3 ms·
There are so many factors here that it is difficult to assess the article. The key for me, which doesn't seem to be discussed, is asking why did the doctors opt
by roenxi 9y ago
There are so many factors here that it is difficult to assess the article. The key for me, which doesn't seem to be discussed, is asking why did the doctors opt for a slower procedure?
If they have a financial incentive to keep the patient in the operating theater for longer, that is a problem and needs to be addressed. If they are slowly learning a new technique (as the article seems to be hinting) that is normal but interesting. If they are using a more precise technique to bring complicated cases up to the average outcome, that is praiseworthy and should be lauded.
This article is interesting regardless, but there isn't enough in it to draw a conclusion.
- wodenokoto 9y agoI went to a symposium on assessing the value and future investment in robotic surgery a few years ago. Figuring out if it is cheaper or not, than regular surgery is surprisingly difficult. For simple procedures, you might ask junior staff to do it with a robot, to get them training on the robot - compared to sending staff of to seminars, this is actually cheap, even though it is more expensive than regular surgery. You might also ask junior doctors to do a slower, more expensive job on a robot to get their performance up to the same level as expert staff. And even experienced surgeons might opt for using the somewhat scarce resource only for difficult cases. So you might end up with the same surgeon, on the same type of procedure, having a worse track record on the robot, because the severity of each case is not recorded in the statistic!
- walshemj 9y agoProbably less invasive surgery has less side effects and better outcomes