4 ms·
Capsules are Hinton's idea. His speech "What is Wrong With Convolutional Neural Nets?" was 2014 and he was already working with capsules. http://techtv.mit.edu
by nabla9 9y ago
Capsules are Hinton's idea. His speech "What is Wrong With Convolutional Neural Nets?" was 2014 and he was already working with capsules. http://techtv.mit.edu/collections/bcs/videos/30698-what-s-wrong-with-convolutional-nets http://techtv.mit.edu/collections/bcs/videos/30698-what-s-wr...
The credit from the paper should go to all researchers of course, but Hinton is main driving force behind the research.
- faitswulff 9y agoI'd say the first and second authors still warrant a mention, at least.
- dmix 9y agoThe article was updated to include the two other authors names. There is an update at the end of the article mentioning this.
- justicezyx 9y agoI would argue that ideas are cheap until they are proven correct, relatively, compared to the effort to proven them, in some cases, also to apply them into real world scenarios. I see the society give unproportionally large credit to the so-called "leaders", because they pioneered certain "ideas". That's wrong. Histories bury too many talented individuals who are not recognized, because of some pioneers are frantically sucked all the attentions the society can give. In professional research community, authors are listed because they are deemed a critical contributor to the work. Plain and simple.
- hatmatrix 9y agoOne might argue that any number of researchers could have performed the labor of testing the idea, whereas the originator of the idea itself is non-fungible.