8 ms·
This is extrapolating from a pretty small data set, and worse, the data set was collected in circumstances different from the ones it's being used to make predi
by _delirium 16y ago
This is extrapolating from a pretty small data set, and worse, the data set was collected in circumstances different from the ones it's being used to make predictions in. It's quite possible stocks will go up in the 2010s, but the fact that stocks went up in the 1940s after losing a bunch in the 1930s isn't a very good reason to think so--- the pattern is extremely weak, and collected from a data set that isn't nearly big enough to falsify these kinds of pattern inferences.
But nonetheless, you can still do better analysis than these kinds of eyeball-the-chart analyses. Does this prediction of cyclic returns hold up under some attempt to retroactively test it, e.g. via cross-validation?
And of course that's ignoring the bigger problem, that it's quite possible average returns in the 21st century will not be as good as average returns in the 20th century were, making any extrapolation too optimistic.
- maigret 16y agoThis whole stock story I found also a bit doubtful. Mint is obviously selling its product ;) But a quite boring fixed interest saving plan would do the same effect, probably with less return but with more security.
- cageface 16y agoExactly. In fact, I'd say it's much more reasonable to expect stocks to do worse in this century. Physical resources are going to be tougher to acquire and more expensive and major scientific advances are going to be more difficult. It won't surprise me at all if the cheap, easy growth of the 19th-20th centuries turns out to be the exception, not the norm. I expect a lot of the current hype and froth around social networking and the web is going to turn out to be no more monetizable than it was ten years ago when people were making similar handwaving arguments about revenue and profitability. I suppose Asia might buck the trend but a portfolio highly skewed in that direction now is a fairly speculative investment.
- REALLYHUGENEKO 16y agoStocks are, generally, fairly speculative. If they weren't, everyone would invest in stocks. The person this article imagined had an unfair advantage- he knew that the decades upcoming would see stock upturns, so stocks were not as speculative. Still, stocks just need to beat the rate of inflation. I can easily see them doing that after they've fallen so much.
- Unseelie 16y agoA diversified stock portfolio is betting on economic growth. The economy has grown consistently for the last six hundred years.
- _delirium 16y agoWell, it's betting on some other factors as well, like the portion of the growth that publicly held firms will capture (versus more of the growth going to new startups or privately held firms). A stock portfolio is by necessity non-diversified on that measure, though large investors can diversify by putting money into VC, angel, and private-equity funds, among other things. It's probably also geographically non-diversified, since some of the fastest-growing markets are hard to buy into (e.g. China is very picky about what kinds of shares it lets foreign investors buy).
- chopsueyar 16y agoSo what stocks have you been trading since 1410AD?
- chopsueyar 16y agoI think you would be surprised at the number of people who own stocks, either through a retirement account (401k, Roth), or a brokerage account. They may not own many shares, but they are invested in stocks.
- gnaritas 16y agoI think you'd be surprised at the number of people who don't own stocks and don't even have a 401k or any other type of retirement plan, and I bet they outnumber those who do.
- xiaoma 16y agoI suggest reading some of Siegel's books. There are good records going back two hundred years. The stock market has beaten every other asset class, every single decade between 1810 and now. You might make an argument that things will change due to a technological singularity, but stock performance has been remarkably consistent over the long run. http://caps.fool.com/Blogs/1802-2009-performance-of/282249 http://caps.fool.com/Blogs/1802-2009-performance-of/282249
- fanboy123 16y agoMy lifetime might not be long enough for "the long run." Any longer than that and your 200 years means very little.
- Unseelie 16y agoThe argument is that stocks have been the best asset class investment in each decade for the last two hundred years, not that it takes two hundred years. I'm going to guess that you'll live for at least another decade, and tell you to go right ahead and consider that the long run. If you've any multiples of decades, you're even more set.
- _delirium 16y agoThat certainly isn't true. For example, stocks were not the best asset class in the 2000s (bonds did much better this past decade). The linked page is just giving broad "stocks are generally better", but isn't doing decade-by-decade comparisons (which would be interesting to see).
- Unseelie 16y agoGranted. But aside from the last decade, the article does claim that stocks win. (from 1930 to 1996). The recent decade is astoundingly bad...especially considering all the neat, new things we've gained..
- 16y ago
- cageface 16y agoI've also read in many places that the truly wealthy don't invest in the open market at all, but rather in private investment funds with high barriers to entry and much better, on average, returns.
- trunnell 16y agoThe article is referring to the business cycle, a well-established economic phenomenon of unpredictable cycles of expansion and contraction. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_cycle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_cycle > This is extrapolating from a pretty small data set I wouldn't call the last century of the US stock market a small data set. Perhaps what you mean is that the author's choice of decade-long windows is too arbitrary? But regardless, the business cycle is a broadly accepted and easily observable phenomenon. Exactly what causes these cyclic fluctuations is hotly debated (at least it was ten years in my macro-econ classes.) > it's quite possible average returns in the 21st century will not be as good as average returns in the 20th century The article wasn't arguing that one should expect those exact returns, but rather that positive returns are cyclical-- good times generally follow bad times.