2 ms·
The claim that Econ 101 does not apply to the labour market is a pretty extreme claim. If the studies aren't showing a consensus, I'm betting on Econ 101. Note
by roenxi 9y ago
The claim that Econ 101 does not apply to the labour market is a pretty extreme claim. If the studies aren't showing a consensus, I'm betting on Econ 101. Note that below, jasode has pointed out that the 1994 Card & Krueger study was based on phone surveys rather than payroll data.
There is some real and interesting debate on the question of should the cost of minimum living standards be borne by companies (through the minimum wage) or governments (through straight welfare). I'd love to see a compromise where it was still economic to do low-value work that is currently not done due to minimum wages.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoIt's not really an extreme claim. Honestly, if you're speaking on economic issues and the model you're using only has two lines: Supply and Demand, you really shouldn't be speaking. Here is a good little blog about how the S/D graph for labor is unscientific. http://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2016/12/an-econ-theory-falsified.html http://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2016/12/an-econ-theory-fa...
- roenxi 9y agoYou hit a nerve there. 1) The economy is everyone's business, especially when governments get involved. It is better for us all if things are discussed publicly, politely and with all views available (albeit, potentially rebutted). 2) Arguing that something that looks like a reasonably competitive market is not a reasonably competitive market is an extreme claim. Low-wage labour might not be a competitive market, but the evidence bar for showing that is still high. 3) Your article is a good read, but it has 2 bits of data that I'm already happy to agree with: 3.a) There is more going on with immigration than supply and demand; skills transfer is a big deal and I would expect migrants to have more gumption because they have shown some initiative migrating. 3.b) Raising the minimum wage obviously doesn't always have a "big immediate negative impact". The magnitude of the negative impact might be fast, slow, big or small based on how carefully the minimum wage is set. But the politics of minimum wages don't look like they are being imposed on the basis of a straightfoward economic case. They are being set first by politicians, justified second by some economists.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>2) Arguing that something that looks like a reasonably competitive market is not a reasonably competitive market is an extreme claim. Low-wage labour might not be a competitive market, but the evidence bar for showing that is still high. Why do you believe it looks like a reasonably competitive market? Tons of studies have been done on minimum wage effects and the conclusions are at least indecisive. If this is a reasonably competitive market why is it so hard to definitively show that? It's not like it's hard to prove competitive markets - anyone can do a study where you take say gas stations, lower the price per gallon at one and watch them pull more customers. >the evidence bar for showing that is still high. Surely the evidence bar is just as high to show that it is a competitive market? This is another problem I have with Econ 101 - the idea that the default state of a market you don't understand is competitive is a political idea, not an economic one. >1) The economy is everyone's business, especially when governments get involved. It is better for us all if things are discussed publicly, politely and with all views available (albeit, potentially rebutted). Sure, I also live in the world and exist in a physical system so it's also my business which interpretation of quantum physics is correct. But I recognize that my existence in a system and my understanding of it are separate so I don't walk around lauding the Copenhagen interpretation (or walk into any other dispute in physics) because I read a few pop-sci articles on it. I feel the same way here. The challenge for scientifically minded laymen in the 21st century is that you can't "know everything." I believe that's also true for economics and a humbling here would serve everyone well. If you walked into an econ forum and found a thread about programming and it was filled with stuff about how functions are bad, no one needs version control and a bunch of quantum computing gobbledygook, you'd probably try to correct them. And when you discovered that they held these beliefs not because they didn't know anything about programming (although they didn't) but because these beliefs somehow validated their existing political view of the world and thus they couldn't be talked out of it you might throw your hands up. My previous comment could (rightfully) be interpreted as me throwing my hands up. >But the politics of minimum wages don't look like they are being imposed on the basis of a straightfoward economic case. They are being set first by politicians, justified second by some economists. Is that not exactly what is going on in this thread? A bunch of people with a fundamentally political disagreement about the minimum wage desperately hunting for economic validation of their belief? In this thread we are all the politicians in your example, stumbling into subjects we know nothing about and finding post hoc rationalizations for what we already "know."
- notahacker 9y agoTo be honest, that's a surprisingly poor article from Noahpinion. The Economics 101 explanation for immigration not depressing wages is that it increases labour demand as well as labour supply (which is of course a well established fact). Shift the labour demand curve and you can make the labour supply curve as inelastic as you like (he appears to concede that in the follow up blog). I wouldn't expect any more than 1 mark out of 5 for answering an actual Economics 101 term paper and not acknowledging that effect.
- lordCarbonFiber 9y agoYou need only think about the axioms under which the traditional S/D graph holds true, to realize labor likely represents a distorted market. 1) Goods are fungible (spend 5 minutes interviewing for technology and come back and try to defend this one) 2) There exists "perfect" competition (that is to say any supplier can enter or exit the market, and there's full knowledge on the marginal utility of all goods) The nature of labor muddies these waters and the world turns out to be a lot more complicated than econ 101 (notice that those axioms are almost never true regardless of market).
- emodendroket 9y agoThe whole point is that the Econ 101 model is deliberately simplified way beyond reality to be assimilable by people learning the topic for the first time.