10 ms·
Bob Lutz: Kiss the good times goodbye: The auto industry's change curve
- taylodl 9y agoIt can't come soon enough as far as I'm concerned, though my 15 year old daughter who's anxiously waiting to learn to drive may see things differently. She could very well be amongst the last people who learn how to drive. The article doesn't discuss how far-ranging these impacts will be. Automakers and dealerships are just the tip of the iceberg. Part suppliers are impacted, as well as auto insurers and gasoline filling stations. Perhaps less obvious are auto repair shops of all stripes, auto repair stores, parking garages...this is a HUGE impact to the U.S. economy. It's amazing how little discussion this is getting beyond unemployed taxicab drivers.
- swampthinker 9y agoIt's not sexy talking about how we have the potential to put millions of Americans out of jobs, and would rather handwave the discussion with a "Oh they said the same thing during the industrial revolution."
- zlynx 9y agoPresent your argument that we'd be better off with 500,000 people employed as farmers and ditch diggers working by hand without automation and equipment.
- lobotryas 9y agoYes, of course. How is this even a question? If we had the resources to give 500,000 people a living wage, a home, health care, in exchange for performing a completely meaningless task then that would be a pretty good deal (that many would also be happy to take).
- traek 9y agoAnything society has the resources to do now, we’ll have the resources to do after the advent of driverless cars. Driverless cars will strictly increase productivity—they let us produce more output with the same input of labor and capital. So no, it is not better to give people resources for performing a completely meaningless task. If the task were completely meaningless then we could provide them the same resources without requiring the labor. Neo-Luddites arguing against driverless cars are fighting the wrong thing. Their fight should be distribution of wealth created, not against innovation that increases productivity and makes our lives collectively easier.
- ryandvm 9y agoYou're basically suggesting the broken window fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window Basically, it's foolish to have people do unnecessary work because in doing so you have squandered time and resources that could have been spent creating additional value.
- yequalsx 9y agoThe broken windows fallacy is not apt in terms of what lobotryas wrote. If we had enough resources so that everyone had a home, health care, and access to a livable amount of money each month then that would be good. Wouldn’t it? Lobotryas did not state how to accomplish this. Just said it’d be great if we lived in such a world.
- uoaei 9y ago>in exchange for a completely meaningless task Why don't we just give them the money and care instead? Then they can actually do something useful with their time.
- tomjen3 9y agoYou can co further: with a SDC the kids can drive themselves to school, you can drive home after a night out and, assuming your job can be done (at least partially) behind a laptop, you can essentially have zero commute and little issue with rush-hour (even if everybody works the same hours people will arrive at stacked times because they have different distances to work) add all that up and it ends up being sensible to live a long way from your place of work, which means that cheap houses out in nowhere suddenly become a lot more attractive and appartments in the city will trade at a smaller premium.
- Doctor_Fegg 9y agoWhat the fuck is up with the scrolling on this article. (Mobile Safari.)
- avn2109 9y agoThe article mentions "handset providers" as a thing that General Motors doesn't want to be. I'd like to observe that "a handset provider" is the most valuable public company on earth.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoThat's one handset provider who captures about 95% of all the profits in the industry while the others fight over table scraps. General Motors knows they won't be Tesla and they don't exactly looking forward to fighting over table scraps.
- BoorishBears 9y agoWhat makes you think Tesla won’t be fighting for scraps while a company like GM does?
- fenwick67 9y ago> Unfortunately, I think this is the demise of automotive retailing as we know it. I wouldn't start this sentence with "Unfortunately".
- epx 9y agoI don't think it will happen anytime soon. I can see autonomous car mode enabled in " controlled" environments like highways and advanced cities but there are a lot of countryside roads and trails where even cell phones don't work.
- Theodores 9y agoIn the UK I don't imagine B roads or smaller being autonomous and the UK road structure is different to the US highways in many ways that make autonomous driving that bit harder. The bit I am seeing is private ownership of cars with a view to the batteries in the car partnering up with their solar panel and cheap overnight electricity. In this mode the car plays a really important role in evening out the peak power demands on the grid by selling electricity back at a higher rate than purchased overnight. Due to the culture of private ownership I see people getting electric plugs on the lamppost in their street, hooking up to that and buying their electric car on a favourable 5 year lease arrangement. It is very much the family vehicle with child-seats and whatnot permanently installed. These cars will be conventionally driven except on A roads and motorways when the car is allowed to drive. There will still be some expectation of the driver being at the wheel. There are trucks from all over Europe, until that guy from Turkey also has an electric, self-driving truck then the road is not going to be a fully automated zone, as proposed in the article. If you don't own an electric car then you won't be able to use it to even out the power demand at home, you would need a Tesla PowerWall or equivalent to store your solar and do that. I am not seeing people buy those things as quickly as they are buying iPhones. Most people don't even have decent insulation. The ownership of the car jumpstarts this transformation in how we use the electric grid and gets people involved in a way 'Uber' services will not.
- pzone 9y ago20 years is not soon enough. My mother is aging and I don't want her to lose her mobility.
- dvtv75 9y agoIf you have the cash, then start investing in research, perhaps? Although I really don't know if that will speed things up any.
- Game_Ender 9y agoHas she consider using Uber of Lyft as they are right now?
- r00fus 9y agoMy parents have given up driving. The cost of the occasional Lyft is less than what they would have paid for insurance, gas and the car payments.
- hprotagonist 9y agoMy counter to this line of thinking, when it's come up in conversations before, is this: Horses are still legally permitted on basically all of the roads they were before automobiles were invented. Granted, they're generally quite rare, expensive to maintain, and a luxury ... but they're still with us.
- dustinmoorenet 9y agoHorses have been relegated to back country roads. If there is any amount of traffic, the horses are on the shoulder of roads, in the grass. I have never seen a horse on an interstate or highway.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- romwell 9y agoThe OP's point still stands. There were no interstates or highways in the horse-and-buggy era.
- santaclaus 9y ago> I have never seen a horse on an interstate or highway. Take a drive through Lancaster, PA. First time I saw a horse and buggy on the highway I was kind of freaked out.
- King-Aaron 9y agoExactly, cars will become what horses became. Things for enthusiasts to enjoy.
- romwell 9y agoThe point is, Lutz's future where you'll have to sell your car for scrap will probably not come. It might make sense to do so, but you won't have to. And, unlike a horse, a car doesn't require much to keep. If you have space to keep it (which, unless you live in a very densely populated urban area, you absolutely do), why wouldn't you? And on that note, if I could keep a pony for free, I would keep one too.
- igetspam 9y agoFrom my cold, dead hands... My wife and I were discussing American culture today and some of the reasons we'll be hard pressed to do anything to solve our present issues with mass shootings and I look at car culture and see the same kind of value. Americans aren't really good at giving up freedom, for any reason, no matter how many people will die. Cars and driving represent a freedom that I don't think we're going to be giving up any time soon. As you likely assumed from my first line, I'm part of the side that would fight tooth and nail against any attempts to legislate away independently owned and operated automobiles. I won't waste any time trying to convince people who hate cars that I'm right but I'll tell you that Uber doesn't come near my house and that's a perk. I live 30+ miles outside of the nearest "city" and loooooooove driving/riding (motorcycles) back roads and hills. I'm not trading in my car or truck or jeep or bike or bike for a blob that slips in and out of a pneumatic tube, no matter how much I love Futurama. ps- Some of my neighbors ride their horses on the same road I drive. We wave.
- sitharus 9y agoI agree, but I think automated vehicles will begin to dominate city and bulk freight transport. I wouldn't be surprised if automated vehicle only lanes start appearing on freeways with a higher speed limit, or dedicated parallel roadways. You can certainly move more people faster without the human in the loop. I think what this article misses is that although non-owned automated vehicles would be great for commuting or leisure activities they wouldn't be great for shopping or road trips. There's going to be a place for the personal car for a long time.
- yequalsx 9y agoConsidering that you are a not a city dweller and most people are (I include suburbs and exurbs in this) I think it quite possible your view is not normative. I don’t hate cars. But I can’t wait for the day I can go without ownership of one. What I do love is not the car but the freedom it gives. If I can replace car ownership without giving up that freedom then I will gladly do so.
- WalterBright 9y ago> Americans aren't really good at giving up freedom, for any reason, no matter how many people will die. Another way to look at it is a lot of Americans risked their lives for our freedoms, and a large percentage of them died for it. The price of freedom is always blood. We should be exceedingly careful about giving up freedoms so dearly purchased.
- rrhd 9y agoI feel like we should start organizing the resistance to this "you just call for it" now. I liek my car. I like owning my car. I like keeping my random stuff in my car. I like being able to jump in my car and go on a trip if I want. I like having my dog in my car. How is "oh well you just call for a car" better?
- nathanaldensr 9y agoI suspect the mindset is a rather typical one: "I don't value what a personal car gives me, therefore no one does (or should)."
- nrb 9y agoI think the mindset is probably closer to "tens of thousands of people each year are needlessly dying a preventable death, and many times more people are injured" With that ideology, you are already ready to give up control of the vehicle. It's not much of a jump from there to give up ownership, especially if that means only paying for what you use and not having to constantly maintain it.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoThat's great. I like my car too. I think it's important to note, though, that while I enjoy owning my car I do not enjoy paying for it. If there was a reasonable alternative to that $10,000 a year luxury that is car ownership, many people would take that alternative. They might take it gladly or take it reluctantly, but they would still take it.
- BRAlNlAC 9y ago>a reasonable alternative to that $10,000 a year luxury that is car ownership This fundamentally isn't true. I've had a used Camry for almost a decade and the annual cost of ownership including purchase price, maintenance, registration and insurance is around 2,500 dollars. It has given me a place to store my things when I have limited housing, it is always ready with all my effects when I want to leave, and I am very much in tune with how the car should feel when it is on the road which gives me considerable comfort. Politically, expect any sort of legislation trying to force "legacy" cars off the road as being anti-poor, because it is. Cars don't have to be expensive.
- harshaw 9y agoMy intuition is this seems like futuristic thinking that you might have found from the 60's where everyone thought we would have bases on the moon and flying cars. I'd love if someone could post some well written rebutals.
- ameister14 9y agoI don't think it's quite that far fetched - the reason we don't have flying cars or moon bases is that neither was actually all that desirable; neither was better than what we have by enough of a margin to make the short-term capital investment worth it. The same doesn't really hold true for driverless cars. It appears they will be cheaper, traffic and road safety would improve significantly and we're already now used to calling for a car with the push of a button on our mobile phones. Plus, we've already got billions being put into the development of them, by real public companies with a lot of shareholders and boards to answer to. We never really had that with flying cars or moon-bases.
- deathanatos 9y agoRiiiighht. > traveling at 120, 150 mph. The speed doesn't matter. What about pedestrians? Or an animal, such as a moose, that wanders, or bounds, onto the roadway from the nearby forest? Even an autonomous vehicle, even a group of autonomous vehicles traveling as a well coordinated group, need to be able to stop for the person/moose, or they risk killing their occupant or that person. (or the moose.) The top speed will be dependent on how far you can clear around the vehicle. (A quick Google says a speed of 150mph has a stopping distance for a car of a fifth of mile!) > in 15 to 20 years — at the latest That is, by 2037, there will be no vehicles that aren't fully autonomous. It won't happen. Even if the technology manages to progress that far, I doubt society is capable of that kind of rapid deprecation, even if we limit it to just the mainland US. > Everyone will have five years to get their car off the road or sell it for scrap or trade it on a module. Such legislation is going to be terrible for the individual; how are you going to propose that people make such a selfless trade, because in my experience, they'll never do it. For some people, you're going to legislate away their current means of transport, require them to start paying either for a new vehicle or for the cost of renting one (through a provider, e.g., Uber, counts as renting), and expect them to be fine with it, when for some folks, this might be hugely financially harmful? > That is the death knell for companies such as BMW, Mercedes-Benz and Audi. Seems to me like they could easily pivot to making luxury cars (which isn't really a pivot?); want a decent ride? $X. Want nice ride? $Y, where Y > X. There will still be people who want to go from point A to point B, and other people who want to do so in style. > computer terminals with full connectivity. No, there will be WiFi. Maybe. And unless we make big improvements to mobile connectivity (which in 20 years, hopefully we will), it must be limited by that. > This transition will be largely complete in 20 years. That would be nice, but I just don't see us going from "I can't buy a fully autonomous vehicle" to "manually cars are illegal" in 20 years. I'm still also curious about a few aspects of (what I know are hypothetical, since nothing is on the market yet) autonomous vehicles: * Will it bend the law, particular during the transition when there is a mix of human and computer driven vehicles? I, as a human, will regularly bend the absolute letter of the law to keep myself and others on the road safe: e.g., to avoid hazards, to allow a motorcycle to lane-split, because I don't believe the fool next to me will remain in his lane, etc. I.e., I'd rather be alive than right, as the old saying goes.) * Navigation of a car is sometimes a hideously complex thing. E.g., I need to stop on a long road trip. I might not know where, yet, but we need to take the next exit. Today's mapping apps have always, in my experience as a user, failed terribly here: searching for something always shows results in a X mile radius around you; this includes useless results that are behind me, or completely irrelevant due to being hard to get to.
- daodedickinson 9y agoMeanwhile, I saw an amazing cabin this fall that had a stunningly low price because it still requires fording a major river to access.
- RickJWag 9y agoLutz is the visionary who brought us the Pontiac Aztec. I hope is vision is just as good here.
- linksnapzz 9y agoWrong wrong wrong. Lutz arrived at GM just as the Aztek/Rendezvous were being released, way, way after anything could be done about it; in fact, in one of his recent books he talks in detail about the process failures at GM that resulted in those cars as well as others being sent to market when even many people inside the company were acknowledging that they were nowhere near what they needed to be to be competitive.
- fulafel 9y agoBizarre that co2 emissions are not mentioned in the article or the first couple of pages of comments here. That's the obvious high bit of why private car culture is unsustainable and immoral.
- neo4sure 9y agoGood thing he is finally admitting reality. Did this guy regularly come on tv to bach Tesla?
- richardknop 9y agoI am in a minority of skeptics in this case. I still believe that the "imminent" arrival of autonomous cars on scale is a pie in the sky and it will take many more decades to really make this leap. I believe we are in the same time period as AI was during 50s, 60s, 70s when huge promises of great things it would achieve were made but it took many more decades before AI started to really take off (meaning just recently). I believe Waymo and others are still in very early stage and it will take decades to get reliable enough product which can be rolled out en masse.