3 ms·
> The idea that you can replace responsible citizens and competent leaders with a ruling elite of (more or less) enlightened individuals given catholic powers f
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
> The idea that you can replace responsible citizens and competent leaders with a ruling elite of (more or less) enlightened individuals given catholic powers for life is an idea at least as long as democracy itself (possibly discoursed over even earlier than Plato's The Republic). Personally, I'm not sympathetic to it.
Isn't this just royalty, and the concept of noblesse oblige? One of the very things that the United States was formed as an antithesis to?
- bllguo 9y agoOnly if you conveniently ignore the word "enlightened," which also happens to be the most important word there. More like a meritocratic oligarchy?
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoI did say "a ruling elite of (more or less) enlightened individuals" :)
- pavel_lishin 9y agoYou think the monarchs and nobility didn't think they were enlightened? Or do you just mean enlightened by your standards?