3 ms·
>> without hitting the missile and causing an explosion. >> caused a short circuit that resulted in an explosion. >> Luckily, the cone did not do enough damage
by sandworm101 9y ago
>> without hitting the missile and causing an explosion.
>> caused a short circuit that resulted in an explosion.
>> Luckily, the cone did not do enough damage to the missile to cause the missile to explode.
To clarify: There was absolutely no chance at any point of a nuclear explosion. The article suggests that some big explosion was on the edge of possibility which, given the context, one might think would be a nuclear explosion. The warhead, the "physics package", was never really a worry. Getting those to detonate requires some careful triggering.
This was also a SOLID fuel rocket. While you wouldn't want to damage it, it wasn't full of the nasty pressurized liquids of other missiles. Getting its fuel to actually ignite would require more than hitting it with a hammer. You need something akin to a blasting cap. Shuttle used something more like a giant flamethrower. The solid retro rockets were not directly triggered by a the short circuit. I'd bet good money that their ignition system felt the short rather than the fuel being ignited by the short.
- bjt2n3904 9y agoNot an aerospace engineer or anything. I think the fear was that the rocket may tip over and collapse under its own weight. I wouldn't be too surprised if that could trigger an ignition of the rocket fuel at the very least, risking nuclear contamination. While the physics package surely has numerous safeties, I'd be concerned that the safeties would be damaged in a way that no one could really predict after falling 80 feet. They served their purpose well, but you can bet all the engineers were in the lab for the next 72 hours straight looking for various failure modes.
- sandworm101 9y ago>> ...one could really predict after falling 80 feet. I'd say that deep within the archives is a report detailing exactly this scenario. Drop testing of munitions is standard stuff. See https://www.rtc.army.mil/Resources/Capability%20Sheets/Insensitive%20Munitions%20Testing.pdf https://www.rtc.army.mil/Resources/Capability%20Sheets/Insen...
- robryk 9y agoAny damage to the warhead would likely make it impossible to have a nuclear reaction. In order to do that, the warhead would have to explode multiple precisely shaped conventional explosives with precise timing. If any one of them was deformed, nothing (apart from the small conventional explosion) would happen, even if all the safeguards incorrectly decided to explode the warhead.
- robotresearcher 9y agoparent was concerned about > risking nuclear contamination. not a nuclear explosion. A conventional boom could spread radioactive materials all over.
- robryk 9y agoEDIT: I was wrong. See the child for correction. There are no radioactive materials in the warhead. In other words: there are no materials that undergo radioactive decay. What is in there are fissile materials: ie. materials that emit neutrons upon being irradiated with neutrons. The only way the warhead might become radioactive is if it partially detonated.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago> There was absolutely no chance at any point of a nuclear explosion Exactly. Even if the conventional primer went off it's not gonna cause a create the conditions necessary for fission because it wasn't set off by the detonator.
- lostlogin 9y agoThere have been other accidents where multistage fail safes failed at multiple stages. I’d stand back.
- cmurf 9y agoThat's a big part of Command and Control, the farther back in time you go, the greater the likelihood the design of the warhead was not one point safe and it wasn't at all assured that it'd take careful triggering to get a full or partial nuclear explosion. A decent chunk of later nuclear tests were to help make bombs one point safe. But even then, it there were absolutely rudimentary fail safes that basically worked on the honor system, for well over a decade. Anyway you still have a mess on your hand if the explosives detonate but there's no chain reaction.
- oconnor663 9y ago> This was also a SOLID fuel rocket. Oh cool, I was wondering why they didn't just defuel the rocket first thing.