3 ms·
Summary: First the financial industry plunged us into economic crisis, then it was bailed out at taxpayer expense. [M]any financial-industry high-fliers made
by adolph 16y ago
Summary:
First the financial industry plunged us into economic crisis, then it was bailed out at taxpayer expense.
[M]any financial-industry high-fliers made fortunes through activities that were worthless if not destructive from a social point of view.
[H]igh-frequency trading probably degrades the stock market’s function, because it’s a kind of tax on investors who lack access to those superfast computers. . .
[A] bill setting rules for pay packages...a step in the right direction... is opposed by the Obama administration, which still seems to operate on the principle that what’s good for Wall Street is good for America.
[W]e’ve become a society in which the big bucks go to bad actors, a society that lavishly rewards those who make us poorer.
- tptacek 16y agoBut, no: HFT isn't a tax on poor investors; it's a "tax" on poor middlemen who would otherwise be able to profit from spreads that HFT systems are slashing. If you're a principal buyer or seller of an instrument, because you have a trading objective (capitalizing on an impending market shift, accumulating exposure to a business or industry you believe in, diversifying your portfolio, or simply a speculator), HFTs are (a) at worst simply replacing a middleman that was taking a chunk out of every one of your trades, and (b) at best helping you by refining competition for access to that spread and thus amping up liquidity and making it easier for you to buy or sell. There certainly do appear to be problems with HFT in particular and large-volume algo trading in general; for instance, it appears to drastically amplify volatility and create crazy swings. But that's not the argument Krugman is making. He's saying it's inherently unfair. Bullshit. It's unfair in the same sense that UUNet was unfair to bulletin board systems.
- aliston 16y agoFrom what I've read (which may be outdated), there was a system whereby high frequency traders could discover buyers limit prices by executing a series of small-volume "probe" trades at increasing dollar amounts. Then, once the limit is found, execute the trade at the buyer's limit price. Without HTF, the trade would be executed at a lower price. To me, that sort of asymetry seems unfair -- it's like knowing, in advance of a negotiation, the other person's exact willingness to pay.
- tptacek 16y agoAgain, you're describing a scheme that allows a firm to replace a series of other traders and firms in the spread. The only difference is that instead of a lot of little bites on its way to price discovery, the HFT-inhabited market takes one big one. Meanwhile, you still sell at whatever price you wanted to sell at, and buy at what you wanted to buy at.
- adolph 16y agoRecast as a "tax" on inefficient middlemen, it seems like HFT would be a net wealth generator by compressing the time it takes to discover prices. Is the author's argument that low frequency trading finds the same result, only over a longer period of time? If so, then HFT doesn't add wealth but it does time-shift it. Since there is a limitless supply of future time, doesn't that make HFT similar to being able to crank out more widgets in an hour?
- tptacek 16y agoOr, "Liquidity is good, right?" ;)