9 ms·
Disney Ends Ban on Los Angeles Times Amid Fierce Backlash
- zaroth 9y agoThe newspapers band together to blackout Disney in response to Disney blacking out the LA Times, but surprise surprise, it's perfectly OK for them to use the same tactics because, you know, they're the good guys. Even if it's true, I am very suspicious when someone tries to sell me that these kinds of tactics are "right when I use them but wrong when you do".
- epistasis 9y agoYes, that's why it's completely inappropriate to put a kidnapper in prison, right?
- zaroth 9y agoSo the newspapers blacklisting Disney from awards consideration is, in your mind, akin to trial by jury, conviction, and lawful sentencing? I think you make my point for me. Arguably they were justified in retaliating, but it's clearly a mudfight, and the newspapers had no problem getting into the mud with Disney and flexing their muscle. I don't see any high ground here.
- s73ver_ 9y agoIf you say journalists were justified in blocking Disney from awards consideration over Disney blocking a newspaper who reported on their actions during the Anaheim City Council elections, then you kinda disproved your theory that there isn't any high ground.
- zaroth 9y ago"Arguably" as in -- the argument could be made. It's not an argument I would personally make, I was trying to identify with epistasis' position. IMO the high ground is fairly simple; You report on the fact that Disney is retaliating for a story they don't like and allow the Streisand effect to carry you to swift and decisive victory, without having to resort to extortion yourself.
- bgun 9y agoPublic opinion should never be used as a weapon, least of all by journalists. That's not to say that it doesn't happen, or that the feeling of schadenfreude when it does isn't justfied, but what you are suggesting amounts to an expectation that the public will do your job for you.
- zaroth 9y agoI think in a round about way that "the public doing your job for you" is actually the fucking definition of journalism! I don't know if I need to explain that further or if it makes sense on its own. But I'm thinking along the lines of -- Journalists report the story, they don't make the story. The public, by reading their story, does the "job" of turning hard-hitting reporting into justice. Not the news organization itself.
- mattmanser 9y agoThe newspapers can criticise Disney's business actions while simultaneously praising their artistic output. It's different parts of the newspaper, different aims on informing the public. That's fair and unbiased and the job of a journalist. While Disney attempts to punish the commercial arm of a newspaper by attacking their entertainment division, because of the actions of investigative journalists in a different field. Disney is resorting to extortion, the newspaper is simply doing their job.
- zaroth 9y agoI agree Disney absolutely resorted to extortion, and I agree the newspaper absolutely was simply doing it's job. Now tell me... what happened next? If you consider it deeply, does it make you feel at all uncomfortable? Or because the "good guys won" are we just supposed to be giddy that Disney got rightly put in their place by the MSM?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Or because the "good guys won" are we just supposed to be giddy that Disney got rightly put in their place by the MSM? Newspapers blocking Disney from a private function, from which Disney benefits but does not depend, is an asymmetric response to Disney blocking a newspaper's film screeners from screening its films, access on which the screeners depend. When we add in that Disney moved first and in response to truthful reporting to its detriment and in the public interest, it's pretty clear that this private dispute is perfectly appropriate.
- Spooky23 9y agoThat’s not the standard that we hold civil matters to. Integrity is essential to the business of news reporting. Creating a culture where it’s assumed that only well behaved critics get to review movies undermines all newspapers and media.
- zaroth 9y agoI completely agree! I don't think I said or implied anything to the contrary.
- ryanlol 9y agoYou could, for example, very well argue that it is exploitative and completely inappropriate to put anyone in an US¹ prison. ¹ And many others, this is just an easy example.
- Analemma_ 9y agoSo what should the newspapers have done instead? Lie down and take it, because otherwise “we’d be just as bad”? This widespread reflex to go “both sides are equally bad!”, even when such equivocation is flatly absurd, is the thing that makes me most weep for the future of the human race.
- zaroth 9y agoNo, that's not what they should have done. If they stood by their reporting, the response to violence or bullying doesn't always have to be more violence or bullying. It's actually possible to stand by your reporting, and continue to pursue a story, without resorting to blackmail. Both sides demonstrated their moral flexibility for using extortion to get what they wanted. That much is clear. What makes me "weep" is the abundance of logical fallacies deployed against my stated suspicion of the tactics used by a very powerful group to bring Disney to heel. Maybe they needed to be brought to heel, but I dislike the methods and again I am deeply suspicious of the coordinated exercise of power which was on display here.
- BEEdwards 9y agoNot reviewing a movie based on a prescreeining isn't "bullying" by any stretch of the imagination.
- zaroth 9y agoI agree completely. You may have missed, from TFA: On Tuesday, members of the Los Angeles Film Critics Association, the New York Film Critics Circle, the Boston Society of Film Critics and the National Society of Film Critics denounced Disney’s blackout of The Los Angeles Times. Each group voted to disqualify Disney’s movies from year-end award consideration unless the blackout was “publicly rescinded.” If I'm not mistaken, those awards are worth hundreds of millions of dollars to Disney. It seemed like a significant escalation to me! EDIT: I was an order of magnitude off in the estimated value of winning a half dozen Academy Awards.
- s73ver_ 9y agoSo, we should all just ignore that Disney is attempting to use its might in order to completely bypass freedom of the press, and end oversight of what it's doing in the city council elections in Anaheim?
- zaroth 9y agoNo I wouldn't suggest ignoring it, but I also would propose it's possible to respond in a way that's highly effective but yet not itself extortion. EDIT: Might I add -- can you please explain why you say Disney "is attempting to use its might in order to completely bypass freedom of the press, and end oversight of what it's doing in the city council elections in Anaheim"? At what point did Disney even come close to trying to take down the LA Times reporting, or imprison someone for reporting it, or somehow stop the oversight from happening? Clearly by trying to retaliate they only gave the story more legs. There was never a question of LA Times retracting their story. And "freedom of the press" doesn't mean that companies can't restrict access to their own products in response to negative coverage. Upthread someone mentioned Apple did something very similar with iPhone X. Companies provide favorable access to favorable journalists all the time. To me, it was the MSM retaliation which raised an eyebrow. And again, maybe they did it for good cause, but it was eyebrow-raising [to me] none the less.
- rhizome 9y agoWhat about a parent who tells their kid they can't have dessert unless they eat their vegetables, is that extortion too?
- zaroth 9y agoSo your position is that the news organizations are Disney's parent and legal guardian - and just looking out for their health and well being? Or less literally, you think the news organizations simply had to threaten Disney with potentially billions (nix that, it's actually just hundreds of millions) of dollars of lost revenue by being excluded from the awards ceremonies in order to restore LA Times access to pre-screenings. It doesn't concern you at all that they would collectively make that threat / wield that might? And this is all going on the assumption that the original LA Times reporting on Disney shenanigans in Anaheim was rock-solid and beyond reproach. Which of course I'm sure it was. Even still I remain suspicious when the MSM bands together to effectively threaten losses of hundreds of millions in revenue [1] to a company which they think is misbehaving. P.S. I feel like I'm in a weird rhetorical bubble here... I'd actually love it for someone to tell me exactly why I'm wrong without lobbing logical fallacies at me! [1] - http://www.businessinsider.com/oscarnomics-2013-how-much-is-oscar-really-worth-2013-2 http://www.businessinsider.com/oscarnomics-2013-how-much-is-...
- tdb7893 9y agoIt sounds like you are saying that context doesn't matter at all for ethics. That's a pretty bold claim
- zaroth 9y agoIt certainly would be a bold claim if I made it. Why would I engage with hypothetical positions which I didn't take?
- ajkjk 9y agoWell, you definitely wrote an opinion that selectively ignored context in order to make something reasonable sound unreasonable, which indicates your willingness to selectively ignore context to evaluate ethics, hence the reading that you endorse that as a general behavior...
- zaroth 9y agoThe newspapers band together to blackout Disney in response to Disney blacking out the LA Times That is an accurate portrayal of the context, is it not? Would you have been happier if I wrote; The newspapers band together to blackout Disney in response to Disney blacking out the LA Times in response to their hard hitting story about Disney. It's a mouthful, and doesn't change at all my following statement as I see it.
- s73ver_ 9y agoThat is a fairly inaccurate, to the point of being dishonest, portrayal of the context. That last part, in the italics, that you claim makes no difference, is a huge difference in context here.
- zaroth 9y agoIt wasn't my intent to misrepresent the context. As a comment on TFA I read TFA and I assume you read TFA. But it's telling that you think... the threat to blacklist Disney from awards, unless they retract their blacklist of the LA Times, is justified, not because they blacklisted the LA Times, but because of why they blacklisted the LA Times. Namely, in response to the LA Times' piece critical of Disney. So, a particularly violent response is justified by the MSM in this case, because Disney is retaliating against a news story which so far is being held up as factual. If they want to retaliate against a newspaper's dutiful and factual investigative reporting, then it's OK for the MSM to hit them where it hurts. I actually get that people think this is justified and that the MSM actually did one right by defending themselves like this. I personally take no joy watching powerful interests try to out-leverage each other. A muscle exercised will be a muscle more quickly used and relied on in the future. I don't enjoy the mudfight and don't think either side comes out entirely clean. (My last comment on this topic)
- s73ver_ 9y agoAnother thing you're either missing or deliberately omitting is that the LA Times didn't disqualify Disney from awards. The rest of the industry, upon hearing that Disney did this because of reporting on their actions with the city of Anaheim, did this because trying to silence journalism like that is objectively wrong.
- oxide 9y agoThe ban was bullshit- good on disney for axing it.
- webkike 9y agoNo, bad on Disney for doing it in the first place.
- pwinnski 9y agoCrazily enough, it can be both bad on Disney for doing something bad, and good on them for ending it. Best of all, this should serve as an example to other companies tempted to do similarly-terrible things. It probably won't, but it should.
- jhall1468 9y agoThey ended it because they bit of more than they could chew, not out of altruism. Once they had threats of losing out on critics awards, they jumped ship instantly.
- r00fus 9y agoReward good behavior, punish bad behavior. Recognition to Disney for ending their bullshit ban, but they still need to answer for their position on the $1.2b Anaheim parking lot that the city "leases" to them for $1/yr.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoWhy would Disney need to answer for that? If you could lease a billion dollar property for $1 / year, wouldn't you? Anaheim should answer for that.
- r00fus 9y agoI think it's perfectly fair to ask companies like Disney and Nestle [1] why they're getting sweetheart deals from local governments where they're going to make millions or billions out of that property. [1] http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-nestle-water-lawsuit-20151013-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-nestle-water-lawsuit-2...
- irl_zebra 9y agoAlso keep in mind that Disney is most likely caving not due to the public backlash, but the threat of being disqualified from critic awards considerations.
- mayneack 9y agoI don't see any indication that this is any more important than the public backlash.
- dsr_ 9y agoIf it becomes known that no Disney-made film will be considered for major awards, the actors and directors who are typically in contention for such things will suddenly be busy when a Disney-affiliated producer calls. Those who are persuaded to come anyway will ask for more money. Executive producers are often hoping to win awards as well as make money; they'll be leery of the situation too. Always look for the bottom line. The boost to Disney from winning any given award is minuscule, but the extra cost of talent can be significant.
- mayneack 9y agoYeah, I understand all that, but nowhere does anyone suggest that they care more about the awards than general backlash. They weren't even blocked from the major awards - academy awards, golden globes - just the regional critics association awards.
- vlahmot 9y agoSo everyone goes back to reviewing movies ahead of time and Disney feels no pain from their actions beyond a small PR hit. I feel like everyone framing this as "We won't pre-review movies until you lift the block" gave them too easy of an out.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoActually I think it called more attention to their capture of the elected officials in Anaheim than they would have liked so perhaps more than a PR hit.
- f2f 9y agoIt also had a Streisand effect on the LATimes article. Which many people (including myself) would not have otherwise read.
- dmix 9y agoYes, large company executives have misjudged the impact of the Streisand effect countless times. But this time isn't just the result of internet network effects, the media has always had the power to push back on large organizations (and politicians) who attempt to bully them. And journalistic organizations have historically banded together in these moments. The media has always been one of the best natural counter-balances in capitalism and democracy to poorly thought out power plays by insecure executives, without requiring direct intervention or oversight by a third party. Hopefully this isn't shielded in the media as generically the fault of 'Disney', which is a large organization staffed by varied people, but the particular people behind this move. Because lets be honest, this will hardly hurt Disneys bottom line. No one is going to not see their big movies, considering the brands they own and their overall reach. But hopefully it filters back to whichever executive had a power trip over this. Few power-players have survived attacking the media, unless the media was widely perceived to be wrong about something, which is not the case here.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoMaybe they keep trying the Streisand strategy because most of the time it works and we only hear about it the few times it fails. How would we know?
- cwkoss 9y agoWhat was the LA Times story that precipitated the blackout?
- mayneack 9y agohttp://www.latimes.com/projects/la-fi-disney-anaheim-deals/ http://www.latimes.com/projects/la-fi-disney-anaheim-deals/
- lsmarigo 9y agoHuge credit to Alyssa Rosenberg from the Washington Post for being the first to stand up to Disney on this. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/act-four/wp/2017/11/06/why-i-wont-be-reviewing-the-last-jedi-or-any-other-disney-movie-in-advance/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/act-four/wp/2017/11/06/w... Also for the curious this was the piece that got LA Times blacklisted: http://www.latimes.com/projects/la-fi-disney-anaheim-deals/ http://www.latimes.com/projects/la-fi-disney-anaheim-deals/ From that article: Even if the parking garage fills just half its spaces, it would still generate more than $35 million in annual revenue and easily hundreds of millions of dollars over the life of the structure. That money all goes to Walt Disney Co. The city of Anaheim, which owns the garage and spent $108.2 million to build it, charges the company just $1 a year for the lease.
- dpiers 9y agoI am going to write a letter to the City of Anaheim to inform them I am willing to pay double, maybe even triple, to lease their garage property.
- forapurpose 9y agoPerhaps there's a law requiring a competitive bidding process ...
- jacquesm 9y agoReading that Rosenberg piece it is incredible how much power Google has amassed, to see that they believe that it is crucial to get in their reviews 'early' in order to capture the audience from Google through increased pagerank. That's a pretty sad testimony to what the web has become, a race to be the first with 'original' content (never mind that 30 other outlets will have the same content within a 24 hour period) in order to sustain a very important plank in the fabric of society: the free press.
- michaelbuckbee 9y agoIt's worse than you think as well - I've heard publishers refer to the "lottery" for repackaging things like John Oliver's "Last Week Tonight" or Seth Meyers pieces, etc. Every major publication tries to get some rank for their 50 word post about how "Jimmy killed it last night" and then puts the YouTube embed on their page. If they do it right, it's a couple million additional visitors that day/week to their site.
- slg 9y agoIn the last week Disney prevented industry critics from accessing a new product early enough to have a review prepared before release. This move was a reversal of both their own previous behavior and industry standard. People were outraged. In the last week Apple prevented industry critics from accessing a new product early enough to have a review prepared before release. This move was a reversal of both their own previous behavior and industry standard. People didn't seem to care. I am at a loss to explain why these reactions were so different. Is it because Apple has more goodwill? Is it because Apple is more opaque in their motivations? Is it because movie criticism is a more mature field with more consistent and well defined standards? EDIT: As a response to the downvotes, here is the specific recent change that Apple made regarding the iPhone X [1]. And for those who say that it is different to punish an outlet for unrelated negative coverage, do I have to remind people how Apple reacted to the Gizmodo iPhone leak? [2] [1] - https://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2017/11/01/apple-iphonex-review-restricted-limited-scared-wrong-spin/#26c267a15cc9 https://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2017/11/01/apple-iph... [2] - http://www.mercurynews.com/2010/06/07/gizmodo-banned-from-apple-event/ http://www.mercurynews.com/2010/06/07/gizmodo-banned-from-ap...
- Aloha 9y agoWhich Apple Case? Disney got a poor reaction because they retaliated against the Los Angeles Times for reporting on fishy financial business between the City of Anaheim, and the Walt Disney Company - the issue is not secrecy, its retaliation.
- slg 9y agoApple severally limited pre-release access to the iPhone X and almost all extended access was given exclusively to non-tech sources. Apple also has a history of doing the exact same thing as Disney by shunning reviewers that they feel do not treat them fairly.
- Aloha 9y agoit'd be the same thing, if say, Disney dumped the Times for giving a bad review of Cars 4 - its not the same thing when you're covering a local issue, which is corruption in the City of Anaheim. They're lacking in 'moral equivalency'.
- jostmey 9y agodisney should have never tried it to begin with. I am reminded of the south park episode where mickey mouse walks around beating people up. Sometimes fiction isn't that different than real life.
- freeflight 9y agoSometimes fiction actually depicts reality way more aptly than reality does. Disney is a company that has literally influenced and changed how most of humanity thinks about "copyright" and public domain [0] This is no small feat and imho it's a far more sinister and evil thing to do than straight up murdering some people. They've been one of the main driving forces for the commercialized monopolization of information and ideas, for the worse and most likely for whole generations to come. There's also something quite macabre about such company focusing so heavily on children and constantly prioritizing their "friendly and nice" appearance: Get them when they are young and they will be loyal their whole life, get them while you are smiling and they won't expect you coming at them. [0] https://www.eff.org/de/node/90076 https://www.eff.org/de/node/90076
- mturmon 9y agoSounds like Disney has done for movies, stories, characters and cartoons what Facebook is doing for chat and social communication -- Putting them behind an aggressively-defended corporate wall and making money by using them as advertising vectors? What I'm trying to suggest here is that there is a parallel between the (Hollywood-based) Disney machine that has employed, enriched, and frustrated storytellers over the years, and the (Silicon Valley-based) machines that are now employing software pros.
- freeflight 9y agoFacebook couldn't do what they do if Disney didn't "clear the way for them", so to speak. Imho it's all part of the same trend where "intangible goods" have become more valuable than actual tangible resources, which seems how we spend our way out of the 2008 recession. At this point it's pretty much impossible to be a fan of something "pop culture" and not having to pay the IP tax to Disney, or some other massive corporation, for owning that IP. On one hand, generating money out of writing code or painting a character sure is a good option to have, creative arts need to be properly compensated. But with how copyright law has changed over these past decades this can sometimes have really bad outcomes and as time progresses it feels like more and more of these "intangible goods" are being monopolized. Happy birthday songs and Christmas songs being "copyrighted", sending out cease-and-desist orders to people singing them, sounds like a bad joke of a dystopian future, but that's where we already have been for quite a while now and it's only getting worse. And it's not like we'd have to convince just one government to reform copyright, at this point we would rather have to convince mega corporations likey Disney because it's them who actually hold the influence to change legislation for literally half of the planet.
- joering2 9y agoRelated (great article of a subject that comes back to HN) https://priceonomics.com/how-mickey-mouse-evades-the-public-domain/ https://priceonomics.com/how-mickey-mouse-evades-the-public-...
- omegaworks 9y agoThis is precisely why it is important to counteract the creeping tightening of copyright law in favor of Disney. They've successfully lobbied Congress for extensions every time Mickey comes up to the end of his protection. >Disney has a history of taking punitive action against news organizations and analysts when they publish articles or analysis that it deems unfair. This kind of behavior can only be afforded by companies with extremely tight control over their media distribution vertical. Government policy created this monster.
- tzs 9y ago> This is precisely why it is important to counteract the creeping tightening of copyright law in favor of Disney. They've successfully lobbied Congress for extensions every time Mickey comes up to the end of his protection. "Every time" is a kind of odd way to describe something that has only happened once definitely, and possibly one other time. The copyright on Mickey Mouse has been extended twice. The first was the Copyright Act of 1976, which changed copyright terms to match those of most of the rest of the world. Works that were still under copyright at the time were retroactively given the term they would have had in the rest of the world (life + 50 for works of individual authors, publication + 75 for works for hire). I've not found anything on whether or not Disney lobbied for the 1976 Act. They undoubtedly were in favor of it, but there probably was little need to actually lobby for it. It's main purpose was to bring US law more in line with the rest of the world, paving the way for the US to eventually join the Berne Convention. It also codified fair use and the first sale doctrine, and legalized library photocopying, relaxed notification and registration requirements. There was widespread enough support for all of these that lobbying would not be needed. The second was the Copyright Term Extension Act of 1998, which Disney definitely lobbied for.
- HelloNurse 9y agoDidn't Disney predict "fierce backlash"? How could they expect journalists to turn their back when one of them is intimidated? A non-psychopath PR answer to embarrassing investigative journalism should involve creative attempts to minimize the gravity of the problem, to look good and to confuse the issue: Disney PR managers appear to have learned how to do their job from gangster movies instead.
- redblacktree 9y agoI think this was a power-tripping executive's decision, rather than a professional's.
- HelloNurse 9y agoBefore power-tripping, an executive should be a professional. It doesn't take a PR expert to know that threatening freedom of the press is a "now I have two problems" solution; anyone considering such behaviour should have been screened out at the start of their career, not empowered.