Pretty sure I would count as a "Giver" and a fairly average one. There are knock-on effects of living in a system with less desperation such as lower crime rat

Pretty sure I would count as a "Giver" and a fairly average one. There are knock-on effects of living in a system with less desperation such as lower crime rates, better infrastructure, and more opportunity which is enjoyed by everyone. The "givers" in your example would in all likelihood not have been givers their entire life. They will have been educated at a university, gotten their first job when someone was off for a year on maternity leave, etc.