3 ms·
Read the report. There is no simple answer to that question. It was a complicated and confusing situation, and the pilots in the cockpit made a number of mistak
by foldr 9y ago
Read the report. There is no simple answer to that question. It was a complicated and confusing situation, and the pilots in the cockpit made a number of mistakes.
- CamperBob2 9y agoIt was a complicated and confusing situation It's the job of the UI/UX designers to make that less likely. Like most air crashes, it took at least two things going wrong to make this one happen. Three in this case. Factor #1, a couple of morons were flying the aircraft. Factor #2, pitot tube icing. Factor #3, the aircraft was designed with certain unintuitive control features that depart from longstanding industry practices. The sticks that everybody's talking about were only one of those elements. An arguable (if perhaps not politically-acceptable) conclusion is that if the pilots aren't sure who's doing what, the control system engineers and the pilots need to go back to school.
- foldr 9y agoThe report examined UX issues but didn't identify the side sticks as a significant factor. You can keep insisting that they were a factor if you like, but you haven't actually provided any evidence in support of that contention.
- CamperBob2 9y agoI think we can find common ground in agreeing that those pilots needed all the help they could get. Same with these sailors.