5 ms·
A Billionaire Destroyed His Newsrooms Out of Spite
- nether 9y agoGood.
- username223 9y agoHow so?
- johnnyg 9y agoA group of workers who weren't making money decided to get together to increase the ask of the owner of the business. That's a big red flag that says "we aren't united in fixing what's wrong here". At that point, the situation is impossible. There's little to no chance of a path to profitability. This isn't some 100 year old car making giant who can be abused for decades and still remain standing, its a money losing small media outlet fighting for survival and relevance. That same group of workers can start another similar business under their control tomorrow. I bet they won't. They want "someone else" to fix their problems. One of their problems appears to be math. There were real problems unions solved in this country. True "we own the store, we own your house, we've blocked the exits, your boss has a gun pointed at you" abuses. This is so comically far from that. The only joke left in the story is the outrage of the article's author for not seeing the obvious, inevitable conclusion that he and his peers forced. I'd like my 20 minutes back from having to have read and responded to this junk. There are serious liberal viewpoints put forth on HN but Mr Hamilton Nolan, yours sir, isn't one of them.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"A group of workers who weren't making money decided to get together to increase the ask of the owner of the business." According to the article: "DNAinfo was never profitable, but Mr. Ricketts was happy to invest in it for eight years, praising its work all along. Gothamist, on the other hand, was profitable, and a fairly recent addition to the company." So at least Gothamist -- one of the companies that Ricketts shut down -- was actually profitable.
- manigandham 9y agoSo one of them becomes even more unprofitable and the other could potentially be unprofitable as well now. Either way, the total net increase in cost across both can easily make the entire venture no longer worth it.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"So one of them becomes even more unprofitable" How do you know this exactly? Maybe the union would make it even more profitable, because it forces the employer to finally treat the employees fairly, and that boosts morale, improving their performance, which increases the quality of their work, and thereby increases profits. "the other could potentially be unprofitable" Anything "could potentially become unprofitable". This is sheer speculation. What's not speculation is that it was profitable until it was shut down. "Either way, the total net increase in cost across both can easily make the entire venture no longer worth it." How do you know there's any increase in costs at all? And if there were increases in costs, how do you know they're not offset by improved performance, morale, or reputation?
- manigandham 9y agoThis entire opinion piece is speculation. Also it's all a single company with multiple properties so 1 single site being profitable doesn't seem like a strong argument.
- pmoriarty 9y agoIt is a strong argument against someone claiming that they weren't profitable. They clearly were.
- dogruck 9y agoI think this is a weak op-ed with an argument that’s primarily supported by emotions such as anger. Nothing is stopping the writers from unionizing. As a union, they can then work for whatever business would like to hire them. It’s not like “The Billionaire” decided to lock the union out, and exclusively employ freelancers. He decided to shut the business down — tough cookies.
- jonathankoren 9y agoYou seem to fundamentally misunderstand what a union is, and how they work. Unions are fundamentally tied to a specific employer.
- dogruck 9y agoCheck ya self before ya clown ya self: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Writers_Guild_of_America,_East https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Writers_Guild_of_America,_East
- jonathankoren 9y agoYou mislinked to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_union Think about it. What’s the point of holding specific votes at specific employers to unionize? Union locals and unions in general do not solicit competitive bids for contract work as the OP implied. That simply doesn’t happen, and to believe that it does, is to not understand how unions operate.
- dogruck 9y agoYou argue by assuming ignorance, and following up with insult and nonsense. Remarkably ineffective and immature.
- jonathankoren 9y agoAnd you can't even quote Ice Cube correctly.
- Sevii 9y agoSo a billionaire decided to shut down his 'business', because he didn't want to deal with a union. If your 'business' never makes money and wasn't expected to make money isn't it basically an illegal charity or political organization?
- gruez 9y ago>If your 'business' never makes money and wasn't expected to make money isn't it basically an illegal charity or political organization? what makes it illegal? i get how it's illegal if it's a charity that's making money, but how is it illegal for a business not to make money?
- sremani 9y agoIt was a Vanity project until the jurnos Unionized, and he did not want to put with that. Also, he may have other interests who would take his tolerance of his "media" unions as a sign and unionize. To just assigning it to "spite" is narrative bias, in my opinion.
- pwtweet 9y agoA rational business person would attempt to sell it. They would also keep the websites and content online with advertising systems intact as to allow for some residual revenue. This guy didn't attempt to sell the business and had the websites and archives deleted.
- fellellor 9y agoThough I agree that it is spite, the article states that the archives are back up as of now.
- markdown 9y ago> To just assigning it to "spite" is narrative bias, in my opinion. If a capitalist no longer wants to have anything to do with something he built, the logical thing to do would be to sell it and get some of his $ back. This would also keep the people who helped him build his vanity project employed. I can't think of a reason to shut it down other than to hurt people.
- Digory 9y agoGiven the NLRB issue, I suspect this was already heavily lawyered and gamed out. Not that he's not angry, but he'd already decided the vote would make it a total loss or close enough. The change in union status may have made it difficult to sell anything ongoing. The biggest asset would be Gothamist's domain name and anyone with that domain was going to have to wade into the labor mess. "Here's an organization running in the red, obligated to negotiate an uncertain new contract with all its employees under NLRB rules! What are my bids?" Might as well save the auction and lawyer fees and take the loss in 2017.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y ago> "DNAinfo was never profitable, but Mr. Ricketts was happy to invest in it for eight years" Anyone who thinks anyone can be "happy" to "invest" in a non-profitable company for eight years shouldn't be writing articles about business decisions. Also, this "billionaire" qualifier to make the story more sensational is so cliche.
- kolbe 9y agoI don't blame the guy. He was already doing charity work by floating the company. I'm sure he thought that since he was sacrificing money for it, his employees should also make sacrifices and be paid in a commensurate fashion.
- couchand 9y agoAs a regular reader of Gothamist, I was very disappointed to hear that they were shutting down. At first, it seemed like so many other stories I've heard: a plucky crew working hard to produce solid journalism getting taken down by the cold, heartless business of online advertising. After digging into it a bit, I was surprised to find out that it was just like so many other stories I've heard: a group of workers that built a successful business trying to ensure they get to participate in a share of that success, only to be shut out by a ruthless capitalist who can't stand the idea of a union preventing him from hoarding all the gains.
- gboudrias 9y agoThe mixture of cultures here on HN is interesting. There are some very anti-union folks and some very pro-union folks (such as myself). The article is very opinionated, and I admire that. I for one think that if a union threatens the viability of your business, then your business model never counted on treating other humans as the vital pieces they are. I am not saddened by the end of such a project (vanity or no), it's simply the natural conclusion of unplanned factors.
- pmoriarty 9y agoThere are lot more pro-union people on HN than there used to be. Not too many years ago any mention of unions on HN would have nearly the entire HN community frothing at the mouth. These days you'll actually find not a few pro-union voices making themselves heard, as in the last article on this subject to make HN's front page: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15616156 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15616156
- dailen 9y agoYeah I agree, the title alone reads to me like my toddler tattling on his brother. Oh I got it maybe the author prefer an impartial unit that could run the media instead and make sure everything is fair for everyone. Kinda like North Korea! ;-) Seriously though, the article reads like a bit of frustration and foot stomping.
- ghaff 9y agoThe article (as opposed to this op-ed) in the Times yesterday was more balanced. [1] It's probably fair to say that there was spite involved--the timing, the immediate takedown of the sites, etc. But it's also fairly clear that the shutdown was probably going to happen sooner or later in any case. Maybe the unionization was the proverbial straw but I'm not sure how different the end result would have been. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/02/nyregion/dnainfo-gothamist-shutting-down.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/02/nyregion/dnainfo-gothamis...
- pg_bot 9y agoHas anyone tried to run a newspaper as a co-op? If you feel like you can run the organization and are pro employee ownership this seems like the logical progression if you feel cheated out of a job. On the other hand I can understand why anyone who is running an unprofitable business would want to shut it down if it were highly likely that it is going to lose more money in the future.
- couchand 9y agoOTOH, the Gothamist was profitable, so what does that mean?
- pg_bot 9y agoThat means there is unfulfilled demand for a media organization and that someone should be able to fill it. If Joe Ricketts wants to throw money away that is his own prerogative. If I were a former staff member who voted to unionize, I would start a new site and use this momentum as a launching point.
- JSONwebtoken 9y agoJournalists shouldn't be demanding higher pay while news revenues are falling across the board and the industry is being inundated with more Communications grads than ever. The economics just don't work out in the ad-block and fake news era.
- gottebp 9y agoI love guilds. I know the article mixes the term with unions, but they are truly different. For a union the primary weapon is withholding of labor by many (replaceable) individual members. Guilds however do not need large numbers to be powerful. They are composed of skilled (ie: less replaceable) artisans and small businesses, and have power by actually owning and wielding property/capital. If there were a "software engineers guild" today it would retain the power to withdraw rights to the intellectual property of its members from any company behaving unethically. Much like how guests visiting a home for a party are expected to behave, a guild works with businesses that are well behaved and punishes those that are not. It holds both its members and outsiders wishing to contract with it to ethical standards that our legal system cannot because it is too gray area. Sort of like how one decides not to invite a bad guest over to the home again. eg: Situations such as FB/Instagram blatantly copying Snapchat features, or Apple sherlocking F.lux with Nightshift while not illegal, could be judged as unethical by members. If unresponsive to pressure to make things right, the guild could respond by withdrawing rights to use its member-owned-IP from the offending company. eg: Imagine certain OSS licenses having a stipulation that one be in "good standing" with the associated guild in order to use it. It only takes a small number of artisans with property to have quite an arsenal. A guild with just a few of the big names in the OSS community would be formidable. Ageism, monopolies, and many other threats out there easily fall down. Remember: guilds went up against kings in the middle ages and often held their own. One last thing: Unions do not own common-stock, but guilds certainly do. In fact they would even seek to become majority holders. This aligns interests of the members with company success. Guilds also have to hold members to a very high standard. There is much more to guilds vs. unions however I'll stop there. One can dream.
- yairhaimo 9y agoCraftsmanship (and its derivatives) is a long talked about topic. I agree that it would be a great idea (or at least a great experiment). What we did in the company I work for is create profession-based company-wide guilds. These guilds (that's what we call them too) back their members professionally and make sure their professional progress is not stagnant (among recruitment and consulting). In addition, the guilds keep the LOBs in check. A guild member can "snitch" about a bad practice that their boss is forcing them to do (skip tests in order to hasten the dev process for example). A guild master or the guild leader will then meet with the project leader and hold them in check. Hopefully this can be cross-company but until then we can do it inside each (medium and up) company.