17 ms·
I still think that proper self-driving cars are such a paradigm shift that predictions of how it will work are still up in the air. For example, right now I li
by aidenn0 9y ago
I still think that proper self-driving cars are such a paradigm shift that predictions of how it will work are still up in the air.
For example, right now I live on the west coast and my parents live on the east coast. 4 kids, Minimum of 40 hour drive or $3500 flight.
Here's one tiny example:
I can work remotely for a few weeks and my boss doesn't mind. The kids sleep for 8+ hours at night. Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Monday nights driving for 12 hours (mostly sleeping) means I am at my parent's house on Tuesday and I either take Monday as vacation or work remotely from a friend's house in Ohio. We see friends in flyover country that we rarely visit or see national parks on Saturday and Sunday.
I can now take the whole family to my parents taking just 2 days of vacation/remote for the trip, for only the depreciation cost on my car. Car trip isn't too bad because the kids are awake for a total of the running time of 6 movies.
Car usage will go up by an order of magnitude because a major cost of driving isn't the dollars, but the time.
- jedrek 9y agoWhile I agree that it's impossible to make predictions, your example is a massive edge case.
- sangnoir 9y agoI don't think it's an edge case: If an operator redesigns the interior of their fleet with large, comfortable reclining seats, long distance travel by road will become much more competitive with business-/first-class air travel. Boarding at my house and being dropped off at my destination and sleeping all the way (or working if you're a telecommuter, or watching movies) is quite appealing to me - the lack of TSA and/or Rapey-scan is a bonus edit: changed a few words for clarity
- notahacker 9y agoI've been on long distance buses with large, comfortable reclining seats and convenient pickup/dropoff points for 8 hour plus journeys more than most sane people I assure you it's not the human driver which means that most people strongly prefer other methods of transport.
- FreakyT 9y agoI feel like a car has greater potential for comfort than even a "comfortable" reclining bus seat. For example, right now the idea of a folding bed in a car isn't something you'll ever see as an option, since it would only really appeal to people trying to live in their cars, which probably don't overlap much with the "people who buy fancy cars with fancy extras" market segment. However, in a future where a car can auto-drive you on a long-distance trip, why not offer an actual bed mode in the car as a purchasable option?
- scirocco 9y agoA bed. With seat belt :)
- lddemi 9y agoImagine something like a modern first class cabin with the concept of 180 degree flat bed-seats.
- barney54 9y agoIn the future cars might be so safe you don't need a seat belt. Another thing that changes with autonomy is a reduction of crash-related features.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoImprobable, unless you can handwave terrain away. (And deer. And malfunctions. And...) There's so many things a car can impact besides other cars that a non-seatbelt in a car is far less likely than cars being replaced by some other form of transport.
- WalterSear 9y agoI don't think the comparison is as apt as, for instance, a 1st class intercontinental seat on Singapore airlines. https://www.singaporeair.com/saar5/images/navigation/flying-withus/cabins/first-class-main.jpg https://www.singaporeair.com/saar5/images/navigation/flying-...
- andrewtbham 9y agoYeh things will change... you sorta already see stuff like this in Asia where drivers are common... people have vans with offices in the back and work while their driver takes them to places.
- Canada 9y agoHow common is that? I've never seen it.
- andrewtbham 9y agoDrivers in Asia are, to my understanding, very common... Idk about the office/van. I just know one guy in South Korea that has that setup and he is rich. He says other people have it but not sure how common it is. But "executive" back seats are very common on luxury brand vehicles in China.
- rorykoehler 9y agoI've never seen that.
- kozak 9y agoWould be interesting to see some photos of such vans.
- geomark 9y agoAm I the only one who gets car sick when reading or using a computer in a car? Everyone keeps talking about working while on a long commute in a self-driving vehicle. Doing more than 30 minutes of it is not really an option for me.
- madengr 9y agoNo. Me too. Can’t even read in a plane, or watch a video. Won’t even think about getting on a boat.
- cardiffspaceman 9y agoI think there's going to be a spectrum of motion sickness. Would happen to me as a teen when we were going down well-made freeways to go to the beach, I had to just watch the scenery go by and ruminate about the lives of the residents of the various districts. Never happened to me as an adult in a plane, even reading tiny low-res screen of netbook. Can't imagine reading on a sailboat, I've got a job to do, or I'm drinking and socializing. No problem reading or walking around on the one cruise ship I've used. Of course there are individuals out there who can't read or even sit quietly in any of those scenarios without motion sickness.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoNope, not alone. Might be something with sudden acceleration changes - doesn't happen to me on a train, and only rarely on a bus.
- intended 9y agoThe line from travel via auto mated car to TSA style security invasion is actually pretty short. It just takes one person to decide to go carmageddon and now every car will have weight restrictions, luggage restrictions, then there will be ~~economy cars~~ pods and more. The moment you start paying for a seat, and the car is owned by someone else, the owners are going to see exactly how LITTLE they can keep in the car, and still get someone to use it. Unlike flying which benefited from budget airlines, car transport is not likely to benefit more people by going this route. All this thread is filled with people talking about some sort of benevolent firm wanting to take care of its customers. The moment the market place hits it's growth plateau, people will be cutting corners to reduce weight, and improve fuel efficiency. As for rapey scans - they will just expect people to get to a hub, and from that hub pick up their cars. The hub will have the rapey scans. The point of the TSA is to make the public feel that something is being "done", post 9/11. Its a product of fear, not of security requirements. So you can take it as a bet, that if any of the scenarios come true here - you will eventually return back to TSA levels of security theater.
- Noos 9y agoDo you drive? Because motion sickness prevents a large amount of people from watching movies or doing work in a car, even if you could make a decent enough workspace. The start and stop mode of car traffic is much different from an airplane or even train, and the road surface varies so much by area that potholes would make sleeping, working, or what have you a nightmare. A lot of this discussion seems dominated by people who don't use a car or understand driving.
- MarkPNeyer 9y agoPeople didn’t just use computers to speed up existing processes. They also started doing brand new things that were infeasible without computers.
- bmsleight_ 9y agoCamper-van, pick-me up at the office (London) on Friday evening, by Saturday morning we in the highlands of Scotland. It sounds silly - but the more automation the more I want to spend within my fictional camper-van. Soccer away match - no problem. Trip to the beach again, overnight. It is like an sleeper train - only more comfortable and spacious, as it would be my families camper-van.
- alasdair_ 9y ago>Camper-van, pick-me up at the office (London) on Friday evening, by Saturday morning we in the highlands of Scotland. I just want to point out that there is a pretty decent sleeper train that departs from the center of London and will have you wave up in the center of Glasgow. You'll have a full-size bed with sink, toilet etc. and a dining car and a bar if you want to avail yourself. Tickets are pretty cheap too.
- Symbiote 9y agoThere are also sleeper trains to the highlands. They leave a little earlier, at 21:15, and stop at the stations in the Highlands between 7 and 10 the next day. If you wake up with the early sun, like I did, then the views from the train are wonderful. https://traintimes.org.uk/London/FTW/21:00/today https://traintimes.org.uk/London/FTW/21:00/today https://www.seat61.com/CaledonianSleepers.htm https://www.seat61.com/CaledonianSleepers.htm
- jasonkester 9y agoI get the impression that people who make this sort of comment have never ridden a night bus with beds. It is in no way comparable to a sleeper train, which rides on relatively smooth, straight rails and isn't constantly swerving about and dumping everybody on to the ground. You need to "sleep" in this tensed up position where you're wedged in between ends of the bed using your core to keep you in place. On the sleeper buses in China, you'll often see people standing in the aisle, getting a rest from "sleeping" while building strength for another bout of it. So yeah, you'll get to Scotland the next morning. But next time you'll take the train and rent your van at the station.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoi never thought about this: you can just fill a car with a bunch of stuff and send it somewhere. makes mailing heavy stuff potentially dumb in some cases, depending on how things price out. also, maybe moving cross country gets easier for the same reason.
- titzer 9y ago> Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Monday nights driving for 12 hours (mostly sleeping) It's really sad that the United States has let passenger rail deteriorate to the point that people are forced into this situation. Really, really poor foresight.
- wskinner 9y agoPassenger rail in the United States probably doesn’t have the same economics as the other places you’re thinking of. I recently drove across part of the country, and it is shocking how much space there is with absolutely nothing there. There is a 100 mile stretch of I-80 without cell service or signs of habitation. If you live in a city, it’s easy to forget that the United States is much, much, bigger than Europe or Japan.
- tigershark 9y agoWhat? Europe is actually bigger than US. US is less than 10M Km^2, Europe is more than 10M Km^2
- 1812Overture 9y agoMore important difference is that a lot of the empty space in Europe is at its northern and eastern extremes and America's empty space is mostly in the middle (and Alaska).
- titzer 9y ago> There is a 100 mile stretch of I-80... Logistically speaking, empty places are really, really easy to build rail through. (Politically they may not be). These rail networks already exist, but they are often not dual line, aren't engineered to support fast trains, and there aren't passenger rail options that utilize them. All of these factors are due to consistent under investment because of chick-and-egg and political problems. It's a real failure of national investment. You can Google around but the cost per mile of new railroad track is comparable, if not a bit less, than interstate highway. And there are _tons_ of miles of interstate highways. The US has just chosen poorly.
- robotresearcher 9y ago> for only the depreciation cost on my car Ignoring fuel!
- rrhd 9y agoThats a cost that occurs no matter the system (you drive, you own a self driving car, dystopian wasteland of ordering cars).
- ghaff 9y agoYour kids must be saints. If I had been cooped up with my parents and sibling as a child for 40 hours even in a large van or RV with robo-Uber at the helm, someone would probably have been murdered at some point :-) As for my adult self, lie-flat seating on planes trans-Pacific is OK but it's still pretty boring. Even if I could work at some level in my comfy cross-country van I'd still take a significantly faster option given the choice.
- monk_e_boy 9y agoBut you can stop and get out, see new things. Journeys are adventures. I let my kids stop us and we all get out and go see whatever.
- ghaff 9y agoSure. A roadtrip--though that's still a long roadtrip. But if you're robo-pedal-to-the-metal across the country instead of flying you're not doing a lot of adventuring along the way.
- PuffinBlue 9y agoI think you perhaps misread the post. It suggests that there is only 12 hours driving per day but the kids would be asleep for at least 8 of those. The idea being drive overnight and stop at the next waypoint (see friends in flyover country/national park etc) during the day. I guess the plan being to do interesting stuff when awake and travel when asleep, for the most part. I suppose as long as you get in the hours you need to as a remote worker and the sleeping is comfortable then this would be pretty sweet for even very long journeys. It would take a complete redesign of car interiors to something far more comfortable/secure for lying down but no reason that problem couldn't be solved.
- ghaff 9y ago>It would take a complete redesign of car interiors to something far more comfortable/secure for lying down but no reason that problem couldn't be solved. Well, it's solved. They're called RVs. As a kid (or even as an adult), I think I'd still find it being pretty cooped up. It's one reason that I've never taken long-haul Amtrak that I suspect I'd find is more interesting in the theory than in the practice.
- landryraccoon 9y ago> Car usage will go up by an order of magnitude because a major cost of driving isn't the dollars, but the time. This is why I think self driving cars will make traffic worse, not better. The more comfortable it is to be inside a car and the less people mind long car rides, the more people will drive (self driving or otherwise). If road infrastructure is the same, that necessarily means a much higher density of cars on the road. It's possible that self driving cars will be more space efficient on the road, but ten times more efficient? I think it's more likely that there will just be way more cars on the road and traffic will worsen considerably.
- modeless 9y agoYou are absolutely right, and this is not widely understood yet. I expect people to live farther from work and spend more time in cars and in traffic. On the other hand, need for parking will plummet and that should free up a bunch of space in cities, increasing density. I wonder if there is money to be made betting on this in the markets? Which companies will benefit, or lose, from these shifts?
- rickycook 9y agothat’s very true. i read somewhere that something crazy like 30% of traffic in city areas are people looking for car parking. don’t have a source on it, but the parking situation definitely shouldn’t be ignored, at least as far as the most built up/problematic areas are concerned
- xbmcuser 9y agoIf we have self driving cars the roads in cities will get a lot wider as no side parking in many streets many 2 lane or 1 lane would become 3 or 4 lane streets as well. Would allow for dedicated bus lanes as well so traveling by bus could also become a lot faster.
- dragonwriter 9y agoIf we have self-driving cars that aren't parked the same way as human-driven cars, but instead drive unoccupied to park somewhere else, then the extra space from reduced roadside parking will largely be occupied by extra traffic lanes to accommodate the added deadhead traffic.
- avn2109 9y ago>> "Car usage will go up by an order of magnitude because a major cost of driving isn't the dollars, but the time." This is the Jevons paradox applied to time cost. Definitely true.
- rorykoehler 9y agoBy then SpaceX will fly you there in 30 mins plus the trip to the spaceport.
- Johnny555 9y agoA $30,000 car that lasts for 200,000 miles costs you $0.15/mile or $450 one way for 3000 miles (I ignored age-based depreciation, but also didn't account for other costs like maintenance and insurance). At 30 mpg (because a car that a family of 6 can feel comfortable riding/sleeping in for 40 hours is not going to be a compact car), that's around $250 for gas. So you're at $700, or $1400 both ways. With advanced purchase, you can get flights from SFO to NYC for $250, so that's $1500 for your family of 6. I find it hard to get good sleep in a car, I can't imagine having a good experience trying to sleep 4 nights in a row. Nor can I imagine spending 40+ hours in the car over 4 days with the kids, even if they are sleeping a lot of that time.
- aidenn0 9y agoUsing similar calculations, we figured it at about $2k for our roadtrip last summer, so sounds right. However, flying: $550 after taxes and fees is the cheapest I've gotten an LAX/IAD roundtrip for in a while, so $3300 minimum for flying. Parking for 3 weeks is about $200 $3500 is the flying price, and often I can't get tickets for under $600 that match our schedule. Depending on the 405, it can take 3 hours to reach LAX and park. You really don't want to have to be running through the airport with little ones, so plan to be there 90 minutes before flight. It usually only 4 hours in the air going west-to-east (east-to-west is longer) but figure time sitting at the gate an taxiing means a minimum of 5 hours on the airplane. So nearly 10 hours of travel time. Issues with flying that were non-issue in car: We cannot change our schedule even by a few hours without incurring fees with the airline. LAX/IAD, plus price sensitivity means almost certainly flying United. I'm not paying the economy plus price times six, so my knees are touching the seat in front of me the entire time. We had a 20 month old, already nervous from flying for the first time fall asleep on the taxi-way with her seatbelt on, resting her head on my wife's lap. The flight attendent insisted she must be sitting up for takeoff. Said child was screaming for the next 90 minutes from being woken up. kid potty training? Not while flying, since the fasten seatbelt sign always goes on at the most inopportune times. It's true that none of these were enough to get us to stop flying (having a kid with PTSD was what did that; you don't want to be locked in a box with 200 strangers when he gets triggered), but it was surprising how much less stressful it was even compared to flying before we had him. Perhaps cross-country will still be niche, but certainly day-long road trips will jump in popularity when nobody has to do the driving.
- Al-Khwarizmi 9y agoIn Europe, it would be very rare for someone to drive for that long. They would take a train or plane. Anyway, indeed self-driving cars can be disruptive for long-distance travel, also in Europe. Suppose you are traveling between two small towns that are hundreds or thousands of km apart. I think the most reasonable model would be self-driving car from town A to nearest high-speed rail station, high-speed rail to station close to town B, and then self-driving car to town B. Rail companies could sell the ticket for the whole thing, and owning a car for long-distance travel would make no sense.
- pjc50 9y agoThe logical conclusion of this may be the self-driving RV as "tiny home". Especially given how expensive property prices are. Laws currently prevent you in some areas from "living in your car", but if you're exempt from that so long as the car is moving? Well then.
- speedplane 9y agoHa... If we can take that idea into a further extreme, we'll end up with Snow Piercer.