4 ms·
I don't think I've ever seen any "flat tax" advocate actually advocate a flat tax. They always seem to actually do a progressive tax with two brackets, with the
by tzs 9y ago
I don't think I've ever seen any "flat tax" advocate actually advocate a flat tax. They always seem to actually do a progressive tax with two brackets, with the lower bracket being wide and having a rate of 0%. For example, Ted Cruz's flat tax proposal a couple years ago had a $36k 0% bracket, and Rand Paul's had a $50k 0% bracket.
NOTE: my referencing Cruz and Paul should in no way be taken as any endorsement or approval of their tax plans on my part. I just used them because they are fairly typical for recent flat tax proposals.
For a lot of people the main selling point of a flat tax is its supposed simplicity. They have fantasies of spending two minutes a year doing their taxes. I say "supposed simplicity" because many of these proposals still include numerous deductions and exclusions, and THAT is where 99.99% of the complexity of the tax system resides.
Once you have figured out your taxable income the actual computation of the tax is close to trivial under both the current system and the two bracket "flat" tax systems. All that changing from the former to the later does is shorten the Internal Revenue Code by about 5 lines.
If a flat tax proposal does actually eliminate all the deductions and exclusions, so that your taxable income really is trivial to compute, then it would greatly simplify doing your taxes--but that has nothing whatsoever to do with it being flat. Such a simplification works just as well for a tax with several progressive brackets.
- TheCoelacanth 9y ago> For a lot of people the main selling point of a flat tax is its supposed simplicity. They have fantasies of spending two minutes a year doing their taxes. I say "supposed simplicity" because many of these proposals still include numerous deductions and exclusions, and THAT is where 99.99% of the complexity of the tax system resides. Exactly, no matter how many tax brackets you have, without the miscellaneous deductions, calculating your total amount of tax to pay involves simply looking at a table of income ranges for a set of three numbers that applies to you and then doing the calculation top_marginal_tax_rate*(income - top_tax_bracket_lower_bound)+tax_on_income_in_lower_brackets. So the entire work to calculate your tax burden is one table lookup, one addition, one subtraction and one multiplication. The flat tax proposals simplify that by getting rid of the addition (by making tax_on_income_in_lower_brackets zero) and making the table lookup only contain two rows instead of many. So you have removed one arithmetic operation(or three if you are under the 0% bracket cutoff), and cut down on the number of rows you have to scan through by a single digit number. That is completely negligible to dozens of pages of reading you would have to do if you have even relatively simple deductions.