8 ms·
On Unread Books
- platz 9y agoTLDR; the most important thing about a book is it's historical and social context in the web of literature of it's time, so by understanding relationships, peers, and authors, reading the actual text is not necessary
- kenning 9y agotldr of your comment: book is good, smart is very good
- derefr 9y agoI never heard this about books, but this has always been my understanding of modern art. An entirely-red canvas is meaningless and valueless on its own; but in its context as a response, in a specific cultural time and place, to artistic trends of the time, one particular entirely-red canvas is quite valuable indeed. It's much more akin to objects (including books!) signed by people: the value of the object is that the object participated in some part of history, rather than anything about the object per se.
- Bodet 9y agoContext does not add to the fact that the red canvas is still red.
- derefr 9y agoThere is no value to the red canvas; there is only value in the conversation you're able to have about the red canvas, and especially value in controlling that conversation (and where/when it happens) by owning the red canvas. I.e., modern art is valuable in part because people will go to art galleries and museums to stare at denotationally-valueless art if it gives them an excuse to talk/think about art history. Art galleries and museums are willing to buy those pieces to capture that foot-traffic, which gives a price to the pieces.
- platz 9y ago> There is no value to the red canvas; there is only value in the conversation you're able to have about the red canvas You do realize you're a dyed-in-the-wool postmodernist, right?
- keiferski 9y ago1. Modern art is an extremely vast field. I really wish this "modern art = scribble drawings" meme would die. Not to mention that modern != contemporary. 2. It's not really that complicated. Writing operates in the exact same way; without the context of our societal language, a novel would just be "meaningless and valueless" as it would simply be a bunch of black symbols on a piece of paper. This would likely be more obvious if we lived in a visually-based society and not a linguistic-based one.
- derefr 9y ago> Modern art is an extremely vast field. I really wish this "modern art = scribble drawings" meme would die. Is there a name for the specific kind of modern art that has red canvases, soup cans, and splatter-painting as central examples? I'd be glad to change my usage if there were a clearer term. > Not to mention that modern != contemporary. I'm not sure what you mean here; I was using "modern art" to refer specifically to the works of the Modern Art movement—which tended to have a lot of 'scribble-drawings'—rather than more generally to "art made in modern times." > It's not really that complicated. Writing operates in the exact same way; without the context of our societal language, a novel would just be "meaningless and valueless" as it would simply be a bunch of black symbols on a piece of paper. This is silly; a book can tell you a story without you needing to know anything about the time and place the book was written in. You need to know the language of the book, yes, but a book with a considerate author will often subtly teach you any jargon it uses, or the significance of cultural signifiers it refers to, etc. This is why outsider protagonists in fiction are so common. And this is also the point of "annotated editions" of books: authors tend to write assuming their audience will understand their own current cultural milieu, but not that of other cultures or eras. A text that comes from another culture has no value to a layperson from outside that culture, until it is annotated with enough context to make it accessible. Modern art (or whatever you'd call the subset of the movement that has scribble-drawings as its central referent) is not self-contained in this way, in the sense that people don't expect or require modern art to build in a lens for interpreting it, to consider it "good." In a world without the "people like owning signed copies of things" effect, I'd expect art that is meaningless without inaccessible-to-laymen cultural context to mostly fail, in the same way unannotated books from foreign cultures fail; and I'd expect such works to succeed exactly to the degree to which the author—or an intermediate, such as a museum curator—went to the effort to create a more complete work that contains both the piece and its cultural context. You know: really long wall tags. Or a documentary video playing beside the exhibited piece. You do see these, but not very often. Why? Because "art lovers" value being the ones to explain the cultural context to their friends, and value works (and curatory paradigms) that enable this, by avoiding annotation and leaving the works illegible. Thus neatly explaining how the scribble-drawings cluster of works ever achieved popularity at all. "Art snobs", who enjoy—to coin a phrase—artsplaining.
- mseebach 9y agoI think the challenge of a lot of non-aesthetic art is that the context disappears, but the piece remains, yet without the context the piece is a bit of a certain emperor without his clothing. A seminal piece of modern art is Duchamps urinal. Apparently, there was a big exhibition in Paris in the early 20th century, and the organizers were a bit snooty, but tried to be progressive, so there were no rules for this exhibition, anything can be art (context: art was at the time narrowly defined as paintings of identifiable subjects in gilded frame, or something like that). Duchamp supposed they weren't totally earnest about that, so he bought a urinal, signed it and submitted it, and sure enough, the organizers rejected it as "not art". He trolled them. Cool, exposing the hipocrites, big deal at the time. But time has more than caught up with this gag. Exposing hipocrisy today is totally run of the mill, literally daily fare in news, comedy, whatever. This leaves us with people paying $20 to visit a the MOMA and look solemnly at a 100 year old urinal that has literally zero inherent artistic qualities. That belong in a history museum, not an art museum. Perhaps modern art museums should be understood more as an art history museum, we're there because it feels significant to be physically near a historically significant object, not to enjoy any inherent qualities of the object.
- mseebach 9y agoI think it's similar to how software engineers can talk about some language being Turing complete, referencing Kent Beck on TDD, shout out to GoF or even describing a type as boolean, without having read the works in question[1]. The important lessons from these works have diffused into, as you say, our context. That said, and not having read the book in question ;), I think TFA is to be read in the context of literary professionals, not muggles[2] who read books for the enjoyment of actually reading the book. 1: The Turing paper is supposed to be a very enjoyable read. Needless to say, I haven't actually read it. 2: I haven't read any Harry Potter.
- ukulele 9y agoStrategizing about how to discuss a book you haven't read has to be the ultimate form of pretentiousness.
- mseebach 9y agoVery literally so.
- memco 9y agoAlso a common discipline among students.
- coldtea 9y agoOr mere utility/functionality (save time not reading some books AND advance your scholarly/literary/etc career as someone who reads and knows them). A con isn't "pretentious". People who have actually read a book can be much more pretentious about it -- in the sense of acting as if this gave them some unique insight over other mere mortals who haven't read it.
- floofyfloofer 9y agoAny book worth reading should be worth reading because of that insight. Which might be a way to say that most words aren't writing, and especially these.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gallerdude 9y agoI've felt a very small version of this in watching certain movies. When I saw Stand By Me, I understood Stranger Things and Super 8 a lot more.
- sanderjd 9y agoFor sure, context can have a multiplicative effect on the value of a text. This article seems to be arguing that context is the value itself, which doesn't quite ring true to me.
- everyone 9y agoImo a lot of literature has 0 novel content, so this is not suprising. Additional: I'm always shitting on the humanities in the comments here. I dont have anything against them, I both produce them and consume massive quantities of them. My point is simply that they are trivial. If all art suddenly disappeared it wouldnt really matter. If knowledge about, and/or the fruits of STEM stuff disappeared it would be a huge setback, it could cause civilization to collapse. Additional additional: It bugs me how large a percentage of our resources we plow into entertainment. eg. "On a global scale, the entertainment and media market was worth 1.72 trillion U.S. dollars in 2015 and is set to rise to 2.14 trillion by 2020" NASAs current yearly budget is about 18.4 billion
- Santosh83 9y agoNot everything we produce needs to be valued by how much they contribute to industrial/scientific civilization. I specify that because loss of much of STEM won't lead to collapse of civilization, it will only set us back to the dark ages. We'll begin again. Same as we'd do if all art disappeared.
- everyone 9y agoIts not the same. If all existing art disappeared we would still be able to produce art at our current rate with no discernible or measurable difference in its quality or effect. Scientific or technological progress on the other hand is iterative. More advanced theories are slowly formulated on the backs of older ones. For precision tools for example you need to start off building crude tools with nothing, then use those to build the infrastructure that will allow you to build slightly more precise tools and so on.
- padraic7a 9y ago"Its not the same. If all existing art disappeared we would still be able to produce art at our current rate with no discernible or measurable difference in its quality or effect." That's a very strange idea. If all existing novels dissappeared do you think we would produce novels straight away? If all painting dissappeared would we paint with perspective, or in abstract, or just go for rough cave type paintings? How long would it take us to come up with rhyming metre, or the observational essay, cinema or stand-up? You think we'd start from having no references and create this immediately?
- svat 9y agoWhen I saw the title here, I immediately thought of the 2007 book How To Talk About Books You Haven't Read by Pierre Bayard. And when I opened the article, I find that it is indeed a review/summary of that book, by Umberto Eco… which I guess goes to show something or the other. Bayard's book is a masterpiece; I found it hilarious and recommended it to a friend, who has taken to it so much he buys copies for others and often uses “Bayardian” as an adjective. All the stuff surrounding the book only add to its enjoyment (after you've read it), such as the fact that there was a question mark in the original title which went away in the translation, the author's coy refusal to say whether he was serious or joking, and his insistence in interviews that the opinions in the book are not his own but that of a fictionalized persona… I think I found this book because it was highly rated on the interesting complete review site (its review of this book is here: http://www.complete-review.com/reviews/books/bayardp.htm http://www.complete-review.com/reviews/books/bayardp.htm). Not everyone is likely to enjoy this book (some found it pointless), but worth taking a look.
- paganel 9y ago> When I saw the title here, I immediately thought of the 2007 book How To Talk About Books You Haven't Read by Pierre Bayard. I've started speaking about this book with my gf for about 2 or 3 years now, even though I haven't read it (and will not read it in the near future, as my to-read-next list is quite big and always growing). I find it's an excellent book, and much more so as it's recommended by a writer like Eco, a guy who I did actually read (even though that happened 20 years ago, so the details are fuzzy) and who forever influenced my view on books and how to read and interpret them. I also heartily recommend Poe's "The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym of Nantucket". I'm not from an English-speaking country so it wasn't required reading for me while in school, but I nevertheless found its no-ending thingie as the quintessence of modern literature. In fact, Eco has often talked about the Gordon Pym story, one of the characters of one of his novels is named exactly like that.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nkhodyunya 9y agoI don't always enjoy the books I've read, but i always enjoy those that I haven't. People never ask me for recommendations. In spite of this, I generously provide my unwanted opinion.