4 ms·
The Internet companies lost the high ground in regard to censorship and 3rd party speech when they tried to shutdown Daily Stormer. When Google or CloudFlare we
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
The Internet companies lost the high ground in regard to censorship and 3rd party speech when they tried to shutdown Daily Stormer. When Google or CloudFlare were told that the website was using their services, instead of taking the high ground with regard to the principle of free speech and 3rd party speech on their services, they used their right to free association to withdraw service.
Now when you use free association to withdraw internet service that you oppose, you implicitly are saying that you endorse the services you keep.
Now most people agree that if people who advocate Nazism are bad, people who actually engage in human trafficking are even worse. And if you are ok with making sure that the former are not on the Internet, you should be even more ok with keeping the latter off the Internet.
This is the reason why the ACLU has historically been pretty absolutist about free speech, even defending and making sure that the government does not censorship even the most odious of speech.
In the past, section 230 made sense as most of the companies had a lassez-faire attitude to speech on their services. With companies now doing more to me censor 3rd party speech on their platform, section 230 is seen as the tech companies wanting to have your cake (bot have any liability for 3rd party speech) and eat it too(be able to censor 3rd party speech whenever they want).
- IBM 9y ago>The Internet companies lost the high ground in regard to censorship and 3rd party speech when they tried to shutdown Daily Stormer. When Google or CloudFlare were told that the website was using their services, instead of taking the high ground with regard to the principle of free speech and 3rd party speech on their services, they used their right to free association to withdraw service. This lassez-faire attitude you speak of never existed. They lost the high ground the moment they started policing their platforms for spam, adult content, malware, copyrighted content, terrorist propaganda, etc., thereby expressing editorial control. They want to have it both ways, they want to absolve themselves of all responsibility (and liability) for anything that's on their platform and at the same time remove anything that is in-line with their commercial interests (for UX reasons or because their advertisers object to the content their ads run on).
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoI agree with you. When section 230 was passed in 1996, from my memory, they were a lot more lassez-faire, and also you had far more choice. I routinely posted on maybe a dozen sites at the time. Now, with everything consolidating and the monopolies censoring in favor of advertisers or PR, section 230 makes a lot less sense.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> They want to have it both ways Censorship is one party telling everyone else what they can and can't see. Prohibiting content is censorship -- it's telling people what they can't see. Prohibiting filtering is also censorship -- it's telling people they have to see your thing in place of the thing they want. Filtering is inherently a weighing of false positives against false negatives. If you require filtering then the false negative rate has to be low/zero, so the false positive rate goes through the roof. No Nazis but also no Republicans or Democrats. If you prohibit filtering then the false positive rate has to be low/zero, so the false negative rate goes through the roof. Everyone is deluged by spam and malware. Section 230 doesn't apply to copyright and look at the mess that has been -- worst of both worlds. Copyright infringement is still prolific but people use fraudulent copyright takedowns for things they don't own left and right, and the platforms execute them because they have minimal incentive to question anything. What you really want is the middle ground where platforms have to compete with each other for users, so they can ban things everyone hates (spam) but lose users if they ban things those people are legitimately interested in (e.g. minority political opinions). The problem isn't Section 230, it's the lack of competition which gives the major platforms too much power when they decide to censor something. It has to be the marketplace of ideas, not the monopoly of ideas.
- nnfy 9y ago>Prohibiting filtering is also censorship -- it's telling people they have to see your thing in place of the thing they want. This reads like a paragraph straight out of 1984. No one is forcing people to view anything by prohibiting filtering. It simply is making certain available on the platform. Now I suppose one could argue that filtering is a form of speech, but thats still reaching I think.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Fnoord 9y ago> The Internet companies lost the high ground in regard to censorship and 3rd party speech when they tried to shutdown Daily Stormer. When Google or CloudFlare [...] Except that Google or CloudFlare does not equal to "The Internet companies" as there are far more out there than these 2. Especially world-wide. Also, companies do make mistakes. They don't strive for that, but they do. It is not too late to admit a mistake was made in this circumstance.
- the8472 9y ago> as there are far more out there than these 2. GP listed them as examples, that does not mean that they are the only two companies that did so. So this becomes a paradox of the heap. At which point does "a few individual companies" turn into "the internet"? Since the internet is a decentralized system there is no clear defined boundary and any of the big, private infrastructure providers finding novel reason (within their own ecosystem) to not provide a service is concerning. What if google refused to resolve some domains via their 8.8.8.8 resolver? Clearly this is trivial to circumvent, at worst you would have to setup your own resolver at home. And yet it could affect millions of unaware users. What if the CEO of a single Tier 1 peering provider suddenly found some content so much in conflict with his values that they refuse to route the whole IP block? Yes, they are private entities, but the internet consists predominantly of private entities providing infrastructure.
- Fnoord 9y ago> GP listed them as examples That wasn't clear at all. As for the rest of what you wrote: It is something we need to keep in the back of our mind, but I am not afraid of that doom-scenario. I've been on the Internet long enough to know that it isn't the end of the world if a few large ISPs stop carrying [certain] information. Even if the whole USA would be forced to do that under this law it wouldn't be the end of the world. If anything, it provides a business opportunity for competitors (akin to the problem of tax evasion). It'd be great for ISPs in the EU, to name an example who'd benefit. OVH in Europe wouldn't mind such a bill. My point is that the Internet will work around it if a large enough group of people support it. A large enough group of people (in relevant positions) support tax evasion as well, so that's gonna stay existent for the time being. There are also documented examples of ISPs as well as darknets which don't or would not censor (you'll find most ISPs operate like that unless it clearly is against the law). Although there's also grey area. It is one of the reasons why a website like TPB existed for so long. The same with 8.8.8.8. Its in Google's interest to handle the vast majority of DNS requests. Why? It allows them to do better profiling. Why would they without a court order actively hamper their business interest? If a company like Google wants to it becomes a cat and mouse game. People swap to a different DNS such as a root-server, or a proper DNS server supporting DNSCurve (a much more secure option than Google DNS). I'm from a country where two large ISPs had to block TPB on DNS layer. Do you think it was effective? Later on, they had to filter certain IPs (also causing other websites to be unreachable). That was slightly more effective, but to this day the darknet, VPNs, and proxies still work both for TPB as well for piracy. BTW, I find the example of Daily Stormer particularly weak. There's far more controversial as well as earlier documented examples related to piracy, terrorism, and CP. The question becomes: where do you draw the line? Because even in darknets, people draw lines. IPFS has a function to blacklist content. What you can observe is that something like CP is difficult (virtually impossible) to obtain because the general public doesn't support it. Whereas piracy, is supported by a vast large group of people. Result: 1) If someone does have a significant amount of it they actively searched for it which severely weakens their legal defense 2) The darknet (and clearnet till some extend) carries piracy, but not so much CP. Supply & demand works even with moderate amounts of censorship because a large enough group of people agree (or disagree) with the cause. And, since I like that CP isn't easily available, it seems the system works, even on the darknet (note I've only verified it on Tor btw). Because CP is where I draw the line regarding freedom of speech; I want the people who produce and knowingly spread that busted. The vast majority of our civilisation as well as the vast majority of people who hold relevant positions at ISPs agree with that. Yet, if freedom of speech was the holy grail, then it'd be available on the Internet. The elephant in the room is that freedom of speech both is not and was not the holy grail to begin with. There's nuances to such extreme ideal. I went into detail about 2 of these examples, but there are more available. > What if the CEO of a single Tier 1 peering provider suddenly found some content so much in conflict with his values that they refuse to route the whole IP block? This could already happen in the case of abuse, or lack of good peering agreement, but it did not happen in the case of spam. Instead we used blacklists like Spamhaus.
- subterfudge44 9y agoThere is no lassez-faire when it comes to Google, Facebook etc. For example i can not advertise guns or cigars on them. Free speech is absolute and should always be but I don't think Google or Facebook should be forced to provide platform for anyone either.
- ashleyn 9y ago>The Internet companies lost the high ground in regard to censorship and 3rd party speech when they tried to shutdown Daily Stormer. Companies still have the right to refuse service to anyone. They're not "banning" them or "censoring" them; they're refusing a service that white advocacy organisations like Daily Stormer are fundamentally not owed, and only continues to disrupt their bottom line by degrading the quality of service provided for every other user of the platform. What is often unsaid in this argument is the corrosive impact of "zero-tolerance" free speech on private platforms. What starts as a well-intentioned marketplace of ideas rapidly degenerates into a choking haze of obnoxious users who alienate more tactful users, as well as advertisers. Well-reasoned albeit inflammatory discussion gives way to a 4chan-style culture where the new bar for "ideas" is set at some variation of "nigger nigger nigger". Then, when normal users leave and Pizza Hut balks at seeing its logo next to a Klan hood, "corporate globalists" are accused of pulling the advertising solely to silence them, when really they're just defending their intellectual property against unsavory people who regularly act in bad faith. "Free speech" on private platforms ends up killing the platform every time, because unsavory people misuse it, and the misuse draws more and more unsavory users. Voat is suffering from this problem, being more than willing to host the jailbait board that reddit wisely canned, as well as hosting content pandering to white community outreach and conspiracy theorists. When advertisers exercise their own freedom of association and refuse to do business with Voat, they're simply derided as part of a global elite that's seeking to extinguish their ideas. When in reality, nobody is interested in their ideas enough to be willing to fund them or associate with them. Google et al are simply acknowledging that advertisers have every bit of freedom of association, as people believe they think they have freedom of speech on a private platform. They are not building governmental organisations, where freedom of speech is absolute and untouchable. They're building for-profit corporations that need to retain advertisers. And you don't retain advertisers by enabling their intellectual property to be placed amidst people who regularly act in bad faith.
- eighthnate 9y agoI agree completely. Not only did they lose the high ground, what did facebook, google, reddit and the rest of social media companies think was going to happen once they agreed to a little bit of censorship? Did they really think these anti-free speech crowd was going to go away? No. Extremists always up the ante and they are going to demand more and more censorship. I've stopped using reddit because so much of the "community" is so extreme now. They are even demanding that pro-Trump subs be banned from reddit and even calling for twitter to ban Trump's twitter account. What's going to be interesting is what these people will think when people start demanding atheist, lgbt, leftist, etc content be censored.
- mindslight 9y ago> What's going to be interesting is what these people will think when people start demanding atheist, lgbt, leftist, etc content be censored. I agree with the sentiment in principle. And I think competing walled gardens is a poor substitute for actual free speech. But I think the likely outcome is that other platforms/communities will rise for the "red team", with a similar philosophy of censorship but obviously much different community standards. Initially, I think this will drive further animosity between the two teams as they become even more isolated echo chambers. But hopefully where the two meet (eg Faceboot), people will relearn that whole thing of not discussing "religion or politics" (redundant) in polite company.
- unabst 9y agoThe best, most effective, and only correct way to fight hate speech is not to censor it. It's to TALK BACK. The thing about speech is it's only a paper trail of sorts. Sounds or printed symbols are not bullets being shot. But what they do is connect and mobilize minds and ideas, and hence the fear. But since they are only a paper trail, censorship never solves the cause. It's like burying it. Silencing does have an impact... in that we no longer hear those words. But where they came from - unless they're funded by the speech itself (like a newspaper or something) - are still live and kicking. You have to kill the people that spoke those words, or else they'll continue to influence (hence the assassination of MLK, and so on). It's the equivalent of putting a silencer on a gun. The point is, we need to engage the cause. The "gun" needs to be made the issue, not the sound of bullets firing. And not fight as in war, because that would lead to justifying offensive tactics that lower our moral standards. Censorship in media is the equivalent of murder on the battlefield. Engaging is to connect. It is diplomacy. And for engagement, SPEECH IS THE ONLY WAY. So silencing goes against the cause. It makes things worse. When we bury what cannot be buried, we get Silk Road and the drug war and the political backlash which is Mr. T. Instead, if we engage these PEOPLE as non-criminals for who they truly are - people just like you or I with different ideas - then we might actually get somewhere. They are here to teach us what we needed to know, and vice versa. We must talk back, and not silence or punish or annihilate. That is the only civil and progressive solution.