3 ms·
I really wish that HN had a rule where it would be mandatory for commenters to disclose their holdings in any cryptocurrency threads. This would make it easier
by pavlov 9y ago
I really wish that HN had a rule where it would be mandatory for commenters to disclose their holdings in any cryptocurrency threads. This would make it easier to flag comments that look like they're just pumping a coin to improve its search engine status.
If you're praising Bitcoin, EOS, IOTA or whatever FooBarToken, please add a short note at the end to explain what you stand to gain. Either: "I'm long IOTA", or "I don't own IOTA and have no plans to initiate a position on the short term".
Similar rules apply at forums where penny stocks and other volatile traditional securities are discussed, so it's absolutely not an unreasonable thing to ask.
- iso-8859-1 9y agoUseless since it is so easy to lie.
- pc86 9y agoIt's not unreasonable to ask but it's completely unreasonable to expect that anyone pumping a coin on HN would have even the slightest inclination to be truthful about their position.
- pavlov 9y agoThe disclaimer (truthful or not) serves two purposes: 1) For the pumper poster, it makes them more conscious of the lie. Promoting a coin and forgetting to mention your holdings feels like a little white lie of omission. Actively lying about your holdings feels like deceit. 2) For the reader, it’s an important reminder that a seemingly objective technical-looking comment can be motivated by greed.
- TallGuyShort 9y ago>> anyone pumping a coin on HN would have even the slightest inclination to be truthful about their position Which is why I already just assume everyone who doesn't do this but makes claims about a certain coin is talking out of their ass.
- conanbatt 9y agoAre people without coins barred from participating?
- pavlov 9y agoIf you don’t have a position in a coin that you’re praising, that’s useful to know.
- swah 9y agoI thought you would start... (I own BTC enough to buy a nintendo game)
- pavlov 9y agoWhen I post an opinion about a coin or exchangeable token, I will. Nothing to disclose though! I don’t care much about the space. But the volume of outright scams is the highest I’ve ever seen in any market.