy to fix, but it effected a lot of people, and led to a couple dozen tickets and support queries in our forums. That one bug has caused more support request related to email than RBLs ever have. (And ClamAV tickets/queries still far outnumber any other aspect of our mail stack, even after the SpamAssassin 20x0 debacle.) We obviously aren't throwing out SpamAssassin just because a few problems pop up now and then.
- 16y ago
- ubernostrum 16y agoI'm kinda stunned you have such a strong emotional feeling about them. The lists themselves don't bother me so much. The people behind them, though, scare the bejesus out of me. There's a line in Nancy Kress' novel Beggars in Spain, where one of the main characters says, of another (a woman whose paranoia has driven her to do some fairly extreme things), that she would nuke the world if it would finally make her feel safe. Too often, that quote floats into my mind when reading things like the SPEWS FAQ.
- jacquesm 16y agoMy experience with the RBL has been exclusively negative to date. We used to send out a mailing every couple of weeks, double opt-in and all that jazz. In spite of that there would always be some percentage of clueless people that forgot they'd signed up and that would go all vigilante on us, list us with every known spam blocker and so on. This would lead to password recovery emails not making it through any more (same server), tech support emails being lost and all kinds of other hassles, including direct loss of revenue because paying subscribers could not receive their payment confirmation emails. In the end we gave up, email is a wonderful medium but if the reliability of the medium is left to people that are well willing to throw out the baby with the bathwater in a well meant but incompetent attempt at improving the situation then you're better off without it. Blacklists are not the solution to any of these problems without a very rapid and transparent problem resolution process. Spamhaus is one of the few such institutions that we've never had an issue with.
- sielskr 16y ago>My experience with the RBL has been exclusively negative to date. >a well meant but incompetent attempt at improving the situation I do not mean to dismiss your frustration, but I wonder if you are comparing the present situation to an unobtainable ideal. Yes, email worked great in the early 1990s. (E.g., most people who ran the net-news infrastructure demanded that there be a working email address in the From field of every message, and I cannot recall anyone back then disagreeing with that demand.) But the internet is drastically different now. We cannot just go back to the way it was.
- jacquesm 16y agoSpam is here to stay. Mostly by virtue of the idiots that continue to buy products that are spamvertised. Blocking the way the RBL does it is counterproductive, you can't combat spam effectively that way. Spamhaus has the right idea (block the spam from zombies), the RBL and it's cousins are out of control. If the battle with spam will ever really be won however it will be by a combination of end user education and legislation that will make it more expensive to send spam than the money you will make on it. The education part of it will be the larger component, the legislation to mop up the remaining die hards.
- tomjen3 16y agoWell if you want an example of what goes wrong, just read the reddit announcement where they talk about a lot of their customers who couldn't receive their email because Trend Micro had decided that the entire amazon cloud was a dial-up pool. Frankly black lists, grey lists and spammers should just go to hell.