3 ms·
Also, FastMail isn't any better for privacy, and you have to pay for it to boot. The article was more or less reasonable until the nonsensical recommendations a
by lern_too_spel 9y ago
Also, FastMail isn't any better for privacy, and you have to pay for it to boot. The article was more or less reasonable until the nonsensical recommendations at the end.
- rrix2 9y agoFastMail is much better than google mail because it's not fueling google's hegemony over the web. That you have to pay for it means their sustainability is not tied to abusing their users. If you want privacy in the way you seem to mean privacy (end-to-end no-trust async messaging) of course anything speaking SMTP isn't going to be "better for privacy", but those systems largely are incompatible with how 99% of the web wants to communicate with you.
- ric2b 9y ago> That you have to pay for it means their sustainability is not tied to abusing their users. Modern capitalism means taking the money _and_ abusing the users, unless the users leaving from the abuse actually ends up reducing profits.
- Spivak 9y agoNo email solution will be better for privacy outside of hosting it yourself. I have it set up for my personal email because I thought it was a fun project, but there's no point in pretending that it's realistic for casual email users. Email without outside encryption like PGP is fundamentally privacy by policy which lives and dies by the reputation and policy of the provider: it seems like Fastmail's is pretty good.
- flukus 9y ago> but there's no point in pretending that it's realistic for casual email users. Are there any technical reasons why we couldn't have an "email in a box" type setup with an easy gui configuration? I've though of setting up a personal email/dropbox/IM/youtube box and the biggest hurdles I could think of were domain registration, bandwidth (for the youtube clone) and firewall rules. Lack of static IP's is also an issue but that seems solvable.
- chrismorgan 9y agoYou can host your email yourself (and there are a couple of email-in-a-box bundles out there), but you will find that reliable deliverability takes surprisingly much effort. (Distressingly much effort.) You can count on winding up on various blacklists, even if you can’t imagine why it would be so; so you’ll need to monitor them with things like MxToolbox, and then manually sort them out—and/or maintain a pool of IP addresses to rotate through (some providers make it very hard to resolve). The big providers are often not fond of low-traffic senders, so you may have difficulty there too. And every so often there will be new hoops for you to jump through—SPF, DKIM, DMARC and so forth; receivers will change their rules and all of a sudden your email won’t get through any more. Of course, it depends on how you use it. If you send out a newsletter or other large quantities of emails you’re in for much pain, while if you tend to only send individual messages to a comparatively small group of people (and are thus a known sender) you’re likely to have an easier time of it—though you may still have some trouble occasionally. (I’m a FastMail employee, but I don’t work on the backend side of things at all; I speak from casual experience mostly before FastMail. But I think that all of us that know anything about how hard it is to run your own mail server are ideologically sad about it; if FastMail wasn’t around, I suspect a substantial fraction of us would run our own mail server.)