3 ms·
"Critical Tor flaw leaks users’ real IP address" This is not a problem with Tor: this is a problem with the Tor Browser (and even then, only on macOS and Linux
by saurik 9y ago
"Critical Tor flaw leaks users’ real IP address"
This is not a problem with Tor: this is a problem with the Tor Browser (and even then, only on macOS and Linux: users on Windows are not affected)... I'd recommend changing the title as this otherwise sounds like some extremely concerning flaw in the platform itself, which this attack is not targeting.
- mirimir 9y agoThat's a good point, and the title ought to be "... Tor browser ...". Still, for the vast majority of Tor users, Tor is Tor browser. However, most of them use Windows, and weren't affected. So maybe "... OSX/Linux Tor browser ...".
- captainmuon 9y agoThe Tor project itself muddles the distinction. If you go to their website and click "download", you get the Tor Browser. They actively encourage people to only use Tor Browser and not roll their own (because your browser requests would look different and you would be trackable). The "only way" (without contortions) to get Tor without the bundle is via linux package manager.
- saurik 9y agoI know a bunch of people who use Tor in various ways that does not in any way involve a browser at all, and the ramifications of an attack at these two levels (in the routing stack vs. in the app layer) are very different. I appreciate why Ars Technica's headline is what it is, but this is Hacker News.
- captainmuon 9y agoYeah, you're right. This would be one of the cases where it makes sense to change the title.