3 ms·
Supply and demand. No one claims that housing supply growth alone would predict the rent increase in a given year. We claim that housing supply growth per job,
by closeparen 9y ago
Supply and demand. No one claims that housing supply growth alone would predict the rent increase in a given year. We claim that housing supply growth per job, per migrant, etc. would. YIMBYs are prone to leave off the denominator on the assumption (right or wrong) that there's not much housing policy can do about it, but the argument is fundamentally that the price comes from the relationship between the population seeking housing and the available inventory.
It's much easier to invalidate this strawman by invoking areas where nothing is being built but prices are flat or declining.
As the article mentions, housing inventory has not been allowed to vary much, while the labor market has been through huge boom-bust cycles. So yes, the labor market should be the best predictor of housing prices.