10 ms·
>>The public will accept the perceived risks in driverless rides. This is what I am trying to highlight - what, specifically, are these risks that people need
by samstave 9y ago
>>The public will accept the perceived risks in driverless rides.
This is what I am trying to highlight - what, specifically, are these risks that people need to be made aware of?
So now, in addition to everything, there will come a day when a person is stranded some-place as the driverless car couldnt exactly find them, and the person had to call the call center to get help and guess what... calling the call center for uber and lyft has been an "email us and we wil get back to you in 24 hours" type of thing, so imagine the following scenario which will happen in the next few years:
Person takes a driverless car to an event.
Person winds up being in an unsafe environment and needs immediate assistance.
Person gets into the driverless car way too intoxicated and passes out/overdoses/dies in the car -- need physical help?
So now we have driverless cars effectively classified as emergency ambulances - so assuming the CARNOC is paying attention, they then drive the car to the hospital - and have to have a mechanism to contact said hospital
I think that driverless cars have WAY too many factors that have literally been either not well thought out, or not openly discussed.
I am positive some of these questions have been asked - but I dont see any answers forthcoming.
Imagine the healthcare implications where if someone hasa seizure, ODs, cardiac, etc... what is the response time from the CARNOC, and getting them to a hospital ==> then what types of lawsuits will these companies see? what type of insurance will they require?
- nwatson 9y agoThese are companies with big purses and lots of human-factors personnel, and lots of lawyers that can write huge terms-of-service agreements, and cover legal costs and damages in lawsuits until they get it right. There are few better test beds for driverless cars than Phoenix metro, from technical, legal, and customer-concern viewpoints.
- samstave 9y agojeasus christ I dont know why you all are literally sticking your heads in the sand about asking questions and thinking answers. "because money" isnt a freaking answer to the questions I have posed - so fucking man up and answer if you know? Just because self driving tech is the new hotness doesnt mean that we can be ignorant to the consequenses and then thought-shame me for asking questions. An engineer of any of his salt should posit an answer, and I literally asked for an ELI5 to some of these things and was met by a bunch of jerks who think that these are stupid questions to ask. WTF HN?
- robotresearcher 9y agoThe basic answer is that, yes, at least until we all understand these things, they will have humans monitoring rides quite carefully. One person should be able to watch tens of rides at a time. At the very least, there will be a panic button that will get human support very quickly. I think people are not jazzed about your questions because this answer seems like common sense. And nobody, engineer or not, owes you an answer.
- Johnny555 9y agoSo now, in addition to everything, there will come a day when a person is stranded some-place as the driverless car couldnt exactly find them Ahh, if you think this is a new problem, you're too young to remember the fun of calling a cab by pay phone to some obscure address, then alternating between going inside and calling the dispatcher and then running out to the street to try to flag down the cab. At least with a driverless car I can pinpoint my location on a map when I call it. Person winds up being in an unsafe environment and needs immediate assistance. Existing car-share (and cab) drivers are also willing to drop you off in an unsafe environment if that's where you told him you want to go. While sometimes they'll stick around to make sure you make it to your door (if you're female), that's by no means guaranteed.
- samstave 9y agoim 42, so no not too young - and I appreciate your point. I feel that people are latching onto their opinions about driverless car tech and not talking about the wider implications. That is the point, I am poorly, making, apparently.... I just think that not all the questions have been asked about what it means to be a "driverless car" and that we need to run through all the risks -- and thats the one thing I find really lacking in any of these conversations at all.
- sharemywin 9y agodid you not read the terms of service when you opened the car door? they are not responsible.
- kllrnohj 9y ago> So now we have driverless cars effectively classified as emergency ambulances That's quite a huge leap you made there. Care to back up and explain how a drunk person calling an uber magically turns the uber into an emergency ambulance?
- samstave 9y agoThey manage to climb in, they OD/go into arrest, cant climb out. What then? So the uber now has to either get a person or take that car to a hospital - how do they know to do such? So is uber running a massive call center that watches every driverless ride and monitors the situation? Are they monitoring if people get into a fight in the car? That actually happened to me, where I took an uber pool, and the two other riders got into a physical fist fight in the car and the driver had to pull into a gas station and kick them out. How to monitor a potential rape? How to monitor unless your watching literally every ride.
- Ajedi32 9y ago> So the uber now has to either get a person or take that car to a hospital - how do they know to do such? It does? Why? What if the person passed out in their own, manually driven car? Would you expect that car to automatically call an ambulance? Just because you theoretically could have some kind of elaborate system that detects when the user falls unconscious and carries them to the hospital, doesn't mean that's _required_. > Are they monitoring if people get into a fight in the car? No. Why would they be? What makes you think that's necessary?
- maxerickson 9y agoThey will have to handle the case where the passenger doesn't exit the vehicle somehow or another. But the fact that it is occurring in an automated vehicle shouldn't make anyone worse off.
- TheCoreh 9y agoYa, this sounds like an easy problem to solve. If the passenger doesn't exit the vehicle after a set time, start a video call to a support central (perhaps the person is unable to get out because the doors won't unlock? or they fell asleep?) The attendant could then instruct the vehicle to go to a pre-specified location nearby where a human can intervene, call another vehicle or notify the competent authorities.
- Symbiote 9y agoReplace your driverless car with the driverless metro in Copenhagen, where you're only likely to see a metro employee in the busiest stations at peak times. Danish society hasn't yet collapsed. I think you're overstating the issues.
- samstave 9y agoIs that said metro attached to rails -- or does it take you along "lines" where you have to get out at a designated station and then walk 2 miles to you house -- or does it pick you up and take you directly to the market. Your comment is bullshit comparison if youre talking about comparing freaking rails with vehicles whos routes are 100% random per rider.
- newlyretired 9y ago> Person gets into the driverless car way too intoxicated and passes out/overdoses/dies in the car -- need physical help? > So now we have driverless cars effectively classified as emergency ambulances - so assuming the CARNOC is paying attention, they then drive the car to the hospital - and have to have a mechanism to contact said hospital > Imagine the healthcare implications where if someone hasa seizure, ODs, cardiac, etc... what is the response time from the CARNOC, and getting them to a hospital ==> then what types of lawsuits will these companies see? what type of insurance will they require? The comparison is useful because all of the above scenarios are possible in the Danish rail system.
- illirik 9y agoThere would be several bystanders in a typical Copenhagen rail car; they would be able to call for help. This wouldn't necessarily be the case in a driverless car; if the only passenger has a medical emergency, it would be up to the vehicle to detect that and take appropriate action.
- mynameisvlad 9y agoNot necessarily in the scenario they presented. While I haven't been in Copenhagen specifically, I've been in plenty of train cars late at night (think last few trains before service closes) where I'm the only person in the car. Just like a random onlooker could see you from the platform, someone in another car could see you in your driverless one and call emergency services. The two scenarios are very similar in the end. It's just that the train car has a higher (but far from 100%) chance that you will be noticed more quickly.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"So now we have driverless cars effectively classified as emergency ambulances - so assuming the CARNOC is paying attention, they then drive the car to the hospital - and have to have a mechanism to contact said hospital" They don't necessarily need to drive the person to the hospital. They could just call a real ambulance and wait in place for it.
- macintux 9y agoYeah, I suspect the liability issues arising from trying to take the person to the hospital would prove too steep. Ambulance + EMT assistance is a safer bet, even with the initial delay.