12 ms·
“realdonaldtrump’s account was inadvertently deactivated due to human error”
- f_allwein 9y agoSeems a bit weird that one employee can inadvertently deactivate such a big account by mistake. You would think there are double checks in place, warnings etc ... Edit: typo
- porfirium 9y agoThere probably are checks in place. My bet is on an employee's joke.
- radiorental 9y agoOr maybe someone on the way out with nothing to lose?
- dbcurtis 9y agoNothing? References are something.
- radiorental 9y agoI've seen bigger bridges burned.
- giobox 9y agoYou would need to be remarkably stupid and/or immature to switch off a primary communication channel of the elected leader of 320 million people as a "joke", regardless of what you think of Trump.
- noobiemcfoob 9y agoI'd give 'em a high five. And buy them a beer after they got rightly fired.
- mywittyname 9y agoThey might not be around to buy a beer. I'm sure the Secret Service/FBI could trump up some kind of Federal charges for such a thing.
- craftyguy 9y agoYou would need to be remarkably stupid and/or immature to use Twitter as your primary communication channel, as an elected leader of 320 million people.
- jsemrau 9y agoI would think it's an automation gone bad. Maybe too many complaints?
- Mountain_Skies 9y agoIf nothing else this points to poor internal controls on user accounts at Twitter.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jcims 9y agoI would imagine most people in traditional IT roles would find some jaw droppers if they spent a day at Twitter HQ.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- orky56 9y agoCurious to know how locked down permissions are at Twitter for this type of thing. After yesterday's news about RT & Twitter, I'm wary of the potential personal involvement Twitter has with US politics & Trump.
- hartator 9y agoKind of interesting that Trump’s account is worth so much to Twitter, and they seem to care so little.
- apetresc 9y agoOther than this freak occurrence, which was remedied immediately and publicly apologized-for, what else does Twitter do that makes you think they "care so little"?
- jjeaff 9y agoDue to the fact that the account appears to have violated Twitter rules many times and still exists shows that Twitter cares about the account very much. Many accounts have been banned for much less. Even somewhat high profile accounts.
- taytus 9y agoOn the contrary. Besides this "mistake", the main reason why this account has not been banned is because they REALLY care about this account.
- always_good 9y agoTrump is probably the best thing to happen to Twitter in some time. His tweets are the only reason I even see tweets anymore in my life. So it's funny when I see the CEO use Twitter to attack Trump.
- cyberferret 9y agoTBH, I've had a Twitter account since 2009, but the only reason I will visit their site once a day now is to check DT's Twitter feed to see if I have to watch out for anything that will impact (a) my industry (b) the financial markets and (c) world peace. No word of a lie. Twitter is probably marking off my visits as a solid 'daily user activity - this person keeps coming back to our platform within 24 hours on a regular basis'. But aside from checking his feed (and sometimes getting drawn into a senseless argument thread), I rarely post my own stuff on there any more as it is just a futile exercise in shouting at the void.
- danso 9y agoHope they release some kind of post-mortem report -- even if it was done out of malice, admitting that -- and providing some details on how this will be prevented in the future -- is much better than a vague excuse that leaves everything to the imagination. Having never worked anywhere on the scale of Twitter, the only non-malicious kind of human error I can think of is like when Google accidentally blacklisted all of Internet as malware [0]. What would be the accidental step/keystroke that happened to target the most controversial user account? Unless @realdonaldtrump was part of the manual-moderation queue and a human accidentally approved the ban. But that would seem to indicate that @realdonaldtrump (and other massive accounts) don't have a special flag to be treated differently, which sounds even worse of a bespoke-workflow-nightmare. @realdonaldtrump must get receive so many abuse reports that it would constantly show up in the moderation queue otherwise. [0] https://www.wired.com/2009/02/google-glitch-b/ https://www.wired.com/2009/02/google-glitch-b/ edit: Update from Twitter: https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744 https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744 > Through our investigation we have learned that this was done by a Twitter customer support employee who did this on the employee’s last day. We are conducting a full internal review. Wow, I imagined ACL/auditing being not completely disciplined -- such as SREs having root-tier access. I never would have thought that a customer support employee had unchecked power to disable accounts. It makes some sense that they would have autonomy to quickly deal with obviously bad/fake accounts. But not with Trump-tier accounts. Not just because of Trump, but all the other major accounts/brands who use Twitter as a primary communication medium.
- radiorental 9y agoMTGA #fakeAdminAccountPermissions
- gb_ 9y agoMy bet is they show tweets out of context to reviewers and they can ban based on the content.
- dahdum 9y agoHappened after the markets closed - would be very interesting to see the impact while open. I'd wager on a mini flash crash as bots short sell.
- deanCommie 9y agoHonestly the right will freak out about this and scream some form of left wing censorship, but... The first amendment only extends to government laws. Twitter, as a private entity has no obligation or legal requirement to give hateful speech a soapbox, even when it's promoted by the "leader of the free world." They would lose millions of users, but they might ultimately provide a net benefit to the future of western democracy if they simply banned Donald Trump from twitter.
- dibstern 9y agoI completely disagree. Taking away diversity of political thought is an incredibly dangerous thing. The right is performing a very useful role in playing devil’s advocate - there’s a huge amount of increasing extremism on the left, and it’s important to have people calling it what it is. And no, Trump’s daily tweets aren’t hate speech. I think he’s an idiot, but he’s not spouting hate speech on there.
- kllrnohj 9y ago> The right is performing a very useful role in playing devil’s advocate Can you elaborate on this? Playing devil's advocate is not inherently useful, in fact it can be extremely destructive. For example playing devil's advocate on saying "hey, maybe slavery wasn't so bad" is at best a waste of time, but if you manage to convince anyone you've just made things worse. There is no value in that role. Similarly suggesting that being a literal Nazi is "all sides are to blame, many sides" is destructive and not in the least bit a valuable role. Trump, and the alt-right in general, is regularly in the destructive end of playing devil's advocate. What would you characterize as being useful in countering "extremism on the left"?
- jack9 9y ago> Taking away diversity of political thought is an incredibly dangerous thing. Equity of content isn't a practical goal. Any view can be split infinitely into sub-viewpoints. Diversity, in this context, cannot be enforced without setting limitations on discourse. All platforms (including reality, where proximity is a limitation) of speech suffer from this. Pragmatically, modal groupings form, appealing to human mental models. Humans choose to throw away diversity of political thought to focus on more immediate needs and goals. It's a borderline tautological statement that all human political activity is "dangerous" because humans are "dangerous".
- jackmott 9y agoJust act on the abuse reports and delete his account for real and do the world a favor.
- PKop 9y agoPeople like you are why he got elected.
- sctb 9y agoCould you please not feed the trolls?
- ceejayoz 9y agoYou're getting downvoted, but Twitter has stated that "newsworthiness" can cause a tweet to be exempted from their rules. https://twitter.com/Policy/status/912438362010783744 https://twitter.com/Policy/status/912438362010783744
- cyberferret 9y agoIronic counterpoint: I now notice that the deactivation itself is 'newsworthy' and has been picked up by Reuters et al. Does this mean that this particular employee is now exempt from sacking or other disciplinary measures because what he/she did was 'newsworthy'? What a tangled (inter)web we have weaved...
- skrowl 9y agoCensorship of political rivals never does anyone a favor. How would you feel if people had said this same thing about Obama? Isn't it enough that over 90% of the mainstream (old) media coverage of Trump is negative for you? Do you REALLY need to ban him on Twitter?
- panic 9y agoObama wasn't setting policy or doing "diplomacy" on Twitter. If he were, I'd say the same thing. People asking for Twitter to ban Trump aren't all doing it because of their political "side" -- his use of the platform is harmful on its own.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- amatecha 9y agoHuman... "error"? Give that employee a raise!
- Muuuchem 9y agoHey it's not a bug! New feature twitter is testing out! So far I hear it had huge ratings!
- partiallypro 9y agoOf course this entire thread becomes a political circle jerk of people wanting Trump banned from Twitter rather than the seemingly poor internal controls on Twitter.
- partiallypro 9y agoAnd now they admit it was an employee on their last day. So, yup, lack of internal controls. Appreciate the downvotes. https://www.thewrap.com/trump-twitter-account-deleted-by-customer-service-employee-on-their-last-day/ https://www.thewrap.com/trump-twitter-account-deleted-by-cus...
- firefoxd 9y agoWhat I find interesting, is the sudden power Twitter just realised they have. Imagine this, they are one button away from taking away the US president main mean of communication. This is akin to a country doing a military parade, showing off their arms.
- rtpg 9y agoI get that Trump used Twitter a lot but he does have a press office where actual stuff happens.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoThe whole scandal though is that he actively dodges the WHPC to distribute information.
- Johnny555 9y agoAnd just a few sentences away from declaring war. If someone took over Trump's twitter and detailed how bombers were in-route to take out North Korea's nuclear capability, would Kim Jong Un wait for independent confirmation before he launched his missile(s)?
- throwaway613834 9y agoThis was really scary to read. I'd never realized this.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoNever before has "2FA enabled" been more relevant.
- synicalx 9y agoSomeone give that man a Yubikey
- 9y ago
- nodesocket 9y agoThey need to fire that employee. Apple, Netflix, and Tesla don't put up with this, because they have strong leaders at the helm. The amount of hypocrisy and constant outraged that comes out of the bay area makes me sick to my stomach. I used to be liberal, then I moved and lived in SF for 5 years. To quote; and I'll be sure to get it right (unlike the Texans owner) "the inmates are running the asylum".
- seattle_spring 9y agoI'm mildly amused that you bemoan "liberal outrage" while being outraged about your Lord and Savior being accidentally banned from a social network for 10 minutes.
- sixstringtheory 9y agoIf it wasn’t on purpose, then they must have some interesting special logic around his account in particular (maybe others?) that was maybe accidentally altered/enabled. I’m just curious what the nature of that special logic is. Maybe to exempt it from context-free abuse review, as gb_ said below?
- ProAm 9y agoI mean he did wish for people to get the death sentence earlier today, Im sure that goes against Twitters Code Of Conduct [1] , but since he saved Twitter from going under Im sure he's got a lifetime get out of jail free card. [1] https://support.twitter.com/articles/20175050# https://support.twitter.com/articles/20175050#
- nodesocket 9y agoThis person killed 8 innocent people by plowing into them with a car. If one of those persons was a loved one of your own, would you want him to get the death penalty?
- ProAm 9y agoIm just arguing that Twitter has a Code of Conduct [1] and Trump definitely falls across that line frequently, I could easily see how he should be banned but probably has special privilege as for he is solely responsible for saving the business from demise. [1] https://support.twitter.com/articles/20175050# https://support.twitter.com/articles/20175050#
- nodesocket 9y agoSure, but I think you're missing the bigger point. It's not about Twitter's business, it's about free speech and the fact that he is the fairly elected president of the United States. You can't pick and choose. I'm sure I'll continue to get downvoted though.
- 9y ago
- indescions_2017 9y agoNo stretch of the imagination to parse "inadvertently deactivated due to human error" as equating to "internal sabotage for the cause of rebellion" ;) I can recommend PBS Frontline's doc "Putin's Revenge" for deep background on how we got to where we are today. It's fascinating to see "unintended consequences" of a series of US foreign policy decisions: Libya, Sochi 2014 Ukraine protests, an "f-bomb" in a a random diplomatic cable. Lead to a compounding of grievances for Moscow. And how pushback was inevitable. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/putins-revenge/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/putins-revenge/ TBH I was decidedly underwhelmed by Twitter general counsel's testimony before the Senate judiciary. Just really unserious, lacking an appreciation of the gravity of the situation. Social media was weaponized by a foreign power to sow dissent, destabilize democracy and ultimately weaken American influence abroad. Regardless of your personal politics, the narrative has morphed into a national security issue. An that means every startup or internet based company. Basically everyone. Needs to have a security policy in place to avoid persecution and or liability.
- flatfilefan 9y agopbs video...“Not available in your region due to right restriction”. He-he, so much to the freedom of speech!
- derblitzmann 9y agoPBS is a non-profit non-governmental entity. It has no obligation to follow the bill of rights.
- smsm42 9y ago> Social media was weaponized by a foreign power to sow dissent, Surely, there was no dissent sown on Twitter and other social media before Putin thought about using it.
- knowaveragejoe 9y agoIs that the point of what this person is saying?
- Spooky23 9y agoI’m surprised they don’t do this anyway. Whatever noteriety they get from Trump has to come with a cost. The words “twitter” and “Trump” become more and more associated every day.
- artur_makly 9y agothats ok since i made a backup for him here : http://TrumpTweets.io http://TrumpTweets.io https in the works!
- porfirium 9y ago"Through our investigation we have learned that this was done by a Twitter customer support employee who did this on the employee’s last day. We are conducting a full internal review." https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744 https://twitter.com/TwitterGov/status/926267806261407744
- surya13 9y agoi think it is not real.
- thesmallestcat 9y agoBugs, fat-fingers and misclicks don't care that you're the president.
- uladzislau 9y agoA bunch of tweets disappeared from my Twitter account in early March of this year without any reason or trace. I had them cached on Twitter mobile app so I had the proof it's not my imagination. I reached out to Twitter support, didn't get any reply and wasn't able to figure out what happened :/
- r3bl 9y agoFrom my experience, you have to be very, very loud if you want to reach them. This is how I managed to reach them in July: https://twitter.com/i/moments/878356515622617088 https://twitter.com/i/moments/878356515622617088