3 ms·
Define child. 2 year old? 5 year old? I have three kids and I can tell you that they wouldn't be able to do this reliably until probably age 5, and even then m
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
Define child. 2 year old? 5 year old?
I have three kids and I can tell you that they wouldn't be able to do this reliably until probably age 5, and even then maybe.
- akud 9y agoMy 2 year old daughter could.
- mcv 9y agoWithout ever having seen one? Or with having seen pictures of one? It's true though that we can generalise from descriptions and recognise the real thing from those. If you describe an elephant as a big grey animal with big ears and a trunk they can use to grab stuff, then an adult (not a 2 year old I suspect) seeing one for the first time, will recognise it from that description. When we see a cartoonish drawing of one, we can still distill the defining characteristics from it and use it to create a description or recognise the real thing. We can recognise a very crude childish drawing of one by looking for these characteristics. We have a lot of additional knowledge that influences our image recognition, and having a big toolbox of general recognition of tons of different objects, we don't really need to train to recognise new objects anymore, because we will distill its identifying characteristics the first time we see it. Computers clearly don't look like that.
- Shorel 9y agoSome pattern recognition seems to be innate, for example chicks just hours old can recognize the shadow of a flying bird as either harmless (long neck short tail) or a predator (short neck long tail). So, while this pattern in particular doesn't apply to humans (it really doesn't?), many animals have ready-to-use pattern recognition when they are just hours or days old.
- mcv 9y agoThose are instincts bred by evolutionary because they're vital for survival. Recognising an elephant is not the same thing for us. Instead, we get a generic toolbox for quickly learning to recognise very different objects, from animals to machines to abstract shapes. We're not born being able to recognise them, but we can pick them up very quickly from even rough descriptions.
- Shorel 9y agoTrue, but if we are into exploring the possibilities of what can be done with artificial neural networks, I see no reason to limit our models to human brains only.
- mannykannot 9y agoIn what way would a precise definition advance this discussion? Especially as it has gone several steps without such a definition being an issue. Ironically, the problem that Dr. Hinton is attempting to solve could be characterized as being that ordinary CNNs have trouble learning what's most relevant in an image.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoThere is a massive difference between a 6 month old and a 10 year old and both would be considered children. In that time period all of the brain infrastructure to do single shot/transfer learning at speed is developed. So showing a 10 year old a picture of an elephant with relevant label could probably be learned in a single shot. Not so with a 1 year old.
- mannykannot 9y agoSorry, but the relevance of these facts to this discussion still escapes me. You have previously said that your 5-year-old could "probably"/"maybe" (from the same sentence!) reliably do this, which is comfortably within your 10-year bound. Even if only adults were capable of this, Dr. Hinton's observation, appropriately amended to reflect that fact, would still be pertinent.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoThe relevance is that human inference is built from exposure to billions of "samples" of audio, visual, tactile information and that the CNN's that he invented are only capturing the slightest smallest sample of that. Not even the equivalent of an embryo level of data and processing capability. People basically ignore that it takes humans YEARS of 24/7 training on ungodly amounts of data to be able to do anything close to reliable inference on even the most basic of tasks. That's the point.
- goatlover 9y agoSo why does Hinton think otherwise?
- seastonATccs 9y agoMost kids 3-5 can identify parts of animals they have never seen as long as there is an analog in their experience.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoNot just an "analog" - specific exposure to a variety of different animals. My 5 year old son was a monster at animal puzzles when he was 3, but we had thousands of hours with animal picture books, animal toys etc... from 4 months on.
- Piskvorrr 9y ago2+. A child I know only ever saw plush/Lego/picture elephants, yet on the first trip to the zoo, pointed at a live one and exclaimed triumphantly: "'phant!!!"
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoRight, and those exposures were probably good enough for several hundred thousand iterations of "training."
- icc97 9y agoPlus as the child walks around the elephant in the zoo there's a ton of information. Just one of the angles that the child sees has to match the 3D object that they've been picking up and moving around in their hands.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoCorrect. It's spatial intelligence.
- mannykannot 9y agoThis thread now contains a cycle. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15610149 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15610149