3 ms·
The world wars aren’t the top wars for percentage of living humans killed, and may not even be the top in terms of absolute numbers of humans killed. For exampl
by mikeash 9y ago
The world wars aren’t the top wars for percentage of living humans killed, and may not even be the top in terms of absolute numbers of humans killed. For example, the An Lushan Rebellion may have killed 10-15% of all humans alive at the time.
- coldtea 9y ago>For example, the An Lushan Rebellion may have killed 10-15% of all humans alive at the time. Those numbers are highly discredited. Historians such as Charles Patrick Fitzgerald argue that a claim of 36 million deaths is incompatible with contemporary accounts of the war. They point out that the numbers recorded on the postwar registers reflect not only population loss, but also a breakdown of the census system as well as the removal from the census figures of various classes of untaxed persons, such as those in religious orders, foreigners and merchants. For these reasons, census numbers for the post-rebellion Tang are considered unreliable. Another consideration is the fact that the territory controlled by Tang central authority was diminished by the equivalent of several of the northern provinces, so that something like a quarter of the surviving population were no longer within the area subject to the imperial revenue system. So, in all, even less that 5%...
- mikeash 9y agoEven the low estimate is gigantic. The high estimate for WWII is something like 3-4% of the world population.
- coldtea 9y agoWhat's actually gigantic and not just perceived as such though, also changes with the scale -- since we're talking about percentages. If the earth had just 200 people, 20 of them killed is 10%, but it's nothing that a small determined fight between two tribes can't easily achieve, without even weapons. Whereas the 3-4% of the 3 billion during WWII is a much bigger affair -- took tons of bombs, battles, war-caused famines, an extermination program, and even nuclear bombs...
- mikeash 9y agoAnd despite all that, the proportion was lower and the absolute numbers at least comparable. Deaths on an enormous scale, including lots and lots of civilians, isn't anything new to the 20th century.