7 ms·
If you unplugged Apple's board (or given decision-making apparatus) and plugged in a (currently nonexistent) AI with the parameter "Maximize Profit," would you
by komali2 9y ago
If you unplugged Apple's board (or given decision-making apparatus) and plugged in a (currently nonexistent) AI with the parameter "Maximize Profit," would you see a different result? I think not. I think we'd see things far more morally horrifying, in fact, with just enough PR makeup to ensure "maximized profit."
Unsure why we laud capitalism and then act horrified at the result. Here in America we've made our decision - profit rules above all else. It is more profitable to lobby congress than it is to upgrade a refinery, it's more profitable to auto-deny every health insurance claim than it is to provide the services your customers think they're paying for, it's more profitable to avoid taxes than not (as long as you can avoid breaking the law TOO hard).
- hashmal 9y agoIt is easy to blame Apple (and other big companies) when the real problem is that governments are incapable of taming these companies.
- AckSyn 9y agoAll Apple is doing is completely legal. Avoiding taxes by using foreign methods isn't unlawful tax evasion, only failing to pay what is owed. The root of the cause is the insane tax requirements governments push onto corporations (people too) for doing national and international business. It's natural for them avoid excessive taxes through whatever methods they can legally do so.
- colemannugent 9y agoI see your point about the bad side of capitalism, but consider that this kind of abuse is only possible because the governments allow it. No economic system can live up to its design when corrupt governments interfere with it.
- aaron-lebo 9y agogovernments allow it corrupt governments interfere with it Are those not in opposition? Another solution is a better breed of business that doesn't see $ as the most important thing in the world, but not sure how you change that. Capitalism can and should be a conduit for innovation without outright greed.
- cortesoft 9y agoThey are in opposition in the same way 'we need to drink water to live' and 'don't drown' are in opposition. Just because something is bad at the extremes doesn't mean it is always bad. We need a government that steps in to address the well known issues with unfettered capitalism (externalities, tragedy of the commons, etc).
- aaron-lebo 9y agoYou're right of course, just not sure whether the poster was saying this was due to government overreach or a lack of government action.
- civilian 9y agoI was working for a tech company that liked to pride itself on being "one of the good guys". They gave us pretty lavish benefits, that often seemed kind of silly, and had a massive well-designed office. Although the office was still an open office, and suffered from those aspects. They recently had to lay off 60 of their ~200 people. What would have been better? Should they have been greedier, given fewer benefits, and prevented the layoffs? Or should they have given more benefits, and not had layoffs, and simply collapse in bankruptcy in a couple years? Money gives you options, and it is the tool which enables us to provide for people. I think your anti-greed position just... misses the point.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoNot using a "massive well-designed office" would be a start. They probably didn't need 200 people, either. If you will look at most tech companies, they are poorly run. Github lost $66 million in 2016 hosting code. You don't gotta be Warren Buffet to know that something is wrong with that setup. The greed aspect comes into the everything needs to be big, because for too many companies the end goal is not the product, but money. That's greed. That's not just a failing of morality but a practical failure of building sustainable businesses.
- nilved 9y agoExcept anarchism, of course.
- mannykannot 9y agoNice try, but there is not much point in considering the corrupted without also taking a look at who is doing the corrupting.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- snowpanda 9y agoIs it really "corrupting" though if the government allows it? It's wrong, but not corrupt (yet).
- fredley 9y agoThis is not the fault of Capitalism alone. In a healthy democracy, the people vote in the Government, who can impose fines, tariffs, penalties and such on companies and business practices that the people (via the people they elect) deem to be working against them. Sadly, as you point out, this creates a direct incentive to lobby or otherwise attempt to control Government by large and powerful companies. The only way to prevent this is to impose fines, tariffs and penalties on businesses undertaking this behaviour (effectively disincentivising it financially), since it fundamentally unbalances the power dynamic between Government and business. However if you've got nobody left to elect who will fight that corner for you, you're kinda stuck.
- fleitz 9y agoThe people of Ireland have democracy, perhaps they have different views on taxation than you do. It may come as a surprise to you but some people aren't so greedy as to believe that they are entitled to the fruits of other's labour.
- kunimu 9y ago"some people aren't so greedy as to believe that they are entitled to the fruits of other's labour." There is a distinct and strong sense of unaware irony in this comment.
- the_mitsuhiko 9y agoMost Irish citizens had no idea about the extend of this.
- barrkel 9y agoI think most Irish people are aware that the primary appeal of the country to multinationals is as a tax-efficient English-speaking common law bridge into the EU, in approximately that order. The specific amounts flowing across the bridge, no, I don't think people are generally aware of the numbers. But because it is a bridge, we Irish don't really have a strong claim on that money: the revenue was generated somewhere else, and it's going somewhere else, it's just resting in Ireland for a while. There's a bunch of hypocritical talk from other EU countries criticising Irish tax rates, all the while having lots of carveouts and tax breaks of their own that reduce supposedly high rates to nearly nothing in various deals. For example, France has an effective rate of about 8% on profits for companies in the the CAC40. Luxembourg is much worse, it's practically a tax haven that avoids being listed as such somehow, probably down to location. In principle I'm in favour of something like the common consolidated corporate tax base. The problem with taxing multinationals comes down to game theory: if there's a common market between countries, there's a race to the bottom in tax rates for hosting multinationals. So there needs to be a pact.
- sol_remmy 9y agoIf you unplugged the government's board (or given decision-making apparatus) and plugged in a (currently nonexistent) AI with the parameter "Maximize Power of Government," would you see a different result? I think not. ----- My point is that you are implying government is the alternative ("they will govern morally! academics will keep them in check! journalists will keep them in check!") then you need to rethink your conclusions
- sp332 9y agoIf it's some kind of representative government, then it would be "the government will push back on anything that threatens the interests of the majority." If you had a power-maximizing AI instead of politicians, it should still court voters.
- MisterBastahrd 9y agoYour reply is pure libertarian silliness. The government hasn't remotely maximized its power.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoDidn't see that implication. Isn't the more obvious solution to have a mixture of effective government and business? We're not talking about going from capitalism to communism, we're asking one of the wealthiest companies in the world to pay their fair share of taxes like the person making $40k does. It's not either or.
- klodolph 9y agoHow are you inferring that government is the alternative? I don't see that implication.
- jimmaswell 9y agoTighter corporate tax regulations as a slippery slope to government oppression? I'm not seeing it.
- komali2 9y ago>if you are implying government is the alternative I implied nothing on purpose, though I understand people will find meaning in other's words on their own. What sort of solutions do you have in mind, if not governmental? Or do you not think solutions are necessary (that this isn't a problem)?
- GCU-Empiricist 9y agoIsn't that a board's fiduciary duty to their stockholders? To put it differently would you buy stock in a board that doesn't act this way, would a mutual fund? Which way do you expect the mutual fund's proxies to vote when electing the board? Multi-polar coordination (competition markets) have a lot of bad Nash-equilibrium states, but they are better than any command market in history.
- mitchty 9y agoNo, it is not a boards fiduciary duty to maximize profits at the expense of all else for stockholders. This is a myth. There is no legal basis for this claim. https://hbr.org/2010/04/the-myth-of-shareholder-capitalism https://hbr.org/2010/04/the-myth-of-shareholder-capitalism So to take your differently put question, would I buy stock in a company that doesn't act this way? Hell yes I would. It means they're likely adults and not just looking out purely for the bottom line. Which tends to lead to bad results.
- GCU-Empiricist 9y ago>https://hbr.org/2010/04/the-myth-of-shareholder-capitalism https://hbr.org/2010/04/the-myth-of-shareholder-capitalism Thanks; Intresting. A look at what the duties are might be this: http://www.oecd.org/daf/ca/corporategovernanceprinciples/1872746.pdf http://www.oecd.org/daf/ca/corporategovernanceprinciples/187...
- checkyoursudo 9y agoNo, not fiduciary duty. One theoretical approach to corporate governance/management, but it's not a legal duty. A competing theory is guaranteeing the long-term health of the company instead of short-term profits (current shareholder value). Another is being a good corporate citizen in society. These are usually all at least in a bit of tension. The reason shareholder value is often (almost always?) pushed at any large company is because it so often aligns with the boards' and managers' short-term goals, i.e., make lots and lots of money while the making is good. For a long time, and perhaps even still, Amazon has been held up as an example of a company that is not especially driven by the theory of maximizing shareholder value.
- fleitz 9y agoI've never understood why is it greed to want to keep your own money, but not greed to want someone else's.
- tasty_freeze 9y agoWe have a system of taxation. I pay my share. I expect others to pay there share. But when the other has found some legal loophole (perhaps one they helped to put in place or at least to maintain) and avoid paying their share, then yes, I'm upset and I want them to pay their share. Why do you try to cast this as a matter of greed. Apple is getting billions of dollars in benefits from being a US-based company, directly and indirectly.
- fleitz 9y agoYou mean you pay what the government says you owe, just like Apple does... Or are you saying that you don't claim any deductions and pay the maximum allowable by the system?
- tasty_freeze 9y agoI don't have the power to entice politicians to enact loopholes which I can then take advantage of. A ambassador might take advantage of his diplomatic immunity to commit a crime with impunity. One could say, "what's wrong with that? he was acting within the law." Or one could say, "That ambassador is a vile person and is taking advantage of the system."
- fleitz 9y agoPoliticians offer voters various tax incentives as part of virtually every campaign.
- komali2 9y agoI see where you're coming from (we're in agreeance that Apple is paying what the law says they owe), I think what people are discussing is that these loopholes probably shouldn't exist (i.e. that the spirit of the law is Apple should be paying ~30% tax on ALL profits, instead of just 50% of profits).
- nautilus12 9y agoThe issue is not capitalism and existing law, but the interpretation and enforcement of the law. The issue is that we have removed rational judgement from legal proceeding with regards to tax law. Its clearly demonstrable that Apple is not following the spirit of US tax law, but simply sidestepping the law by offshoring its money in this way. Does anyone with more legal expertise know of a more concise way of expressing this? Could the state simply sue apple and if they win then this establishes a new precedent for not offshoring money to dodge taxes?
- tryingagainbro 9y agoUSA can make it illegal probably but they will not (treaties? And /or a total breakdown of the current system.) Should Apple pay 35% if they can legally pay 5%, with some maneuvering? Then we can ask: Why not pay 50% since they're really profitable?
- nautilus12 9y agoI would say that its the "with some maneuvering" that we should re-evaluate as a society. If you can demonstrate clearly (and I think its clear to everyone here that they are dodging taxes) that they are attempting to sidestep the law even though its technically legal, then we should pursue precedents that prevent this.
- twblalock 9y agoWhere would that end? How could anyone be confident that their actions would not land them in jail, if following the letter of the law did not guarantee safety, and judges or juries could decide that their interpretation of the "spirit" of the law was enough to result in a guilty verdict?
- nautilus12 9y agoIm not a legal person so I apologize, but how does intent play into this then. If Im climbing with someone and I accidentally drop them and they die, then I have to show that my intent wasn't to murder them right? Can't you make the same argument here, the crime is that apple didn't pay the full taxes it owed the government don't they still have to prove that their intent wasn't dodging taxes?
- bitL 9y agoSeems like we need some government-business GAN to keep each other at check...
- sova 9y agoAnd if the law is too costly, just buy the law! Mortified.
- valuearb 9y agoWhat’s horrifying about paying every cent of tax you are legally obligated to pay? If i own a stock that increases 50% this year, am I doing something unethical by not selling it until january so i don’t have to pay taxes on the gain for another year? That’s equivalent to what Apples doing. It pays all the taxes it owes in every country it does business in. It pays taxes in the US, UK, France, Germany, etc, etc, and what’s left over from the foreign profits it chooses not to bring back to the US, or leave in France, Germany, etc, etc. Instead it moves those profits to Ireland or the Channel islands so it doesn’t have to pay more taxes on their interest every year while it waits for US corporate tax policy to no longer be so irrational so it can directly return that money to its owners, Apple shareholders.
- pathseeker 9y ago>Here in America we've made our decision - profit rules above all else. It is more profitable to lobby congress than it is to upgrade a refinery, it's more profitable to auto-deny every health insurance claim than it is to provide the services your customers think they're paying for, it's more profitable to avoid taxes than not (as long as you can avoid breaking the law TOO hard). This is not the decision "we've made in America". What you're describing is the behavior of some giant companies. There are millions of small to medium sized businesses that operate within the rules just fine and don't use the "corrupt the politicians" move as part of their business strategy.