13 ms·
> "Here, I made a layout for you": Unless you really believe you are as good as the designer you're hiring, it doesn't make sense for you to actually do any des
by Silhouette 16y ago
> "Here, I made a layout for you": Unless you really believe you are as good as the designer you're hiring, it doesn't make sense for you to actually do any designing yourself.
I respectfully disagree.
For one thing, a (graphic) designer can provide a variety of related services, and some of them may overlap other experts on the team, such as the user interface team or a web usability specialist.
For another thing, this presupposes that the designer is the only such expert involved in a project. For larger projects, this may well not be the case, and there may be someone setting the parameters for the overall system and then a number of designers responsible for implementing the general rules in specific areas.
> Obviously you're the customer, but you're not getting much bang for your buck if you insist that the primary design be done by an amateur.
You imply a false dichotomy. I can't speak for others, but on several projects I currently work on we might outsource things like graphic design, artwork and typography to a specialist, but want to retain direct control of the overall layout and interactive elements. In one case that comes immediately to mind, that is because we have extensive knowledge of usability issues from a previous version of the software that no designer joining the project fresh would have. In another case, we have web-based access and various apps for mobile devices, and we want a consistent overall look and feel across all versions of the service, so while the designer is free to fit the branding to the natural style on each platform, they don't get to move everything around in a way that could confuse our users. These decisions are not made by amateurs, they are made by specialists whose job is to analyse hard data and make these decisions. I wouldn't ask these people to decide what kind of antialiasing to use on the web buttons, and I wouldn't ask a graphic designer without the relevant knowledge of our products to lay out the user interface.
- chc 16y agoI agree with everything you said here, but we're talking about different situations. I never meant to suggest that what I was saying are universal truths, just that the OP reflects common problems that come up.