3 ms·
Hope they release some kind of post-mortem report -- even if it was done out of malice, admitting that -- and providing some details on how this will be prevent
by danso 9y ago
Hope they release some kind of post-mortem report -- even if it was done out of malice, admitting that -- and providing some details on how this will be prevented in the future -- is much better than a vague excuse that leaves everything to the imagination.
Having never worked anywhere on the scale of Twitter, the only non-malicious kind of human error I can think of is like when Google accidentally blacklisted all of Internet as malware [0]. What would be the accidental step/keystroke that happened to target the most controversial user account? Unless @realdonaldtrump was part of the manual-moderation queue and a human accidentally approved the ban.
But that would seem to indicate that @realdonaldtrump (and other massive accounts) don't have a special flag to be treated differently, which sounds even worse of a bespoke-workflow-nightmare. @realdonaldtrump must get receive so many abuse reports that it would constantly show up in the moderation queue otherwise.
[0] https://www.wired.com/2009/02/google-glitch-b/ https://www.wired.com/2009/02/google-glitch-b/
edit: Update from Twitter:
https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744 https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744
> Through our investigation we have learned that this was done by a Twitter customer support employee who did this on the employee’s last day. We are conducting a full internal review.
Wow, I imagined ACL/auditing being not completely disciplined -- such as SREs having root-tier access. I never would have thought that a customer support employee had unchecked power to disable accounts. It makes some sense that they would have autonomy to quickly deal with obviously bad/fake accounts. But not with Trump-tier accounts. Not just because of Trump, but all the other major accounts/brands who use Twitter as a primary communication medium.
- rrhd 9y agoa couple years ago someone messed up when setting up ACLs and took down (IIRC) S3.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- manicdee 9y agoMy guess is someone didn’t double-check the account name that had received 1000 abuse flags in the last half hour and just followed procedure.
- mst 9y agoGiven the number of accounts that I've seen indefinitely suspended for a report storm that were honestly quite reasonable, this seems likely to me.
- anonu 9y agoMy guess is that there are certain accounts that have separate procedures. Twitter is in the black this quarter for one reason - and I'm pretty sure its the @realDonaldTrump.... If your company was being propped up by 1 individual - wouldn't you put special procedures in place to make sure nothing inadvertent happened? (EDIT - GUESS NOT!! https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744 https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744) As a side note: I started using Twitter a lot more to follow @realDonaldTrump. It doesn't matter what I think about him. The reality is we live in a new news paradigm where every POTUS tweet is news before the actual news writes about it. Thats powerful... I'll go straight to the source then...
- IgorPartola 9y agoIt’s not the source though. He basically posts his reactions to stuff he hears on Fox and Friends. It’s pretty well known that he can keep his attention on primary source briefings that every other president has relied upon before him. Unless you count a thousand word CNN article about a short tweet as news. I don’t. I skip those articles because basically it’s just journalists being baited.
- brink 9y agoIt looks like it was done by a customer support employee on their way out https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744 https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744
- Grue3 9y agoThese replies... How'd they feel if their accounts were banned by a random Twitter employee (a secret Trump supporter or something)? It's like these people have no self-reflection at all.
- alenox 9y agoIf my account was occasionally fomenting international crises, perhaps it’d be justified.
- HumbleGamer 9y agoI agree, it sucks. I also think its a good moment to step back and recognize the power we've granted these sites. People calling having your twitter account deactivated as being "kicked off the internet" sounds ludicrous to me, but it speaks to the power these sites have.
- Spooky23 9y agoThe lack of internal controls is incredible. Highly influential people use Twitter to communicate. There should be controls to prevent influential or otherwise vulnerable people from access by insiders.