4 ms·
> I'd rather live in a world where 20 countries have 50 warheads each, then one where two countries have 4,000 warheads each. I absolutely would not. Those 2 c
by ars 9y ago
> I'd rather live in a world where 20 countries have 50 warheads each, then one where two countries have 4,000 warheads each.
I absolutely would not. Those 2 countries know far more about the process then those other countries, and they have the budget to do it right. You would have to duplicate labs, and computers, and other efforts 20 times in your scenario, and each of those labs will not be as good as the 2 higher funded ones.
> A weapon detonating by accident is terrible. Thousands of weapons on hair-trigger alert is civilization-ending.
Look at it from a fear point of view: No one will detonate a thousand weapons unless they are declaring total war. So all one needs to do is read global moods and see if total war is likely (it's not). (i.e. war might happen, but not total war)
An accident on the other hand can happen randomly, you would be permanently and constantly worried about one.
- taurath 9y agoMajor conflicts only happen in non nuclear states. In all honesty I’ll bet that’s what has kept India and Pakistan from a war.
- lostlogin 9y agoHow do you define a major conflict? Iraq seemed pretty big, and so did Afghanistan.
- a_t48 9y agoThe draft wasn't invoked, so there's that.
- aidenn0 9y agoThose didn't happen in nuclear states.
- lostlogin 9y agoChina has had several major border skirmishes with India, some with Russia and with Taiwan and I’m sure there are others too. Israel has had lots. Russia has had some ugly episodes too.
- taurath 9y agoI'd argue that the other side having nukes is what kept them to being skirmishes. Plenty of ugly episodes for sure but there is a cap on how much conflict can happen before the doomsday machines come out.
- exhilaration 9y agoAhem... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Pakistani_wars_and_conflicts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Pakistani_wars_and_confli...
- lostlogin 9y agoWho are the two countries you speak of? There have been some pretty spectacular accidents due to underfunding and poor performance in superpowers.
- rflrob 9y ago> No one will detonate a thousand weapons unless they are declaring total war. Or if they believe (rightly or wrongly) that the other nuclear power has declared total war. There's been a number of false alarms that have been successfully ignored, but what if one of those false alarms came during the Cuban missile crisis or immediately after the invasion of Afghanistan?
- rangibaby 9y ago> Cuban missile crisis US dropped depth charges on a USSR submarine and the latter thought WWIII had begun. Three people had to agree to use nuclear weapons and two did.
- vkou 9y ago> I absolutely would not. Those 2 countries know far more about the process then those other countries, and they have the budget to do it right. You would have to duplicate labs, and computers, and other efforts 20 times in your scenario, and each of those labs will not be as good as the 2 higher funded ones. If your goal is maintaining an arsenal of world-ending weapons cheaply, sure. I am not trying to optimize for that use case. > No one will detonate a thousand weapons unless they are declaring total war. Or they think that the other side declared total war. Or they are engaged in a small-scale conventional war, and are afraid the other side will escalate. Or they are escalating, by using tactical weapons, and the other side retaliates with strategical weapons. (Spoilers: Russia has made it very clear that it will use tactical nuclear weapons, against military targets, in an otherwise conventional conflict.) Or there's an intelligence failure, and they believe that they are the target of a sneak attack. All of these are incredibly plausible ways for a nuclear war to start.
- hitekker 9y agoAgreed. In this vein, Politico noted six years ago: >I talked with the president at one of those fundraisers some months back, and I asked him, "What keeps you up at night?" > And he said, "Everything. Everything that gets to my desk is a critical mass. If it gets to my desk, then no one else could have handled it." So I said, "So what's the one that keeps you up at night?" > He goes, "There are quite a few." > So I go, "What's the one? Period." > And he says, "Pakistan." > I get that: There's the question of whether Zardari's government is actually in control, or whether the military is. And how close the Taliban, or Al Qaeda, or whoever else is to having their hands on real weapons of mass destruction. It's the closest government there is to allowing those weapons to either be used or sold to places that we really wouldn't like to have those weapons. That's a concern for all of us. One bad actor ruins the game.