4 ms·
If Your Vibrator Is Hacked, Is It a Sex Crime?
- anigbrowl 9y agoAn interesting question. I'm inclined to say yes, insofar as the device is identifiable as a sex toy rather than just 'adjustable thing #73'. As to which sex crime, that depends on both the circumstances and the degree of information about them available to the remote abuser. Those inclined to offer defenses of the form that 'it was just a prank, 1337 h4x0r5 couldn't have known how it would impact the victim' should brush up on the 'eggshell skull' rule in tort law, which basically says the person who commits a tort is liable for all consequences, not just easily foreseeable ones, and the concept of strict liability, which can mean you're fully responsible for the outcomes of some criminal acts even without proof of intent. Judges often pieces of existing conceptual frameworks when presented with a novel situation on which they have to issue a ruling.
- vanattab 9y agoIf sell a laptop bundled with pornography/livecam software and market it as a "sexual entertainment system" would any hack of that system also be elevated to the level of sex crime? Even if all the attacker saw before launching the attack was the ip address?
- anigbrowl 9y agoI don't think so, but I'm not an attorney. You'd have to some prior awareness, I bring up the strict liability idea just because if you did know that you were hacking some stranger's sex toy, your lack of complete knowledge about what they doing with it at the time probably wouldn't be enough to avoid liability. I mean, otherwise you could grope strangers on the subway while keeping your eyes closed and claim that you weren't looking at them so you didn't know that your groping was causing them distress. Then again pretty offer some pretty wacky defenses, especially where sex is concerned.
- robbrit 9y agoThis brings a whole new meaning to the phrase "penetration testing".
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoI think the CFAA statute is appropriate, but as to whether it would be a sex crime, I think it would have to depend on the context. If a vibrator was hacked and messed with but nobody was using it, then it's just hacking. But if someone was using it, then I think a sex crime charge is fair, especially if the hacker knows its being used intimately, which would be akin to being a peeping Tom, but creepily closer.
- angersock 9y agoCFAA is hilariously overly broad. Charging it as a sex crime seems a bit off, least of all because of all of the treatment of sex offenders in the US. There seems to be a qualitative difference between turning on a publicly-exposed vibrating buttplug and forcibly inserting something into the rectum of an unwilling participant. Like, is it really reasonable to say that somebody should lose the right to vote and bear arms because they issued a POST request to an unsecured web server in their neighborhood that happened to be a sex toy? EDIT: I don't want to sound like I'm blaming victims here, but using toys that are properly locked down is the responsibility of the participants--much like making sure they're sterile.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoIntent is usually necessary for a crime to have occurred, in the case of the accidental POST. I think the sex offender registry has a lot of...how to put this..."societal-technical" debt, a reasonable solution to a serious problem that causes all sorts of harm on its own. I think that's a topic better suited for an entirely separate conversation.
- kelnos 9y ago> I don't want to sound like I'm blaming victims here, but using toys that are properly locked down is the responsibility of the participants--much like making sure they're sterile. Despite your "I don't want to sound..." prefix, that is literally the definition of victim-blaming. Just because I leave the door to my house unlocked, it doesn't mean people have the right to enter it without my permission, and it's not my "fault" if they do. Engaging in sexual contact requires consent. I expect it's legally debatable if remotely turning on a vibrator that's already inserted into someone counts as "sexual contact" (I would say it is, or if not, should be), but if it is, it requires consent. I think intent and foreknowledge does matter here: if someone just found a random web server and sent some requests to it without knowing what it is or what it does, I'd say that's unwise, but not criminal. But if it's obvious from the name advertised by the device and/or the names of the endpoints accessed, or requires knowledge of a protocol specific to a connected sex toy, I'd say that should be enough to establish nefarious sexual intent.
- jondubois 9y agoWell I think it depends on the degree of control which the attacker is exerting on the device and the type and quantity of information which they extracted from the device during its use. As an actuator, a vibrator has a very limiting set of features for an attacker to exploit and act upon. As a sensor, I don't think they're very advanced.
- mikehines 9y agoThe headline sounds like a Philip K Dick title.
- ellius 9y agoHahaha nicely done
- ashildr 9y agoBeing a relatively kinky person myself I’d still. consider shoving quite a sizable Li-Ion battery into my body a way bigger potential problem than some foreign person activating my buttplug. But yes, the question is interesting. I can imagine situations where unknown people taking control is part of the play.