2 ms·
First of all, advance apologies for meta. But this is rather interesting. I am not sure this article deserved to be flagged. It's an opinion piece, so one can'
by bostik 9y ago
First of all, advance apologies for meta.
But this is rather interesting. I am not sure this article deserved to be flagged. It's an opinion piece, so one can't expect too rigorous source vetting. That said, the reference links weren't particularly shabby.
And it's political, which goes against the HN guidelines. However: it does make couple of very interesting points.
The first one: that partisan media is more insulated than before. That's certainly a viewpoint that carries weight and has been discussed, in various forms, on HN for quite some time.
And the second one? That in the current political climate there is no more room for moderate and reasonable discussion. You either broadcast a polarised and incendiary view or get no visibility nor acknowledgment - but when you do submit to the attention economy, you get flooded and drowned out by the professional wound-ups.[ß]
---
[ß]: Modern Finnish has a term which I don't know how to translate properly: "ammattinärkästyjä". It would fit really well here.
- Oxitendwe 9y ago>And it's political, which goes against the HN guidelines. People violate this "guideline" so much that I literally did not even know it was a rule (and yes, I checked beforehand) until I was shadowbanned for it without warning. Apparently the rule is that you can talk about politics if you don't talk about too much, or exclusively, although I strongly suspect it had more to do with having the wrong views than posting about them too frequently (data on this would be welcome).
- krapp 9y agoI believe politics is off topic if it's a mainstream news story - "If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic," as the guidelines say, although that's a bit vague. I think the guidelines allow for political articles with intellectual merit and which demonstrate an "interesting new phenomenon" worth discussing to potentially be on topic.