10 ms·
Living cells are very fast and crowded places (2012)
- danaliv 9y agoI am suddenly very uncomfortable, imagining myself as a roiling blob of goo.
- goldenkey 9y agoAnything can be described both fancifully or dreadfully. One can say we are blobs of goo, biological automotons living on a speck of dirt in a googlplex of a cosmos. Or one can say that we are the result of billions of years of evolution on top of natural laws that first produced symmetries, conserved quantities, and higher level order like atoms and then stars - that then birthed heavier elements that eventually became us. So when you look up at the hard mineral made stars, remember that goo is just a mindset, for those very stars are effectively the embryonic stage of life itself.. You may enjoy Alan Watt's take on this: https://youtu.be/SOKwgP1Hte8 https://youtu.be/SOKwgP1Hte8
- teraflop 9y agoDon't be silly; you're trillions of blobs of goo.
- JshWright 9y agoAnd a lot of those blobs aren't even 'you'...
- ekianjo 9y agoNot that many actually, the estimations about people being made of more non self stuff than selfstuff were based on no serious measurement and its more of an urban legend than a fact.
- kens 9y agoCurrent estimates are that there are slightly more bacteria than human cells (3.8x10^13 vs 3.0x10^13) in a "reference man". However, the mass of the bacteria is only 0.2kg, so human cells totally dominate by mass. Interestingly, most of the human cells by count are red blood cells. http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.1002533 http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/jour...
- Ultimatt 9y agoNope. Its no urban legend. Recent findings now suggest there are free tissue bacteria species previously unknown about in humans. So the numbers of bacterial cells to human is only going up with understanding not down.
- JshWright 9y agoI was referring to the number of blobs, not their mass.
- DonHopkins 9y agoBe thankful you're not a Martian Print Amoeba, otherwise someone might kill you and throw your cadaver into a vat of fixing chemical while you're emulating an iPhone. http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/Content.asp?Bnum=1776 http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/Content.asp?Bnum=1776 And also be glad you were't selected to become a spy and altered to be appear in Blobel form! https://philipkdickreview.wordpress.com/2014/06/06/oh-to-be-a-blobel/ https://philipkdickreview.wordpress.com/2014/06/06/oh-to-be-...
- Terr_ 9y agoIf it helps, consider that you are the descendant of the original "grey goo" which since pervaded the surface of an entire planet. The inheritor of a billion years of techniques in construction, alliance, deception, and warfare. A uniquely coordinated swarm of assimilating nanotechnology, poised to leap into the cosmos. ... No pressure.
- Asooka 9y agoOr you can sit here and wait to become a star again.
- tasty_freeze 9y agoI highly recommend the book "The Machinery of Life" by David S. Goodsell. It isn't too long, the text is interesting with out getting too bogged down in the details (there simply would be too much to cover in detail), but the highlight is he a professor of molecular biology, he is an excellent illustrator, and the book is packed with detailed illustrations that alone make the book worth it. $18 on amazon. (get the 2nd edition, not the 1st edition) Just do a google search for images on the book title and author name to see what is inside.
- javajosh 9y agoSounds great! Along these lines, I've really enjoyed some of the iBiology[0] videos, especially the ones about molecular machinery. It's the 3blue1brown[1] of molecular biology. 0. https://www.youtube.com/user/ibioseminars https://www.youtube.com/user/ibioseminars 1. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYO_jab_esuFRV4b17AJtAw https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYO_jab_esuFRV4b17AJtAw
- Ultimatt 9y agoThis book is genuinely awesome. Im not sure why its so cheap in hardback but im glad it is. I buy almost anyone I know whos interested a copy. It's very good at giving you the right impression whilst being clear and easy to learn from. David Goodsell is also a really great guy and worth supporting.
- ggm 9y agoI spoke to a colleague who had done some work in his PhD in the physical chemistry of cells. Concepts like 'liquid' do not translate well at the intra-cellular level. 'holes' or 'channels' in a membrane, again are mostly about metaphors rather than mechanistic statements of completeness. he said for some things, an Escher infinite-space filling grid was as good a metaphor, for the cellular structure that the various organelles negotiate. (this btw, is asinine, and would deserve a "physical chemist here: this is bullshit" response)
- msie 9y agoTo clarify: your colleague's comment is asinine?
- ggm 9y agoAh grammar, where would we be without you.
- xkcd-sucks 9y agoThe physical chemist's response is that stuff gets really weird at interfaces, and a cell is a dense nugget of interfaces
- katastic 9y agoIn my experience, K-12 and 4-year college were all about "useful abstractions and assumptions" to help people understand concepts, and grad material was about slowly peeling away those assumptions and abstractions that made it convenient to learn and teach but were never really there (at least not guaranteed to be there). One of the best teachers I had forced us to write or assumptions down every time for every problem on the test. If you didn't write any, you got zero credit. "What's the point in learning equations if you don't know when they stop applying?" You also got _negative_ credit if you applied the wrong assumptions because you were just guessing or going on habit.
- nsxwolf 9y agoI wish I understood where all this stuff came from. When we talk about evolution we talk about random gene mutations and natural selection, but it doesn’t seem like the machinery of the cell itself is described by DNA. How do cells themselves and all their internal machinery evolve? If all you had was a genome, could you really use it to engineer the cell required for it to go inside of?
- openasocket 9y ago> If all you had was a genome, could you really use it to engineer the cell required for it to go inside of? Definitively no if you consider multi-cellular organisms. And that's not just me being pedantic. Consider that every cell in your body, from the white blood cells to skin cells to neurons, has the same DNA. It's entirely non-genetic factors (epi-genetics like methylation of genes, but also hormones and existing intra-cellular structures) that leads to a neuron acting like a neuron instead of a liver cell.
- dkural 9y agoLuckily, someone did an experiment similar to this one. They wrote the genome (and ONLY the genome) of a unicellular organism synthetically. Then they've removed the genome of an existing cell of a different species. The've then inserted the genome they created from scratch. The genome worked and produced versions of everything it needed, and cell division happened etc. Everything was produced & worked. So - they bootstrapped that genome using machinery of the empty cell w/o the genome, but from that point on, the new genome produced everything needed for many other cells & itself. (Venter's papers creating synthetic life) In fact, following that, the same team refactor that genome to create a minimum viable genome, the MVP of genomes if you will, just to see how few genes you can get away with! Here's an article: http://www.nature.com/news/minimal-cell-raises-stakes-in-race-to-harness-synthetic-life-1.19633 http://www.nature.com/news/minimal-cell-raises-stakes-in-rac...
- tuxguy 9y agoCraig Venter's "playing God" experiment ?
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dkural 9y agoAlthough there is truth in the post, this is not entirely correct. Many chemical and biological processes take place in a much slower timescale than hundreds of thousands per second, many miles per hour etc. These processes include DNA synthesis/cell division, transcription, the transmission of electricity / ions between neurons, and many other basic processes. Also, Many proteins don't simply float every around the cell at these massive speeds - they form stable, localized protein complexes that keep on doing what they're doing at the same location for quite a while. That's why we can image them and make real-time movies at human scales of perception (seconds, minutes etc.). Even more so for more complex processes - this is also why cellular motion takes quite a while - go on youtube and watch dictyostelium cells move towards folic acid. It takes quite a while, many hours in fact despite the presence of a very clear folic acid gradient as the signal.
- abecedarius 9y agoAlso, speeds like "100 times per second" should be scaled down with the size scaling, if you want a feel for mechanics. Times Square is about 1km long, and a eukaryotic cell around 10 microns, so scale by 100 million. (A pretty typical protein, 5nm across, becomes 0.5 meters across in Times Square.) From this perspective even the rapid purposeful actions the article talks about go extremely slowly: 100Hz becomes a million seconds per action -- a couple weeks. The biomolecules do whip around at random very fast -- but net progress happens only after a lot of wriggling.
- 100ideas 9y ago> Also, speeds like "100 times per second" should be scaled down with the size scaling, if you want a feel for mechanics. I'm a little confused, are you saying that the real speeds and rates in the article/this thread are all too fast by a factor of 100 million, or are you saying that its useful to perform this scaling mentally when imagining these systems to get a better intuition of their mechanics...?
- abecedarius 9y agoThe latter. Maybe I should reread the post, but it invites you to visualize a cell as Times Square -- scaling the sizes -- and then the unscaled speeds give the wrong impression within that visualization. (Mechanical properties like stiffness don't vary when you scale space and time together.) Outside of it, of course the absolute speeds are what you want to know.
- mncharity 9y ago> cells are extremely crowded and busy places Cells are extremely crowded and busy... and random and violent places. Molecular biology dances in a nano moshpit from hell. The Inner Life of a Cell is badly misleading. It reinforces many educationally toxic misconceptions. Yes, the graphics technology was limiting. But the video doesn't attempt to mitigate the negative impact. For instance, adding a couple of frames of Goodsell's crowded proteins, fading to sparseness, could have reduced its reinforcement of the "big empty cell" misconception. And it doesn't just hide almost everything (crowded), or slow everything way down (busy), or show completely aphysical rendezvous and docking (random), but it also strings together carefully selected snapshots to tell a misleadingly peaceful narrative (violent). That kinesin walking along, towing a vesicle? Its "feet" are actually madly flapping around. It is randomly "stepping" back and forth - only its net motion is biased. And between one net step and the next, that big vesicle has been slammed around to every position within reach of that tether. It's a random walk on a leash. Reality isn't a donkey quietly towing a slowly-moving barge. It's a balloon flapping madly in a hurricane, tethered to an intoxicated panicked mouse clinging to a rope. Biology rides a ragged energetic edge, between things being too strong, too expensive to dis/assemble, and being smashed to pieces too quickly. More generally, the video illustrates a pervasive problem with science education media. Even when done "well", some aspects are done with great skill and care, while other aspects are silently left utterly bogus. Pity the students, who lack the knowledge to sort out which is which. So rich ecologies of misconceptions are established. And are intractably expensive to displace. It's so easy to create content that leaves students worse off than if they had seen nothing at all. So that's, in general, what we create. The violence of nanoscale is a critical, defining characteristic. That so many biology undergrads are unclear on it, let alone high-school and primary students, shows just how very far we have to go before teaching deep understanding, transferable knowledge, and cross-cutting principles, finally becomes a reality. Or more upbeat, how breathtakingly awesome science education might eventually become. (FWIW, the top section of my very crufty http://www.clarifyscience.info/part/Atoms http://www.clarifyscience.info/part/Atoms might help some with getting a handle on at least the size aspect of small things.)
- Balgair 9y ago> It's a balloon flapping madly in a hurricane, tethered to an intoxicated panicked mouse clinging to a rope Welp, my desk is now covered in coffee. Thanks for that one, I'll be stealing it ;) It may be better to think of a cell as more of a liquid crystal than anything else, considering the densities. The synapse of neurons is incredibly dense with structures and scaffolding proteins. Even most grad students still think that the ER is a soma kinda thingy, but it goes all the way up the dendrite to just kiss the synaptic buton. The ER is really more of a cell inside a cell, or rather the cell membrane is just a latex bodysuit for the ER. It's always amazing to me when I heard guys like Elon and Kurzweil talking about MMIs and how you are never gonna actually die, you'll just upload your brain, somehow. Like, they really have no idea how clueless we are in biology. Eric Schmidt goes to parties in West LA about living forever. It's crazy. We are decades away from even a cursory understanding of 1 cubic mm of brain tissue, with all the neurons, astrocytes, glia, mesenchymal cells, etc. Like, we just found out that the immune system is in your brain too, like 3 years ago. I actually think Elon has better odds of putting 0.6 of a Saturn V on Mars and not having it explode before we have a MMI.
- ngsekar 9y agoInteresting.... Its very difficult to think about works of cells... if god is there... he is so great of creating lifes...
- Ultimatt 9y agoThis article mentions two things as if they are unrelated. That the cellular environment is crowded is exactly why you need transport proteins and vesicles. All the really fast proteins are mostly going nowhere, they're just wobbling on the spot bumping into everything crammed next to them. Sandwiched most of the time between membranes they cant diffuse through freely. Its like angry jelly not hot soup.
- jlebrech 9y agoGod is a using 4 dimensional Autocad, unaware that his gears and cogs have created life. that's my guess.
- hyperpallium 9y agoThe information processing capability of cells, and the fact that single-celled creatures have behaviour, makes it hard for me to believe that neurons (not just in humans, in all animals with neurons) don't use any of this information processing capability. I understand researchers have claimed to replicate the brains of some very simple animals (having something like 306 neurons)... but have they replicated the behaviour, i.e. for the same initial and ongoing inputs, you get the same outputs as the modeled brain? That should show the accuracy of the neuron model.
- _Wintermute 9y agoThey've tried, but there's definitely a lot more work to do. If you're interested check out the Open Worm project http://docs.openworm.org/en/latest/faq/ http://docs.openworm.org/en/latest/faq/
- agumonkey 9y agoIMO the internals are already busy being the fundation for the externals .. I don't think there's a strong information channels between the two.
- vbuwivbiu 9y ago"As a result of all this random motion, a typical enzyme can collide with something to react with 500,000 times every second. Watching the video, you might wonder how the different pieces just happen to move to the right place. In reality, they are covering so much ground in the cell so fast that they will be in the "right place" very frequently just by chance." That's the problem with those visualizations - they aim to give one an intuition of what's happening, but in fact they mislead. I wonder how it's possible to give an intuition of the reality, when in addition to the crazy statistical noisyness of the scene, those molecules are also in quantum superpositions.
- pdm55 9y agoI found Goodsell's images of the crowded intracellular environment in E. coli, useful visualisations in developing a model of a living cellular process, namely, transcription control. Transcription is the first step in gene expression: in E. coli, RNA polymerase transcribes a complementary copy of a gene, namely, messenger RNA, for further processing to protein. The transcription process is controlled by proteins that either compete with RNA polymerase for the start site of transcription (turn off the gene) or bind adjacently and promote transcription (turn on the gene). The difficulty I had in constructing a mathematical model of transcription control was that I wanted to include nonspecific binding, where RNA polymerase binds with low affinity to random stretches of DNA. While such binding occurs with low affinity, the sheer length of the DNA meant that a significant proportion of the RNA polymerase was bound in that form. Fortunately, I became aware of the work of people like Allen Minton (NIH) and Tom Record (U Madison-Wisconsin) who studied molecular crowding. To borrow a sentence from Wikipedia, "[H]igh concentrations of macromolecules reduce the volume of solvent available for other molecules in the solution, which has the result of increasing their effective concentrations." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macromolecular_crowding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macromolecular_crowding I found (I hope correctly) that Tom Record's quantification of crowding, as affecting a 100-fold increase in concentration, "exactly" compensated for the reduction due to nonspecific binding. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5425810/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5425810/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]