4 ms·
The problem with PPT is that it encourages the creation of bad presentations, encourages the emphasis of style over substance. Honestly, under what circumstanc
by lisper 9y ago
The problem with PPT is that it encourages the creation of bad presentations, encourages the emphasis of style over substance. Honestly, under what circumstances can (say) a flashy transition animation ever convey useful information? 90% of PPT's features exist so you can distract the audience from the fact that the presentation has no substance with bright shiny things.
- Sangermaine 9y agoOr it's an acknowledgment of the reality that humans aren't computers just absorbing information during a presentation. They get bored, they get restless, they get distracted, etc. I'm not saying effects aren't used in the way you say, but I think they can have a place to keep a presentation from becoming dull and monotonous. Even the most interesting content can lose the audience if the way its presented doesn't hold their attention.
- lisper 9y agoIf a presentation is boring and monotonous then the way to fix that is not by distracting the audience with bright shiny things. The way to fix it is to change the presentation so that the information conveyed is relevant and interesting rather than boring and monotonous. And if that's not possible then the way to fix it is to cancel the presentation and just point people to a document they can refer to. Seriously, the whole point of giving a presentation is that sometimes watching a person tell a story about whatever the topic is is better than reading about it. If that's not the case (and often it's not), then a presentation is a waste of everyone's time.
- gumby 9y agoWhat kind of tool would encourage substance over style? I mean beyond a simple text editor?
- lisper 9y agoA whiteboard. Seriously. A presentation is (or at least should be) first and foremost about a human being telling a story, which humans have been doing for hundreds of thousands of years. If you can't tell an effective story without a computer then no software is going to save you. Take a look at some of Eddie Woo's videos on YouTube. He gives some of the best presentations ever with nothing but himself and a whiteboard. [EDIT] Start here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=McDdEw_Fb5E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=McDdEw_Fb5E It's three minutes long. Notice the audience reaction and total absence of bright shiny things.
- watwut 9y agoI strongly prefer technical or business presentations not to tell stories. Tell me business or technical stuff. Is shiny effect is what it takes to keep audience focus, then I don't mind it if the content is there. And if that allows to create acceptable presentations to more technical less showmany people, then all the better. "The story" is just another shiny thing, just in different form.
- lisper 9y agoNo. The story is not just there to hold your attention. The story actually matters. The story provides the context, the reason you should care about the topic being presented. Boring presentations are often that way because the presenter make mistaken assumptions about shared context between themselves and the audience. If I tell you, for example, that Cody Bellinger committed an error in the first inning of yesterday's game that fact in isolation isn't very interesting, particularly if you don't know who Cody Bellinger is. If I tell you that that error set the stage for the Astros winning their first world series in their history suddenly it becomes a lot more interesting. A more technical example: if I tell you that Edwards curves have complete point addition and doubling formulas that fact in isolation isn't very interesting. But if you know that having such formulas enables you to build cryptographic systems that are more resistant to side-channel attacks, suddenly it's more interesting. (Assuming, of course, you know what side-channel attacks are. If you don't, then I have to be explicit about more of the story: there are attackers who want to break into your secret stuff, and one of the ways they do this is by looking at things like how long your code takes to run under different circumstances. Notice that now we have all of the elements of a good story: a protagonist, an antagonist, conflict... ) This is a fundamental feature of human psychology. Humans don't care about things for their own sake, they care about things that help them to achieve goals. Once you have a goal, you have a person who is trying to achieve that goal (i.e. a protagonist) and some reason they are at least temporarily unable to achieve that goal, and hence some agent thwarting their ambition (i.e. an antagonist). The antagonist doesn't have to be another human (c.f. Moby Dick). Often the antagonist is the laws of physics. But there is always a story behind anything that anyone cares about.
- moftz 9y agoAnything designed by engineers for engineers is probably not going to have much style. A lot of software out there works the same way it has worked since the 80s because the guys originally making it back then still make it today, same with their users. Clunky CAD software like Cadence is probably the most obvious example. I could have gone back in time to 1995 and the software wouldn't look any different. At least things like AutoCAD maintain their old school functionality but add features and UI improvements. It all depends on what kind of market the software company is looking to sell to. Autodesk wants to be on the front of innovation for their stuff so they can sell to new companies and education (i.e. young people). Cadence sells to companies that have been doing the same stuff for years and have no plans on changing.
- siproprio 9y agoSPICE software kept popping into my mind while I read this comment.