4 ms·
I wonder why we use these services if we aren’t satisfied with how they work.
by TaylorAlexander 9y ago
I wonder why we use these services if we aren’t satisfied with how they work.
- crush-n-spread 9y agonetwork effects, and convenience.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoFacebook does one thing that no other service can duplicate: it has all of my friends on it.
- JoshMnem 9y agoArguably, that's one of the problems with Facebook. Not all of one's contacts should be in the same conversations together.
- throwawaysml 9y agoDidn't Google try to solve that with circles. I never used Facebook or any other "social network", so I'm probably unaware of some details, but I read about circles when Google+ came out and it sounded like a solution for exactly this problem.
- JoshMnem 9y agoI think they got the idea of circles from Diaspora. The WWW works best when used as intended: decentralized communities that encourage people to be creators rather than consumers. Instead of Facebook, participate in independent online communities around your interests (for example, forums). Instead of chat apps that attempt to envelop everyone you've ever met into monolithic walled gardens, use SMS and email. Instead of Medium, learn how to create your own independent blog with something like Metalsmith, Hugo, or Hexo. Etc.
- throwawaysml 9y agoIt's ironic since there are more content creators now if we count all the users of the silos. My theory is that it's all about convenience and network effects. So if a fully decentralized IPFS based/alike social network would come out with mobile apps and was marketed as the way to communicate, it could have success. The big fault such projects make is to stress the technical merits and forget to play the psych-advertising game. I've seen non-technical people have the most number of messenger apps on their phones, and some even advocated the security of their favorite messenger. Technical folks seem to be harder to persuade to join a messenger network to communicate with a new person in their life. So I want to say once we will have a couple more high profile data breaches and centralized SPOF downtimes, people will care about security and availability, though history doesn't support they would.
- JoshMnem 9y agoCreating isn't just about "content". Posting vapid updates and linking to articles that other people wrote isn't really creating anything. For most people, posting on social media is consumption, not creation. The Internet is on its way to becoming TV 2.0. There are at least two ways to perceive the world: as an "architect" or as a "consumer". The Internet/WWW should teach people how to be architects, but it's failing in many ways.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoI've never understood this. We can't all do the same thing. We can all be sandwich makers. The internet is teaching people to do all sorts of things other than be architects.
- JoshMnem 9y agoI think that not everyone can be a large-scale architect, but those numbers can be increased. People can be taught to at least think like architects in order to make better choices in life and understand when and how they are being manipulated by malevolent architects. Also, one doesn't need to build million-user products to architect small changes in local communities. An analogy: not everyone can be a good philosopher, but they should at least read philosophical ideas and be aware of them as they make decisions in life. Collective intelligence/wisdom can increased, even if most individuals are not professional philosophers.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- KGIII 9y agoI have mine in my email address book. It works like it has for a number of decades, more or less.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoFacebook has a very different use case than email.
- KGIII 9y agoSending messages to friends and family?
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoKeeping up with how your friend group is doing, and having an ongoing group conversation about it, without needing to maintain mailing lists and Reply All and spam people with the implied urgency of email. Social media exists for a reason. It's not just email for stupid people.
- liberal_098 9y agoIt is call monopoly - one form of violence. People simply do not have choice. And if they find some alternatives then these companies appeal to the state or even military force. For example, some largest military invasions of the US into Iraq and many other countries can be explained very simply: people did not want to use Facebook and Google.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoNothing's perfect. I'm not really satisfied with how anything works in my life, but many things are good enough or I've learned to accept the trade-offs.