3 ms·
I'm crazy about the idea of wikileaks but the Journal's article brings up good points. These documents are unlikely to fundamentally change peoples' opinion on
by drivebyacct2 16y ago
I'm crazy about the idea of wikileaks but the Journal's article brings up good points. These documents are unlikely to fundamentally change peoples' opinion on the war(s), yet the documents have already been found to name afghan informants by full name, village and father's name.
- cma 16y agoSounds like a case of "collateral damage." Our military's stance is that such damage is completely ok no matter what proportionalities are involved.
- rick888 16y agoRight. So seeing a questionable video involving a few asshole US soldiers means that it's perfectly okay for hundreds more to die needlessly. what the hell kind of reasoning is that?
- cma 16y agoI said it was our military's stance, not my stance.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoI understand your point, but isn't the idea to be better? It's hard to argue that information should be free when the direct results of this will be human casualties. I mean, that's how it is being played and will be played. Note, I'm speaking literally when I say "hard to argue". I think it's the correct ideal and I think our government could use doses of unexpected transparency but it's the Fox News I'm thinking about.
- jacquesm 16y agoI wrote about exactly that: http://jacquesmattheij.com/In+defense+of+wikileaks http://jacquesmattheij.com/In+defense+of+wikileaks
- rick888 16y agoyou're wrong. The messenger had a responsibility with the information they received. They willingly gave out the information with no regard for the people in the documents. The difference between Wikleaks and the actual person that leaked the information is that Wikileaks has a large audience. They could have removed names, but didn't. Now the blood is on their hands.