3 ms·
A whiteboard. Seriously. A presentation is (or at least should be) first and foremost about a human being telling a story, which humans have been doing for hu
by lisper 9y ago
A whiteboard. Seriously. A presentation is (or at least should be) first and foremost about a human being telling a story, which humans have been doing for hundreds of thousands of years. If you can't tell an effective story without a computer then no software is going to save you.
Take a look at some of Eddie Woo's videos on YouTube. He gives some of the best presentations ever with nothing but himself and a whiteboard.
[EDIT] Start here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=McDdEw_Fb5E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=McDdEw_Fb5E
It's three minutes long. Notice the audience reaction and total absence of bright shiny things.
- watwut 9y agoI strongly prefer technical or business presentations not to tell stories. Tell me business or technical stuff. Is shiny effect is what it takes to keep audience focus, then I don't mind it if the content is there. And if that allows to create acceptable presentations to more technical less showmany people, then all the better. "The story" is just another shiny thing, just in different form.
- lisper 9y agoNo. The story is not just there to hold your attention. The story actually matters. The story provides the context, the reason you should care about the topic being presented. Boring presentations are often that way because the presenter make mistaken assumptions about shared context between themselves and the audience. If I tell you, for example, that Cody Bellinger committed an error in the first inning of yesterday's game that fact in isolation isn't very interesting, particularly if you don't know who Cody Bellinger is. If I tell you that that error set the stage for the Astros winning their first world series in their history suddenly it becomes a lot more interesting. A more technical example: if I tell you that Edwards curves have complete point addition and doubling formulas that fact in isolation isn't very interesting. But if you know that having such formulas enables you to build cryptographic systems that are more resistant to side-channel attacks, suddenly it's more interesting. (Assuming, of course, you know what side-channel attacks are. If you don't, then I have to be explicit about more of the story: there are attackers who want to break into your secret stuff, and one of the ways they do this is by looking at things like how long your code takes to run under different circumstances. Notice that now we have all of the elements of a good story: a protagonist, an antagonist, conflict... ) This is a fundamental feature of human psychology. Humans don't care about things for their own sake, they care about things that help them to achieve goals. Once you have a goal, you have a person who is trying to achieve that goal (i.e. a protagonist) and some reason they are at least temporarily unable to achieve that goal, and hence some agent thwarting their ambition (i.e. an antagonist). The antagonist doesn't have to be another human (c.f. Moby Dick). Often the antagonist is the laws of physics. But there is always a story behind anything that anyone cares about.
- watwut 9y agoSorry I guess. I dont know who Cody Bellinger or Astros are nor do I know what sport they compete at. So I mean, that particular story is not much interesting. Likewise, I like math. I am one of those people who honestly like math instead of culture around math that just sounds cool. I also have interests in security. I like to read easily digestible technical blogs about it. Stories about hackers in presentations about above are annoying to me. I came to learn and instead I am getting fairy tale. Most of them are bullshit, despite following protagonist, antagonist conflict formula that is repeated so much that anything that goes just slightly against it makes entertainment hundred times more interesting. And that story is not helping me to achieve any goal, except of realizing that presenter is wasting my time. I heard already enough presentations with formulaic stories in them to know what is the part I usually wish presenter would skip. And I guess really good writer could create an interesting story, but I don't really expect that from technical presenter who I would prefer to focus more on whether his explanations are clear then on this.
- lisper 9y ago> Sorry I guess. I dont know who Cody Bellinger or Astros are nor do I know what sport they compete at. So I mean, that particular story is not much interesting. Yes, that was exactly my point. Cody Bellinger is a baseball player. Baseball is a sport played mainly but not exclusively in the United States. It is a team sport. The annual championship game for baseball is called the World Series (despite the fact that the competing teams are almost exclusively from the U.S.) The world series is a best-of-seven tournament. This year the world series was played between a team called the Houston Astros (or just "the Astros" for short) and another team called the Los Angeles Dodgers ("the Dodgers"). The Dodgers have not won a World Series since 1988. The Astros have never won one (until yesterday). Because it is a best-of-seven series, the length of the tournament varies. It can be as short as four games (if one team wins them all) or as long as seven (if both teams wins three games apiece). Naturally, the tournament is considered most exciting in the latter circumstance, which was the case yesterday. A game of baseball is divided into nine periods called "innings". (Additional innings can be played if there is a tie at the end of the ninth inning, but that didn't happen yesterday.) Each inning is further divided into two halves called the "top" and the "bottom". Yesterday, during the top of the first inning (i.e. near the start of the game) in the seventh game of the world series (i.e. the crucial game which would decide the championship) a player on the Dodgers named Cody Bellinger made a mistake. He was attempting to throw the ball to another player on his team, but the throw was off-target and the other player was not able to catch the ball. As a result, the Astros scored two points in quick succession, which they would not have done had the throw been on-target. Baseball tends to be a low-scoring game. Double-digit scores are rare. So a two point lead is significant. That one mistake seemed to set the tone for the rest of the game, where the Astros, who up to that point had been fairly evenly matched with the Dodgers, took a commanding lead and ultimately won 5-1. So that mistake turned out to be a big deal. > I like math. Did you watch the video I pointed to above? > Stories about hackers in presentations about above are annoying to me. Not all stories are good stories. The story has to be relevant to the point being made. Telling a good story is not easy. That's one of the reasons that I find PPT to be so annoying, because it lets you cover up the fact that you're telling a bad story. BTW, your view of story is too narrow. Fiction is a proper subset of stories.