3 ms·
I've addressed the popular mechanics article in other comments. It's difficult to square some of its key claims with the description of events in the accident r
by foldr 9y ago
I've addressed the popular mechanics article in other comments. It's difficult to square some of its key claims with the description of events in the accident report. In particular, the report gives no indication that any of the three pilots successfully identified that the plane was stalled.
The fundamental issue here is that if only one pilot has his hand on the stick (which should always be true) then linked sticks won't help much, and if both have their hands on the stick (which triggers both audio and visual warnings on the airbus) then they are already fighting over the sticks, indicating a total breakdown of cockpit discipline. The author of the popular mechanics article appears to think that it's normal for both pilots to be holding their sticks at the same time.
It's also worth noting that a half-competent PNF could have looked at (i) the pitch attitude, (ii) the throttle setting and (iii) the rate of descent and concluded that the plane was stalled. The fact that the PNF never managed to integrate these three very basic pieces of information makes it seem rather unlikely that he would have paid close attention to the position of his (hypothetically linked) control stick.
Note that when the PNF took over the controls briefly, he made a lateral input rather than pushing the stick forward! (p. 183)
Finally, sidesticks don't really have "a position". The airbus is usually flown using short movements away from center with the stick then returning to the center.
- dredmorbius 9y agoPilot error based on the actions of a single pilot, or even, in extreme cases, two pilots, might reasonably be attributed. To have three pilots fail to grasp a situation central to principles of flight, and to have similar situations arise in other aircraft, suggests exogenous factors at play. You've repeatedly made the case that multiple pilots fighting for control indicates a breakdown of cockpit discipline. You've failed to note that the pilots showed no awareness of such a conflict, or, further, that the stick-back position couldn't be readily identified by anyone other than the pilot applying that input. You're insinuating that AF had three other-than-half-competent pilots in the cockpit, which raises numerous other concerns. You're litigating use of the term "position" rather than the general understanding of "force feedback" which applies whether controls have a significant range of motion (traditional mechanical yoke) or a very short throw (sidestick). In general, you're showing very little charitability to points of view differing from your own, which raises concerns.
- foldr 9y agoIt's clear from the available transcripts that there were only brief moments when both pilots were making stick inputs, as otherwise the "dual input" alarm would have sounded repeatedly. So it seems likely that for the most part, the pilots knew which of them was in control. That would makes sense, as there are clear audio and visual indications of this. I have not been able to find any source other than the popular mechanics article (and its descendants) suggesting that there were extended periods of time where both pilots had their hands on their sticks and were making conflicting inputs. Accidents almost by definition involve rare confluences of factors. This one seems to have involved two incompetent pilots in the cockpit, and a captain who came in too late to resolve the situation. Pilot error does happen. There have previously been accidents caused by pilot error when three or more people were present in the cockpit. I'm not "litigating" the use of position. My point is that if you looked at the position of the pilot's stick, it would usually be in the center position, even if the control surfaces were significantly deflected. For example, if you push the stick forward and then let it return to the center, the plane will pitch down, and remain in that attitude until the stick is pushed again. To know the deflection of the control surfaces, you'd have to mentally track "number * length of forward movements - number * length of backward movements".