2 ms·
> If one can read the thoughts of the other so easily, in my book it is the same person. I can also read your thoughts. Are we the same person? The only differ
by ars 9y ago
> If one can read the thoughts of the other so easily, in my book it is the same person.
I can also read your thoughts. Are we the same person? The only difference is you need to put them in text, and she does it via electrical impulses.
Their thoughts are not integrated into a single entity, but rather they are able to communicate via a channel you don't posses. As evidence, when they need to share thoughts it takes them extra time, to me that means communication, not single entity.
Another way to put it: They can distinguish their own thoughts from those of their sister.
> am resident in Neurology
Then you should know that even a regular brain is really multiple independent "thinkers" that are wired to give the illusion of a single entity. Disrupt that wiring and the different "minds" will do their own thing, separately from the others (alien hand syndrome for example).
And I know that that sounds like an argument against what I'm saying.
It's basically the question of consciousness: Who is the "I" that is speaking. That alien hand has no consciousness. These conjoined sisters have two, because each can perceive itself as distinct.