4 ms·
It's weird that the abstract of the first scholarly paper linked in this article basically disproves the headline of the article. From the article: "Because o
by nostrademons 9y ago
It's weird that the abstract of the first scholarly paper linked in this article basically disproves the headline of the article. From the article:
"Because once in our history, the world-wide population of human beings skidded so sharply we were down to roughly a thousand reproductive adults."
And from the abstract of the paper that that text links to:
"Both genetic and anthropological data are incompatible with the hypothesis of a recent population size bottleneck. "
- lokiboy 9y ago"The world-wide population of human beings skidded so sharply we were down to roughly a thousand reproductive adults." This is a completely mind blowing idea that humans were down to a count of about 1000 adults. Look at us now at 7 billion, and we just can't stop warring with our fellow relatives.
- BurningFrog 9y agoA smaller percentage of the world population than ever is fighting or suffering war these days than ever before.
- pizza 9y agoThose who commit war can kill a much higher multiplier of casualties than ever before, however. It would get pretty bad if there were a reason for the percentage who are fighting had a reason to broaden their scope.
- coldtea 9y ago"These days" being the last few decades? No sign that this is not just a temporary stop, in fact the opposite. There were periods of relative peace in world history for longer than that. In the last 100 years we had 2 world wars, 100s of millions killed, and tons of peripheral wars during the "Cold War". Besides for a lot of modern history wars didn't involve much of the citizenry (they had mercenary armies). Now civilians are almost fair game. And where they had arrows, spears and swords for most of history, we now have airforces and atomic bombs.
- RepressedEmu 9y agoYes but in the last 100 years we've also added around 6 BILLION new people. 100 million dead is a drop in the bucket compared to the amount thats been added due to advancing technology and culture.
- mikeash 9y agoThe world wars aren’t the top wars for percentage of living humans killed, and may not even be the top in terms of absolute numbers of humans killed. For example, the An Lushan Rebellion may have killed 10-15% of all humans alive at the time.
- coldtea 9y ago>For example, the An Lushan Rebellion may have killed 10-15% of all humans alive at the time. Those numbers are highly discredited. Historians such as Charles Patrick Fitzgerald argue that a claim of 36 million deaths is incompatible with contemporary accounts of the war. They point out that the numbers recorded on the postwar registers reflect not only population loss, but also a breakdown of the census system as well as the removal from the census figures of various classes of untaxed persons, such as those in religious orders, foreigners and merchants. For these reasons, census numbers for the post-rebellion Tang are considered unreliable. Another consideration is the fact that the territory controlled by Tang central authority was diminished by the equivalent of several of the northern provinces, so that something like a quarter of the surviving population were no longer within the area subject to the imperial revenue system. So, in all, even less that 5%...
- mikeash 9y agoEven the low estimate is gigantic. The high estimate for WWII is something like 3-4% of the world population.
- coldtea 9y agoWhat's actually gigantic and not just perceived as such though, also changes with the scale -- since we're talking about percentages. If the earth had just 200 people, 20 of them killed is 10%, but it's nothing that a small determined fight between two tribes can't easily achieve, without even weapons. Whereas the 3-4% of the 3 billion during WWII is a much bigger affair -- took tons of bombs, battles, war-caused famines, an extermination program, and even nuclear bombs...
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoFirst suspects in a murder are usually the family.
- mirimir 9y agoThe article is mixing evidence for bottlenecks at different times. Your quote ... > Because once in our history, the world-wide population of human beings skidded so sharply we were down to roughly a thousand reproductive adults. ... links to Hawks et al. (2000), with this in the abstract ... > It is our conclusion that, at the moment, genetic data cannot disprove a simple model of exponential population growth following a bottleneck 2 MYA at the origin of our lineage and extending through the Pleistocene. Archaeological and paleontological data indicate that this model is too oversimplified to be an accurate reflection of detailed population history, and therefore we find that genetic data lack the resolution to validly reflect many details of Pleistocene human population change. However, there is one detail that these data are sufficient to address. Both genetic and anthropological data are incompatible with the hypothesis of a recent population size bottleneck. Such an event would be expected to leave a significant mark across numerous genetic loci and observable anatomical traits, but while some subsets of data are compatible with a recent population size bottleneck, there is no consistently expressed effect that can be found across the range where it should appear, and this absence disproves the hypothesis. So yes, according to that study, the rest of the article is bullshit. But then, it was published in 2000.
- nl 9y agoI'm not sure that "1000 reproductive adults" disproves the headline at all - that's a barely viable population group. I agree that it is fairly different from the "40 breeding pairs" quoted at times in the article though.
- nostrademons 9y agoIt's not that "1000 reproductive adults" disproves the headline, it's that the paper that that quote links to says there's no evidence for a recent population bottleneck.
- gone35 9y agoUnsurprising. Krulwich is particularly notorious for sloppy science writing/reporting/whatever he does.