6 ms·
Craig Venter: 'We Have Learned Nothing from the Genome'
- michaelkeenan 16y agoI was curious about the disagreement over his predictions from 1998, so I looked it up. I don't think it reflects well on him. Spiegel interview 2010: SPIEGEL: The genome project has been called the Manhattan Project or Moon Landing of its era. It has also been said that knowledge of the genes will change the future of humanity and become a "main driver of the world economy." Venter: Who said that? I didn't. That was the people at the consortium. SPIEGEL: You're wrong. You made all those statements in an interview with DER SPIEGEL in 1998. Venter: Really? Those are Francis Collins' lines. So I may have said that that's how he describes it. I, on the other hand, have always said, "This is a race from the starting line to the finish." Spiegel interview 1998 (translated to German by Spiegel and back to English with Google Translate[1]): SPIEGEL: What does the knowledge of the genetic material? Venter: The End of Ignorance, a completely new understanding of the human body and a revolution in medicine. What we plan is there, of the order of the Manhattan Project or the moon flights. The decoding of the genome will change the self-image of humanity. [1] http://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&sl=auto&tl=en&u=http://www.spiegel.de/spiegel/print/d-7972392.html&prev=_t&rurl=translate.google.com&twu=1&usg=ALkJrhhtyOWCfoxOrojkUDuXwu8uuAG5-g http://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?hl=en&...
- yurylifshits 16y agoWell, he was not saying anything about "economics driver". I guess his remark "I was not saying this" was about economic part of the claim.
- ugh 16y agoHe did (Google translation, same interview): SPIEGEL: How much money do you think the human genome is worth? Venter: In any case, a lot. Each of the major pharmaceutical companies is constantly working on 50-60 new drugs. If only a part of the future knowledge of the human genome based on, then this alone brings hundreds of billions of dollars in the next decade. The knowledge of the human genes is one of the strongest drivers of the global economy.
- rwmj 16y agoAccording to this excellent book I read: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Backroom-Boys-Secret-Return-British/dp/0571214967 http://www.amazon.co.uk/Backroom-Boys-Secret-Return-British/... Venter also wanted to patent the whole human genome once he'd sequenced it. It was only by a huge and expensive effort by the Wellcome charity that the genome was sequenced and made freely available. If you enjoy reading ..AGAAACCATCAGCACA.. then: http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/3501 http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/3501 This is also discussed in the Wikipedia page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Genome_Project http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Genome_Project Anyway, the book I linked to is great fun.
- ben1040 16y agoVenter also wanted to patent the whole human genome once he'd sequenced it. It was only by a huge and expensive effort by the Wellcome charity that the genome was sequenced and made freely available Not only Wellcome (although their Sanger Centre was a major player), but a whole worldwide bucket of public money. It also bears mentioning too that on March 14, 2000 Bill Clinton and Tony Blair issued a joint statement saying that the results of genomic sequencing shouldn't be patented. The biotech sector lost $40bn in value as a result[1], as it became evident the patent business model was dead. [1]http://books.google.com/books?id=FOk3LE70l1EC&lpg=PA284&ots=CvGQ1E6YuC&dq=celera%20stock%20crash%20march%2014%202000&pg=PA284#v=onepage&q=celera%20stock%20crash%20march%2014%202000&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=FOk3LE70l1EC&lpg=PA284&...
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoI don't think the comments themselves reflect poorly on him. Late 90's would have been significantly influenced by the bubble and who wasn't thinking how much the sequenced genome would be worth. Twelve years is a long time to reverse-map current feelings and knowledge onto previous memories. The part that reflects poorly, IMO, is how he tries to pin it on Collins when faced with the quotes. I can understand why the interviewers didn't press the issue, but I would have liked to see them press it.
- adulau 16y agoAn interesting point of view, especially that is a "bit opposing" the perspective of Sergey Brin described in this article : http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/06/ff_sergeys_search/all/1 http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/06/ff_sergeys_search/all/... where Sergey Brin knows having a specific gene (LRRK2) that has been associated with a higher rate of Parkinson disease. But the conclusion looks the same, we still don't know well the interaction of the Genome with our real biological operation and need more research especially in data analysis. Looking at it on a programming perspective, it seems that we have a large pile of "source code" and we are still evaluating some functions (or even at some variable name) without grasping the overall modus of operation. When we are doing binary reverse engineering, we are always looking for an entry point where the program starts to be executed. It seems that for Genome that there are many entry points...
- phaedrus 16y agoLike a program binary, which has been developed by trial and error without a design, which uses overlapping instructions that mean different things depending on the entry point, and which makes extensive use of self modifying code (via gene expression). And which goes through three phases of binary to binary translation: DNA->RNA->Proteins.
- mbreese 16y agoAnd that's just the simple stuff. Now imagine that you will silence a lot of the binary code, only running small parts of it. But you may not know which parts. I think this is one of the big things to come out of the human genome project: exactly how little is there. And since there is so little code to work with, there is a bigger need for epigenetic regulation and alternative splicing.
- carbocation 16y agoI would not have expected such a misunderstanding of the fruits of the knowledge of the human reference sequence from J Craig Venter. Frankly, it sounds like sour grapes. For some reason, I feel inclined to try to explain some of the technical reasons why the public project's approach was necessary for the completion of the human genome. There is broad agreement (perhaps "universal - 1") that Venter's sequencing approach would never have been able to achieve the level of completeness that we have now thanks to the Human Genome Project. This is because of duplicate DNA in the human genome, and the nature of short read lengths. Let's try this with colors. Say you have a terrible sequencer that only reads 7bp at a time, max. You come across the following 2 strands of DNA: GREENgattacaGREEN REDgattacaRED They're on 2 entirely different chromosomes, but you don't know this since there exists no reference sequence - you're mapping de novo, remember? Good. So you're get readouts like "GREENgattac" and "gattaca" and "attacaRED" - but you don't have any reads >7bp, so you never see what is on both sides of gattaca at once. Thus, since you can never span gattaca, you will never know if your DNA in this region should be GREENgattacaRED + REDgattacaGREEN, or REDgattacaRED + GREENgattacaGREEN. For de novo alignment with short reads, this type of shortcoming is deadly. Because the public consortium / Human Genome Project used much longer read lengths and a method involving bacterial artificial chromosomes, they were able to map the more difficult regions of the genome having repeats. Edit I should have addressed the public consortium's approach more thoroughly, though to be clear I am less familiar with the approach and have never used it myself. Essentially, you chop up the 3 gigabase genome into a bunch of 150 kilobase segments (in this case, bacterial artificial chromosomes). You can map these back to their source chromosomes, of which we already knew we had 23. You then chop these BACs up into smaller pieces and sequence. In the worst case, you might be unsure of where some of your reads from each BAC map within the 150kb window that they come from, but hey, at least you know which chromosome and more or less which portion of the chromosome they come from. In other words, in the situation described above, the RED and the GREEN never co-occur, since they are on different BACs and are not sequenced together. Thus you know that RED/RED and GREEN/GREEN are the right pairings (and you know which belongs on which chromosome).
- ramanujan 16y agoSure, but Venter and Celera do deserve props for introducing whole genome shotgun, which became the de facto standard for getting most of the genome. This doesn't invalidate anything you're saying, because finishing is important, but the whole trend towards short reads and pushing more of the job to the computer was begun by Celera. Eugene Myers is/was an amazing computer scientist, and the public project would never have finished as quickly without the push from Celera. [beat] Also, all of this really deals with the technical aspects of obtaining a sequence, which is not really what Venter is talking about. He's saying that a good sequence isn't that useful! I'm not sure what he means with this, or whether he's just trying to be controversial.
- GiraffeNecktie 16y agoAs I pointed out the first time this article was posted (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1559056 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1559056), the article title is a truncated and distorted version of the actual quote: "We have learned nothing from the genome other than probabilities."
- igravious 16y agoOh how I would love to see both Craig Venter and Stephen Wolfram together, in the flesh, in the same room, at the same time. I would love to see if it were possible for both their egos to be occupy the same portion of space-time for longer than 20 attoseconds.
- jacquesm 16y agoI'm equal parts impressed with, annoyed by and intrigued by Craig Venter and his undertakings. Impressed because of the relentless energy he pours in to his ventures and their success rate, annoyed because of his tendency to take credit and self-aggrandise at every opportunity and intrigued because I wonder where it will all lead.
- checker659 16y agoDamn, I missed this article while it was higher up on the page. Not sure if there are enough people around but I'll ask my question nonetheless. """Venter: Well, the goal is multifold. We have to start by creating minimal cells. A human cell is too complex -- we have no idea how any human cell works. We don't even know how the simplest bacterial cell works.""" Do we have no idea how a cell works? I know we understand the anatomy but I had no idea we hadn't moved beyond that? Is this some kind of satire/joke or is this where the state of the science is at?
- z92 16y agoUnfortunately, as I understand it, that is this where the state of the science is at. Physics can now explain most of chemical processes, but it's still unable to explain even basic biological processes. Someone please correct me if I am wrong.
- danielford 16y agoI think what he's getting at is that you can look at the genome of E. coli, which was sequenced in the nineties, and is one of the most common model systems used in research, but we don't know what the functions of a lot of those genes are. Last time I heard anything about this we had no idea what twenty percent of its genes did. That number may be off by ten to fifteen percent either way, since I haven't read anything on the topic in years, and it's going to depend on the parameters you set for how sure you are about a gene's function. Keep in mind that this doesn't mean we're completely clueless about how the cell works, just that there's still a lot of work to do.