4 ms·
So, basically, you want participation and guidance from your client because vague guidance is not enough (#1), except that you want them to not tell you how to
by Silhouette 16y ago
So, basically, you want participation and guidance from your client because vague guidance is not enough (#1), except that you want them to not tell you how to do your job and to trust that your judgement will automatically result in acceptable work (#2, #6, #7, #10). Moreover, you want to work with an open-ended budget (#5) and timescales (#8) and communicating on your terms (#9).
Here's another theory: If I'm outsourcing part of a project, I will provide a specification for the work including any constraints I require, you will submit a proposal including estimates of how much it will cost and how long it will take, and I will consider your proposal and decide whether to accept it. You will be available at reasonable times for me to communicate with you, you will provide regular updates as the project progresses, and you will inform me immediately if your estimates are going to be incorrect, or I will not pay you. This is what is known in the business world as "how things actually work if you're the one providing the service and the other guy is the one paying the bills". Final hint: if you don't like being asked for a ballpark figure because it's hard for you to give one, then you were right about one of us being a beginner, but you have misjudged which of us it is.
(Edit: I would agree that co-operative discussions and effective communication are the best way forward in most business relationships. I just think the ideas in this particular article are so obviously one-sided in favour of the designer that no serious client is likely to employ the designer's services on that basis, so they aren't really very useful at all.)
- mcritz 16y agoI am a designer, and I agree. The article is a childish wish list that portrays designers as pampered prima donnas. It shames hardworking designers that believe in honest work, open communication, and finding creativity in constraints.
- solost 16y agoI work with designers every day and I can tell you I had to share this around and their reaction along with my own is summed up perfectly in your comments. What a terrible way to portray the expectations of the design profession.
- chc 16y agoI agree that the tone of the article smacks of entitlement, but the "don't" list actually does cover some big pain points I think a lot of designers are familiar with. I just think the article doesn't explain them very well. "Here, I made a layout for you": Unless you really believe you are as good as the designer you're hiring, it doesn't make sense for you to actually do any designing yourself. Guidance, yes; clear specifications and limits, yes; a concrete design, no. If you could do that, you wouldn't need to hire anyone. It's like hiring a photographer and telling him, "Here, I set everything up. You just push the shutter button." Obviously you're the customer, but you're not getting much bang for your buck if you insist that the primary design be done by an amateur. It's trouble for me and it usually does mean a worse product for you (not out of spite, but because I'm hobbled by an ill-thought-out design that the client drew up in 10 minutes on a napkin and insisted be followed exactly). "How much does X cost?": This isn't about having an open-ended budget. It's about providing a clear specification. Asking for a budget without any kind of specification is asking for disappointment later on. For example, a business owner asked how much a blog would cost. I gave a relatively low number to set up WordPress and do a simple theme. After further questioning, it turned out that when he said "blog" he meant something more like "Facebook competitor." Even better is "How much does a website cost?" "I want to show this to my <spouse/friend/child>": This isn't unreasonable, but you shouldn't treat any one person as "the public's opinion." Unfortunately, many people do. For example, I worked with a guy whose wife thought it would be awesome to put pictures of her poodle all over a business website because the dog was so cute. Everyone else who saw a design with the dog was completely perplexed by it, but she loved it.
- trevelyan 16y agoI have specified details of layout and had designers ignore them. The result was unusable because they did not listen. A case in point is providing a color header graphic of fixed width instead of a (faster loading) white-based background design which could scale to variable width and still look good. Someone who provides a layout is telling the designer what they need and asking for it to be improved. You get better results this way. If a designer told me this was bad for them, I would use someone else. Saves me from getting something unusable back. That said, I think this designer is in the minority. Most are more professional and realize design needs to be contingent on tech/usability factors they may not understand. So they want information and ask questions when they see ways to improve things.