4 ms·
This is a thing I've been wondering about. Is dynamic linking (in the way that C/C++ programs use it all the time) not a usecase that Rust wants to cover?
by majewsky 9y ago
This is a thing I've been wondering about. Is dynamic linking (in the way that C/C++ programs use it all the time) not a usecase that Rust wants to cover?
- steveklabnik 9y agoYou can do dynamic linking, you just can't do it across compiler versions. This is how all of the Linux distros are doing it, for example. It's a spectrum: Rust: recompile the world when you update the compiler C++: recompile the world when you change ABIs or when the ABI changes (My understanding is that MSVC++ changes the ABI every ~2 years? I could be wrong.) C: never recompile the world It's not that we don't want the benefits of a stable ABI, but it's a monumental task, and there are more important things for now. Don't forget that you can get a stable ABI today by using the C ABI. You just lose out on the fancier features Rust has.
- Karliss 9y agoStarting with vs2015 microsoft promises more stable abi.
- the_why_of_y 9y ago> C++: recompile the world when you change ABIs or when the ABI changes (My understanding is that MSVC++ changes the ABI every ~2 years? I could be wrong.) This is only half true: every new release, the ABI of the runtime library changes. But the Visual C++ compiler ABI hasn't changed in decades. If you design your own library ABIs so they don't pass std::foobars around, you can link C++ libraries built with VC++6 with ones built with the latest version, and the whole thing is going to work fine - the trick is that multiple versions of the runtime DLLs can coexist in the same process. GCC/libstdc++ hasn't changed its ABI in more than a decade, since release 3.3 or 3.4; they even did incompatible changes to std::string in GCC 5 without breaking ABI: https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2015/02/05/gcc5-and-the-c11-abi/ https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2015/02/05/gcc5-and-the-c...
- steveklabnik 9y agoGreat, thank you for the clarification.