4 ms·
This is similar to the tactic used by Harvey Weinstein to discourage newspapers from reporting on rape allegations against him. Journalists that participated i
by michaelt 9y ago
This is similar to the tactic used by Harvey Weinstein to discourage newspapers from reporting on rape allegations against him.
Journalists that participated in the cover-up got access to his film premieres, parties at award ceremonies, interviews with celebrities and so on. Turns out that was enough to get every entertainment journalist to cover up his crimes for years.
Apparently people in Hollywood don't see any problem with this!
- bsder 9y ago> Apparently people in Hollywood don't see any problem with this! I suspect the bigger problem is that there are so few honest people involved in the business that you would have to shut down if you broke off association with everybody doing shady things in Hollywood. While I'm pleased to see Weinstein going down, I keep scratching my head about "We know that there are people in Hollywood doing far worse things. Why the focus on Weinstein in particular? Something smells kind of fishy ..."
- pault 9y agoI wonder if the child sex abuse problem in hollywood will ever be blown wide open like this current scandal was. I imagine it is comparably widespread and it's a /much/ greater threat to the reputations of those involved, so really any measures to keep it covered up would seem justifiable those on the inside.
- notyourday 9y agoHollywood still defends Polanski. Hollywood still attacks RMG. Hollywood still defends Ben Afflec. Hollywood still has not kicked Tarantino/Clooney/Matt Daemon out for covering it up. Netflix/Amazon/HBO still has not dropped everything that Harvey the Stain makes money off from its catalogs. House of Cards has been canceled but not pulled. It is simply posturing.
- praneshp 9y ago> Netflix/Amazon/HBO still has not dropped everything that Harvey the Stain makes money off from its catalogs. For what? Hasn't being fired from his company, etc, stopped Harvey the Stain from making money anyway? If not, make that happen. It's stupid to drop all movies he produced; I'd probably cancel Netflix if they did that.
- notyourday 9y agoBecause if the solution is to punish a person not an entity that protected that person then nothing would change. Also, he operated as an officer of the company.
- praneshp 9y agoSure, but Netflix/you/me are not the authorities that get to "punish".
- SauciestGNU 9y agoAdditionally, what's to gain by making art unavailable to the public? Many of the things these people produced are very high quality artistically. Polanski is responsible for Chinatown for instance. Limiting the reach of these works ould not be a good thing for society. What we need is a mass critical reevaluation to help us better understand these works in the context of these monstrous artists/producers.
- ksk 9y agoI think it is a bit of a moral gray area. Should one use data from unethical human experiments that were already conducted, and the perpetrators punished (e.g. Nazi doctors)?
- ConceptJunkie 9y agoThis is true. For whatever reason, Weinstein was thrown under the bus, but he's not even the tip of the iceberg. There have been a few cases of women being emboldened enough to call out a few others, but I suspect all this will blow over in a few months and the vast majority of the real abuse, harassment and other horrible behavior will go back to being swept under the rug. Also, reading back over this I'm not sure there's enough room to shoehorn another cliche into that couple of paragraphs. :-/
- gooseus 9y agoMy assumption is that he upset some other powerful people who then allowed this to happen. Reminds me of a line from Rules for Rulers by CGP Grey: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs It's not the people's revolt that overthrows the king, it's the court who are overthrowing the king by allowing the people's revolt to progress... because the king has stopped providing them with enough treasure to keep him propped up. My guess is that something changed the political calculus for his key supporters and they either precipitated this or allowed it to happen. For sure there are other abusers who are probably showering their allies in treasure to keep them loyal so they don't get caught up in this.
- r00fus 9y agoIt's also the tactic used by the Bush administration to deal with negative reporting... limit their access to white house pressers and the President. Probably something done a lot in politics.
- L_Rahman 9y agoAt a lower level, this is the game everyone who participates in "access journalism" is playing. Journalists and publications build relationships with sources and report stories keeping one eye on the writing/impact/truthfulness and another on the long term relationship with the sources. That's the implied norm of institution (business/government) relationships with the media - we maintain relationships, you write about us and some stories will be critique us so we'll soft cut your access off for a little bit but not explicitly and then we'll let you in again. An example would the one you yourself made. Journalists join the White House press corps, and over time get access to various West Wing staffers to write stores. (if you're wondering whether this mechanism contributes to status quo bias and protection of established interests you're headed in the right direction :) ) Access journalism is distinct from investigative journalism which is what we're seeing here. Investigative journalism assumes journalistic independence and a more adversarial relationship with the institution being documented. What we hope to see after an expose like this is the institution coming to terms with its behavior and in response to public outcry, tempering the things that were revealed. The problem of course is that institutional power in the United States, especially that of large corporations, is so large that they respond to this kind of journalism with aggression. I don't know whether Disney will suffer for making that choice, but I hope that they do.
- Mountain_Skies 9y agoSame thing happens with pro sports teams, especially when it comes to coverage of stadium subsidies. If you want year around free content via access to players and staff, you can't report anything that harms the business side of the operation. So now almost every local media outlet cheerleads for new stadiums and arenas to be paid for by public dollars.