18 ms·
Massive Government Report Says Climate Is Warming and Humans Are the Cause
- s3nnyy 9y agoHate the fact that politics intervene, fund or don't fund this kind of stuff and hence interfere with almost every study on this topic.
- Delmania 9y agoThe irony here is that under Scott Pruitt, the EPA is removing any references to climate change from the department. Yet, the same government that gives him the power to do that also made this report.
- wooter 9y agoso maybe we should reign in the largest polluter in history? The US Military. As a citizen, I think this is a logical first step. Isn't it fully within the government's control?
- saas_co_de 9y agosorry, but how is the U.S. military the largest polluter in history? Surely the billions of people using electricity and driving cars and living off of products created with fossil fuels have managed more pollution than a few million in the U.S. military?
- intopieces 9y agohttps://www.ecowatch.com/military-largest-polluter-2408760609.html https://www.ecowatch.com/military-largest-polluter-240876060...
- kolbe 9y agoThis provides absolutely no basis for comparison, jut a few slightly quantitative anecdotes. I am, without doing any research, supremely confident that US civilians and private industry are far more environmentally destructive than the US military in 2017.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago"The U.S. military is the largest institutional consumer of oil in the world. Every year, our armed forces consume more than 100 million barrels of oil to power ships, vehicles, aircraft, and ground operations—enough for over 4 million trips around the Earth, assuming 25 mpg." http://www.ucsusa.org/clean_vehicles/smart-transportation-solutions/us-military-oil-use.html http://www.ucsusa.org/clean_vehicles/smart-transportation-so...
- grepthisab 9y agoRight, the single biggest maybe. But more than US citizens combined, as the parent comment indicates? No.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoRight, but the US military is top down control, which means changes are easier versus herding hundreds of millions of individual consumers to the right solutions. Nobody likes a dictatorship until something needs to get done fast.
- wooter 9y agoNot only top down, but 100% accountable to the government already. No new laws necessary (under Bush, Obama, or Trump). In fact, MOST Americans want to end these useless dragging wars. Really reveals how much they truly care about pollution versus posturing for more control.
- wooter 9y ago
- pge 9y agoI think what he is saying is technically true, though the conclusion doesnt follow. It is technically true because the US Military could easily be the largest single polluting organization in the world (because it has way more employees and vehicles than any other organization). By that token, the next biggest gov't agency would probably be USPS because of the miles of driving they do. That does not mean, however, that the most effective path for stopping pollution starts there. For example, automobile fuel efficiency standards, or subsidies for solar power, etc could all offer more opportunity for reducing climate emissions than what is possible in reducing the US military usage of fossil fuels.
- observation 9y agoI don't know if it is true, but it's not obviously false. Military uses huge numbers of powerful diesel engines and the US military is larger than most of the rest combined.
- crazy1van 9y agowhat are you basing that claim on?
- mnglkhn2 9y ago> reign in the largest polluter in history You mean China, right?
- SubiculumCode 9y agoA massive push to clean electricity tech and infrastructure funded by the Federal government may seem expensive, but is SO much cheaper than Climate Change related war+starvation+sea-rise+giant storms.
- gerry_shaw 9y agoBut what if climate change isn't real and all we end up with is a cleaner, healthier and quieter environment to live in? /s
- afarrell 9y agoIf climate change isn’t real, there’s no good reason for us to cause the unemployment, crime, and suicides that will result from dismantling the main industry of America’s 4th largest city (Houston).
- vilmosi 9y agoYes, there is. >>> cleaner, healthier and quieter environment to live in
- VikingCoder 9y agoThat's inevitable. Will it be replaced by nuclear or solar is basically the only question.
- tdb7893 9y agoNuclear has been around for a long time and has never caught on. Barring large changes in public opinion or price it's probably on the way out, too
- afarrell 9y agoUnless we can mine enough lithium to make grid-scale battery farms viable or can make large-scale flywheels work, both forms have issues with demand response that are currently being solved by natural gas.
- abtinf 9y agoWhy wouldn't NPR publish the source report?
- creaghpatr 9y agoAccording to the org website the report will be delivered late 2018 http://www.globalchange.gov/nca4 http://www.globalchange.gov/nca4
- anigbrowl 9y agoYes, but why wouldn't NPR publish what they have? I'm sick of news organizations hoarding documents so they can report on the contents. Redact any information that might identify the source and release it, otherwise the news value (and by proxy, the credibility of the investigating outlet) diminishes substantially. Downvoters: the NPR article says they have obtained a copy. It's in the second sentence. So not publishing is a matter of choice on NPR's part.
- fishcolorbrick 9y agoWhat if you can't be sure what level of redaction is safe? What if your source is compromised by some watermark or steganographic content you missed? The Intercept had contacted the NSA on May 30 and sent copies of the documents to the agency, in order to confirm their veracity. The NSA notified the FBI about the situation on June 1. The FBI realized the documents had been printed out because the PDF copies sent by The Intercept "appeared to be folded and/or creased, suggesting they had been printed and hand-carried out of a secured space".[22] Next, the NSA did an internal audit, confirming that Winner was one of six workers who had accessed the particular documents on its classified system [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Winner#Intelligence_report_leak_and_arrest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Winner#Intelligence_re...
- anigbrowl 9y agoPrint it out and scan it again. OCR it and change the fonts, say you're doing it to protect your sources. It's easy to obfuscate stuff, and sometimes you should be willing to take risks, especially when the stakes are sufficiently high. Someone was willing to take the risk of leaking it to NPR to start with.
- vondur 9y agoI’m thinking it’s too late for just CO2 reduction alone. We need to get CO2 sequestration going.
- mnglkhn2 9y agoNot really. Plant a ton of trees and the CO2 problem solves by itself. The problem stems also from the huge deforestation that has taken place in the last couple of centuries.
- mac01021 9y ago> Plant a ton of trees and the CO2 problem solves by itself. Citation? Obviously we're emitting CO2 at some rate E and a ton of trees will sequester that CO2 at another rate S. But it's not clear that you've measured and compared those two numbers.
- mnglkhn2 9y agoHere we go [1]: This has to do with a study about the measurement of the impact deforestation of tropical forests has on global warming. > How big is three billion tons? Three billion tons of anything is a lot, but it’s hard to grasp just how much — particularly when it’s tons of CO2, which we don’t have any everyday experience in weighing. One way to look at it is that the average U.S. car emits about 5 tons of CO2 a year from the tailpipe, so three billion tons is the equivalent of 600 million cars — about twice as many as there are in the whole United States. Another way of expressing it is that this is the equivalent of about 13 million railcars full of coal, which would stretch about 125,000 miles (half the distance to the moon). It's also equal to the total emissions from Western Europe, including Austria, the Czech Republic, Slovenia, all the Scandinavian countries, and Finland. [1] http://www.ucsusa.org/global_warming/solutions/stop-deforestation/deforestation-global-warming-carbon-emissions.html#.Wft_T0xFyHs http://www.ucsusa.org/global_warming/solutions/stop-deforest...
- fishcolorbrick 9y agoPlantation forestry grows about 20 cubic meters per hectare-year [0]. Doug Fir weighs ~600 kg-m3 [1]. 3B US tons / (20x600 kg) per hectare-year = 6,796,166 hectares. Plantation lumber is harvested in 7, 14, and 21 year cuts [0], so to ensure you're always sequestering enough carbon you need 21x6.8 million hectares of new forest to defray the current CO2 production... which is about 551,000 square miles, which is approximately [2] Texas + California + New Mexico... or [3] France + Spain + Italy. The new forest would still be ~20% of the size of the Amazon rain-forest though [4]. [0]: https://www.quora.com/How-fast-do-pine-trees-grow https://www.quora.com/How-fast-do-pine-trees-grow [1]: https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/weigt-wood-d_821.html https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/weigt-wood-d_821.html [2]: https://state.1keydata.com/states-by-size.php https://state.1keydata.com/states-by-size.php [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependencies_by_area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependen... [4]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazon_rainforest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazon_rainforest
- mithoon 9y agoEvery week, I read an article about this, all I say in my head is 'but then what'. Unless there is money bleeding no politicians will take this to rest. It's sad but true and this will keep on continuing.
- Joeri 9y agoIt’s ok for a politician to spend money to clean up a disaster. It’s far more troublesome to spend money to avoid a disaster. Politically it will always be advantageous to wait with adressing a problem until after its negative consequences are fully felt.
- komali2 9y agoI always wonder why people need to "feel the pain" before they make a decision - when it's usually too late. My mom and dad read wikipedia and a couple investment books, and so when the 2008 crash happened we didn't lose all of our savings because we were potently diversified - why did most of our friends have to "start over?" Because "a crash will never happen again?" This coming from people who became adults in the dotcom bust? Then you have people living through Desert Storm convincing their kids it's "safe" to join the military "just for the scholarship." "Just do 4 years, America will never go to war again." Shock and surprise when 9/11 happens and a ton of my highschool buddies are called off to Afghanistan for uh... some reason? Does it matter? Did they think that wouldn't happen for any made-up reason regardless of if 9/11 happened, when their grandparents lived through Vietnam and their parents through Desert Storm? What's with this short-sightedness and ignoring of history / professional advice? Not that I'm immune, I got my credit card info stolen for being comically arrogant at defcon.
- anigbrowl 9y agoWell some politicians have spent political capital on this, but have been heavily attacked for it. Let's not pretend that all politicians are equally at fault when they manifestly promote different positions and policies.
- monk_e_boy 9y agoIts a shame you can't pay a "core 80%" set of taxes, then choose what other things your "extra 20%" would go towards. NASA, climate stuff, recycling, bee stuff, extra education... etc
- dschuler 9y agoIt's hard enough to know how to approach a tragedy of the commons problem like climate change if everyone could agree that it is a problem, but it's difficult for me to understand why some people will argue that it is in fact happening. I would be interested in understanding the root cause of why people will disagree about this point. For example, a conservative friend of mine, who I think is one of the most intelligent people I know, will argue that climate change does not exist. I've asked him what he makes of e.g. the rising level of CO2 in the atmosphere. His response was there are scientists interested in self promotion and are willing to fabricate data, and/or that we can't actually measure CO2 accurately. Those are very unconvincing counterarguments in my view. I'm led to believe there must be a deeper root cause that prevents someone from objectively looking at data and seeing that some change is occurring (without even coming to a conclusion about what that change means or what to do about it). Yet, I have no idea what that root cause could be. Any ideas?
- poke111 9y agoIt's because of the way the issue has been politicized. In people's mind it's a binary issue: either you agree that warming is happening, we are causing it, it is likely to be catastrophic, we can substantially improve the outcome by acting now, and the cost/benefit of this intervention makes sense, or you don't. In reality the basic science is but one small piece, and reasonable people can disagree about the economics or politics of it. But the tribalism of politics make most people boil it down to only two possibilities.
- r00fus 9y agoAll part and parcel of the anti-climate-change coalition's efforts to poison the well. As long as people are divided, they can continue to pollute the planet while reaping windfall profits. Meanwhile, wind/solar will get killed with new congressional tax plan and state/local legislation that makes them infeasible. Ironically I think only China will have global power to do something about climate change because their air (Beijing) is so damn dirty.
- dinoleif 9y agoAmong the conservatives/libertarians/etc in my life, who I broadly consider among the smartest people I know, there is a broad unwillingness to have a real discussion for fear of being shamed. The climate debate has become more about moral posturing and smearing people who disagree as "deniers", which has made it impossible to convince anyone who's not already convinced. It has also deprived climate activists of substantive critiques that could help them move past their own biases (which are substantial).
- kylek 9y agoTerrifying if this report has an impact on policy. Ctrl-f sun (No matches) Garbage article with no source
- liberte82 9y agoWhy was this flagged the first time? The number of flagged articles on HN is becoming ridiculous. It's creating a precedent where any group with an extreme opinion can shut down conversation by deciding a topic is 'controversial'.
- wooter 9y agoany idea why my comment below is flagged?
- randyrand 9y agoI've long been on the human-caused GW band wagon - ever since I learned about global warming 10+ years ago. But the alarmism turned me off to the idea that dramatic legislation is actually needed, or that GW is even all that big of an issue. As far as I can tell unabated GW would never have a big impact on my life [edit:] even if all the change happened within my lifetime.
- mikeash 9y agoScrew future generations?
- randyrand 9y ago*even if all the change happened within my lifetime.
- mikeash 9y agoYou don’t think you’d be affected by the massive economic disruption from having so many major cities flooded, or ocean ecosystems devastated by acidification, or refugee crises on a scale never before seen when productive agricultural regions become unproductive?
- randyrand 9y agoWell definitely a small small fraction of how I was affected by the 2008 financial crisis or even the recent refugee wave. GW will happen slowly over many decades... Not suddenly like either of those. I think people forget that. In fact, we're already living through the speed of these changes! Cities are already flooding more and more and refugees are already leaving, it's just such a slow process that it's barely noticeable and not even a daily concern. And this is predicted to be the same speed for the rest of GW. A city slowly flooding more and more over 50 years is not too different than the emigration from Detroit over a smaller timespan. Same goes for agricultural shifts. Markets are already adjusting. There will be no crisis.
- artorias 9y agoHow do we know humans are the cause again? The planet is what, 6 billion years old? Oldest "humans" are roughly ~3 million years old? Gee. That sure does leave a lot of room for variable. I'm not saying we shouldn't try to take care of our planet (hint, we should because our options are limited in space ;) ), but jesus christ. 6 billion years. You can't prove jack shit with 2700 years worth of data.
- wdn 9y agoCan we just give Al Gore and his buddies 15 trillions and settle this issue? For Christ sake, the Earth has been warning before human was here. There are a lot of extra factors that we don't know yet. At the very least, have a debate about it. This is not settled like the government funded research tell you. If there is a solution, it will not be more government regulations. Just look the past 20 years in the financial markets, how many scandals were there and have SEC and their regulations prevent anything?
- fmsf 9y agoGiven that this starts with 'It is "extremely likely" that human activities...', that is enough for folks and organisations behind pushing that there is no global warming and it's not human's fault if there is. To say "they don't know for sure" and stop reading it.
- bodono 9y agoThe scientific method means making a prediction based on a theory and seeing if it matches the observed results. So honest question - have any predictions from climate science about the change in global temperatures come true? Have what climate scientists said ten years was going to happen in ten years actually happened? Global climate dynamics are very complicated and it's very hard to understand, but real science makes testable predictions and then theories are accepted as 'our best theory at the moment' when the observations match predictions within a small tolerance and the theory is thrown out when it doesn't, regardless of how hard or complicated it is.
- kapauldo 9y agoSurprised this isn't flagged.